Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Sherlock Holmes: The Awakened transitions the series into a fully real-time 3D environment, presenting the investigation from a first-person perspective. This shift enhances immersion, placing you directly in Holmes’s shoes as you scour Victorian London and eerie rural locales for clues. The game retains its classic point-and-click adventure roots, allowing players to interact with objects, examine evidence, and converse with suspects using a simple mouse-driven interface.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The puzzles in The Awakened are thoughtfully designed to challenge both your deductive reasoning and observational skills. From piecing together torn letters to reconstructing crime scenes from witness testimony, each mystery segment feels cohesive and thematically tied to the unfolding narrative. While some puzzles lean on trial-and-error, most reward careful note-taking and intelligent inference, staying true to the spirit of detective work.

Navigation feels more organic than in previous entries, thanks to free camera control and smooth movement. You can explore Holmes’s lodgings in Baker Street, trudge through misty docks, or investigate sprawling cult hideouts without jarring transitions. The developers strike a fine balance between guided storytelling and player autonomy, ensuring the game never feels overwhelmingly linear nor excessively open-ended.

Graphics

The move away from pre-rendered backdrops to fully rendered 3D environments marks a significant visual leap for Frogwares. Buildings, interiors, and NPCs are modeled in fine detail, lending the game a tangible sense of place. Dimly lit corridors, flickering lanterns, and the murky Thames all contribute to a brooding atmosphere that complements the Lovecraftian horror elements.

Character models for Sherlock Holmes, Dr. Watson, and key suspects display expressive facial animations, though occasional stiffness emerges during extended dialogue sequences. Still, the lighting and shadow work do much of the heavy lifting in conveying mood. Rain-slicked cobblestones and smoke-choked alleyways feel convincingly oppressive, especially during nighttime investigations.

Performance remains generally stable even in graphically intensive scenes, though aging textures and lower-resolution assets can surface on higher-end displays. Overall, The Awakened’s aesthetic successfully bridges the gap between classic adventure charm and modern graphical expectations. The environments not only look good—they actively reinforce the suspense and dread that drive the narrative forward.

Story

At the heart of The Awakened lies an unsettling narrative that blends Victorian detective intrigue with eldritch horror. Sherlock Holmes and Dr. John H. Watson follow a trail of disappearances that gradually reveals ties to a clandestine Cthulhu-worshiping cult. Thematic tension builds as familiar detective tropes collide with cosmic dread, keeping players on edge throughout the journey.

The writing cleverly balances Holmes’s razor-sharp logic with the creeping irrationality of ancient cult rituals. Dialogue exchanges feel authentic to Conan Doyle’s era, with Watson’s earnest curiosity often contrasting Holmes’s cool detachment. Secondary characters—from dubious street preachers to fearful magistrates—are well-voiced and supply crucial breadcrumbs without feeling overly expository.

Pacing is a standout strength: early chapters focus on methodical clue-gathering, while later segments accelerate into heart-pounding escapes and unsettling revelations. The finale merges deductive triumph with chilling ambiguity, leaving players pondering the boundary between empirical science and unfathomable mythos. For fans of both Sherlock Holmes and Lovecraftian lore, this fusion yields an engaging and memorable tale.

Overall Experience

Sherlock Holmes: The Awakened represents a daring evolution for Frogwares, successfully marrying classic point-and-click mechanics with modern first-person exploration. The result is an adventure that feels both familiar and refreshingly new, appealing to longtime series devotees and newcomers alike. Its accessible control scheme allows for intuitive gameplay, whether you’re a puzzle enthusiast or a seasoned detective gamer.

Immersion remains the game’s hallmark: detailed environments, atmospheric sound design, and a haunting score work in concert to build tension. While occasional technical quirks and dated assets remind players of the game’s age, they rarely detract from the overall experience. Most importantly, the blend of deduction, exploration, and cosmic horror delivers a compelling package that sustains interest from start to finish.

For potential buyers seeking a rich narrative, well-crafted puzzles, and an immersive setting, Sherlock Holmes: The Awakened is a standout choice. It may not boast cutting-edge visuals by today’s blockbuster standards, but its strong storytelling and innovative gameplay design ensure lasting appeal. Dive into Holmes’s world, confront ancient evils, and prepare for an investigative journey you won’t soon forget.

Retro Replay Score

7/10