Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Phantasmagoria: Stagefright delivers a dual dose of interactive horror by combining the original Roberta Williams’ Phantasmagoria and its sequel, A Puzzle of Flesh. Both titles embrace the classic point-and-click adventure formula, but diverge in tone and mechanics. The first installment keeps you rooted in tense environmental puzzles and hidden-object hunts, while the sequel leans into inventory manipulation and branching dialogue paths to unravel a darker, more psychological narrative.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Switching between the two titles feels like sampling different horror subgenres. The seven-disc original forces you to explore every creaky floorboard and secret passage of the enigmatic estate, solving logic puzzles and unlocking new rooms. In contrast, the five-disc Puzzle of Flesh challenges you with more character-driven tasks—finding clues in mundane settings and piecing together your protagonist’s fractured memories. Together, they balance exploration and narrative depth.

Disc swapping is part of the charm (and occasionally the frustration) of Stagefright. With 12 discs in total, you’ll be pausing for CD-ROM changes several times per chapter. If you have a multi-drive setup or plan to emulate the collection, the interruptions become less intrusive. Regardless of technical setup, the gameplay remains immersive, drawing you deeper into its gruesome lore and complex puzzles.

Graphics

The visual presentation in Phantasmagoria: Stagefright is pure mid-’90s FMV extravaganza. The original seven discs boast higher-resolution scenes for Windows 3.1 or DOS, bringing grainy but atmospheric video to life on CRT monitors. You’ll witness real actors navigating gothic corridors, their performances punctuated by stark lighting and bold color contrasts that heighten each scare.

Puzzle of Flesh steps up the polish for Windows 95 or DOS environments, leveraging faster CD-ROM speeds and increased RAM to render sharper video sequences. The result is a noticeable jump in clarity during close-ups and story scenes. Although today’s gamers might find the resolution modest, the uncanny valley charm of full-motion video still delivers chills.

Between both titles, Stagefright showcases a variety of locations—from decaying mansions to sterile laboratories—each rendered through a mix of pre-filmed backdrops and live actors. While the graphics may feel dated by modern standards, they remain a fascinating window into the era’s multimedia ambitions. Collectors and horror aficionados will appreciate the authentic feel of pixelation and video artifacts as part of the overall ambiance.

Story

At its core, Phantasmagoria: Stagefright weaves two distinctive horror tales. In Roberta Williams’ original, you play Adrienne Carmichael, who stumbles into a house of unspeakable evil. As she uncovers the estate’s gruesome history, you’ll experience ghostly apparitions, shifting walls, and a malevolent force that grows increasingly personal. The narrative builds tension through environmental revelations and scripted jump scares.

Phantasmagoria: A Puzzle of Flesh shifts gears dramatically. You step into the shoes of Curtis Craig, a corporate researcher plagued by hallucinations and conspiracy. The plot explores body horror, corporate corruption, and the fragility of the human mind. Story branching and dialogue choices give you a sense of agency, though the overarching mood remains ominous and unsettling.

Stagefright’s anthology approach highlights how horror can evolve across two sequels. While the first game leans on supernatural dread and haunted-house tropes, the second delves into psychological terror and sci-fi grotesquery. Together, they deliver a well-rounded experience for genre fans who crave variety in their frights and a deeper look into ’90s adventure storytelling.

Overall Experience

Phantasmagoria: Stagefright is a collector’s delight, packing 12 discs of classic FMV horror into a single box. If you own the required hardware—Windows 3.1 or DOS 5.0+ with 8MB RAM and a 2× CD-ROM drive for the original, and Windows 95 or DOS 5.0+ with 12MB RAM and a 4× CD-ROM drive for the sequel—you’ll experience these games as they were meant to be played. Expect disc-change pauses, nostalgic loading times, and the memorable creaks and moans of early multimedia CDs.

The compilation offers tremendous value for both newcomers and longtime fans. You get two complete stories, spanning nearly ten hours of gameplay each, plus behind-the-scenes FMV sequences and a soundtrack that captures the eerie mood. Packaging up both titles under the “Stagefright” banner reminds players how ambitious mid-’90s PC horror could be.

For anyone intrigued by pioneering full-motion video adventures, Stagefright remains a must-have. Its blend of practical scares, inventive puzzles, and period-accurate graphics provides a unique time capsule of interactive horror. Pop in the discs, dim the lights, and prepare to rewind into the heart of 90s terror—if you dare.

Retro Replay Score

null/10