Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Elf Bowling 1&2 bundles two simple yet oddly addictive mini-games that rely on timing and a bit of accuracy rather than complex mechanics. In the first installment, Elf Bowling, you step into Santa’s boots, hurling a bowling ball down a snowy lane at mischievous elves. Your only tools are the directional cone that slides back and forth and a single button press—get the timing right and you’ll score strikes, but mistime it and the elves get away. The intuitive control scheme makes it instantly accessible to players of all ages, though the challenge of mastering the cone meter keeps you coming back for more.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Moving on to Elf Bowling 2 (also known as Elves in Paradise), the developers trade the bowling alley for a ship’s deck and swap pins for shuffleboard-style scoring zones. Each round begins with you positioning an elf on the deck using the D-pad, then gauging the perfect moment to launch with the A button as a light indicator sweeps across a target grid. The combination of precision and timing evokes the thrill of a classic carnival game, turning each shot into a mini puzzle of angles and power.

While neither game offers deep progression systems or multiplayer modes, they shine as lightweight time-killers. Short rounds mean you can play in quick bursts, whether you’re waiting for a meeting to start or looking to break a personal high score during a commute. The learning curve is minimal, so even casual players will feel rewarded by the first few rounds. However, those seeking elaborate challenges or competitive leaderboards may find the gameplay loop somewhat repetitive over extended sessions.

Graphics

The visuals in Elf Bowling 1&2 are lifted directly from their Flash-based origins, preserving the simple, cartoonish style that made the originals a viral hit. Both games feature bright primary colors, thick outlines, and exaggerated character designs—especially the elves with their oversized heads and goofy expressions. There’s a certain nostalgic charm in the low-resolution sprites and straightforward animations, though modern eyes accustomed to high-fidelity visuals may find them dated.

On the Nintendo DS, the dual screens are used effectively: gameplay elements reside on the bottom touchscreen while scoreboards, menus, and wacky elf reactions appear on the top. The transition from browser-based Flash to dedicated handheld hardware hasn’t altered the frame rate or sprite quality, which means you’ll see the same jerky elf celebrations and simple particle effects that made the browser versions both endearing and crude. For fans of retro Flash games, this is a faithful preservation; for newcomers, it reads as a deliberate throwback rather than a cutting-edge presentation.

Audio cues are equally minimalistic, consisting of basic jingles, crowd cheers, and comedic “oof” sounds when you miss. There’s no voice acting, and background music loops can grow repetitive quickly. That said, the sound design complements the visual style, leaning into the slapstick humor and keeping the mood light. If you’re after high production values, this title falls short, but if you appreciate indie-era Flash aesthetics, the unchanged graphics and audio feel right at home.

Story

Neither Elf Bowling nor Elves in Paradise offers a deep narrative, instead relying on a playful premise: Santa Claus taking out his holiday stress on a platoon of elves. The goal is never to humanize your targets; rather, the comedic absurdity of hurling elves like bowling pins or shuffleboard pucks drives the experience. It’s intentionally silly, and you won’t find cutscenes or plot twists—just round after round of elf-flinging fun.

Occasional on-screen captions and the elves’ cartoonish reactions inject a bit of personality into the proceedings. After a particularly successful strike or well-aimed shuffleboard shot, elves tumble in humorous ways—sometimes flying off-screen, sometimes bouncing repeatedly before coming to rest. These moments provide the game’s only narrative flavor, turning each mini-game session into a self-contained comedy sketch rather than part of an overarching storyline.

For players expecting a holiday-themed epic, the lack of character development or story depth may feel like a drawback. However, if you approach Elf Bowling 1&2 as a whimsical distraction—the kind of thing you share with friends for laughs—the thin narrative is part of the appeal. The games never take themselves seriously, and that tongue-in-cheek attitude is the closest thing to a “plot” you’ll find.

Overall Experience

Elf Bowling 1&2 is best described as a nostalgia trip wrapped in bite-sized gameplay. The compilation faithfully recreates the browser-original mechanics and visuals on the Nintendo DS, allowing longtime fans to revisit the viral hits without firing up a web browser. For new players, the games offer quick, uncomplicated fun that’s easy to pick up but challenging to master if you aim for high scores.

Longevity is where the package shows its limitations. After a few hours, the novelty of knocking down elves or sending them sliding into scoring zones can wear thin. There are no difficulty settings, extra modes, or unlockable content to extend replayability. What you see is what you get—pure, unadorned mini-games serving a single purpose: amusing you with elf-target practice.

In the end, Elf Bowling 1&2 succeeds as a lighthearted diversion rather than a deep or memorable gaming experience. If you have fond memories of the Flash originals or you enjoy simple, timing-based challenges, this compilation will bring a smile to your face. If you crave narrative depth, robust modes, or the latest graphical flourishes, you may feel that these elf-flinging antics belong more to computer nostalgia than modern handheld gaming. Either way, it’s a quirky entry in the DS library that caters to a very specific taste—festive, irreverent, and delightfully basic.

Retro Replay Score

4.4/10