Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

The core of Sherlock Holmes in “Another Bow” is a classic interactive fiction engine that places you directly in Dr. Watson’s shoes. Players type commands to question suspects, inspect clues, and navigate the cramped corridors of the S.S. Destiny. This text-driven approach demands attention to detail and rewards careful note-taking as you piece together each clue.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

With six smaller cases woven into the larger mystery, the gameplay feels almost episodic. Each mini-case introduces new puzzles—ranging from decoding cryptic notes to tailing suspects without being spotted—and contributes to the final revelation. The time-limit mechanic adds urgency: dilly-dally too long and you might miss critical evidence, forcing you to prioritize investigations wisely.

One of the most compelling twists is Holmes’s advanced age and diminishing eyesight. Rather than wield the detective’s genius directly, you guide Watson as the active investigator. This subtle shift in agency not only deepens immersion but also introduces an element of risk: ordering Watson (and Holmes) to act brashly can jeopardize Holmes’s reputation and end the game prematurely.

Graphics

Being a product of the early Living Literature series, “Another Bow” relies almost entirely on evocative prose rather than lavish visuals. There are no scrolling 3D environments or animated cutscenes—just richly detailed descriptions that paint the foggy decks and shadowy lounges of the S.S. Destiny in your mind. For modern players, this retro minimalism may feel sparse, but fans of text adventures will find the atmosphere richly textured.

Occasional static illustrations accompany major story beats: a small black-and-white sketch of the victim’s cabin, a line drawing of Houdini mid-escape, or a stylized portrait of Pablo Picasso at his easel. These images serve as visual punctuation, heightening the sense of period authenticity without overshadowing the narrative focus. If you’re looking for high-res textures, you won’t find them here—but the artful simplicity is part of the game’s undeniable charm.

Sound design is similarly minimalist—an echo of a ship’s horn or a soft creaking floorboard appears sparingly, if at all, depending on your platform. What you lose in atmospheric audio is more than compensated by the strength of the writing. The game trusts your imagination to fill in the gaps, creating a personalized tableau that no pre-rendered environment could fully replicate.

Story

The narrative thrust of “Another Bow” is a brand-new mystery set aboard the luxurious steamship S.S. Destiny. When a crewman awakens Holmes and Watson to what appears to be a suicide, the pair quickly realize something darker lies beneath the surface. From the first typed command, you’re drawn into a layered plot that balances red herrings, hidden motives, and period intrigue.

What truly sets the story apart are the real-world figures peppered throughout your investigation. Houdini, Gertrude Stein, Lawrence of Arabia, Picasso, Edison—each cameo feels organic, as though historical titans have casually booked passage on this ill-fated voyage. Interactions with these luminaries not only enliven the dialogue but also present unique mini-cases that test your investigative mettle.

At its heart, the story explores the tension between youth and age, brilliance and fallibility. An aging Holmes contends with lapses in memory, forcing Watson (and by extension, the player) to shoulder much of the legwork. By the time you unearth the final clues, the narrative payoff resonates emotionally: it’s not just about solving a murder, but about preserving a legacy.

Overall Experience

Sherlock Holmes in “Another Bow” stands as a testament to the power of interactive fiction at its best. The game’s text-only interface may feel antiquated to some, but it remains endlessly replayable—each playthrough inviting you to explore different suspects, sequence clues in new ways, and uncover hidden details you missed before. Patience and thoroughness are richly rewarded.

If you’re a Sherlock Holmes aficionado or a devotee of classic adventure games, this title offers a unique blend of historical flair and cerebral challenge. The time-sensitive structure keeps the tension high, and the interplay with iconic personalities adds an unexpected layer of delight. While newcomers to text adventures may face a learning curve, the sense of accomplishment upon solving each case is well worth the effort.

Ultimately, “Another Bow” may not boast cutting-edge graphics or voice acting, but its strength lies in an engaging mystery that harnesses the full power of imagination. Whether you’re charting the ship’s promenade under moonlight or decoding a suspect’s alibi in your mind’s eye, this interactive journey captures the essence of Holmes and Watson’s legendary partnership. It’s a must-play for anyone who craves a thoughtful, text-driven detective experience.

Retro Replay Score

null/10