Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

All-Star Baseball 2000 refines the core mechanics of its predecessor to deliver an immersive baseball simulation. Motion-captured animations give each swing, pitch, and catch a fluid naturalism that translates directly into responsive on-field controls. Whether you’re stepping into the batter’s box against a 95 mph fastball or fielding a hot grounder up the middle, the timing window feels razor-sharp and gratifying when you connect.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Beyond the standard exhibition and playoff modes, ASB 2000’s expanded roster management is a standout feature. You can now sign rising talent from the minor leagues or even craft entirely new players, assigning them custom attributes and play styles. This depth of customization encourages experimentation—build a power-hitting first baseman, a fireball-throwing reliever, or a speedy pinch-runner, then watch them grow through each full season.

The inclusion of both a full 162-game inter-league season and the complete 1999 MLB schedule adds impressive replay value. Jump right into rivalry matchups or grind through a realistic pennant chase. For those wanting a rapid thrill, you can simulate games in seconds; for purists, playing out every inning and adjusting your lineup on the fly makes for hours of strategic fun.

Graphics

Graphically, All-Star Baseball 2000 takes a considerable leap forward. The motion-capture technology not only enhances gameplay but also underpins character models that move and react like their real-life counterparts. From the subtle head-tilt of a batter sizing up a curveball to the fluid stretch of an outfielder diving at the wall, each animation is executed with polish.

Licensing the full 30 MLB teams means you’ll recognize every uniform, stadium landmark, and even the players’ facial features. Ballparks such as Fenway Park’s Green Monster and the ivy at Wrigley Field are faithfully rendered, giving each contest a distinct atmosphere. Crowd animations and dynamic lighting during day-to-night transitions further immerse you in the ballpark experience.

Your hardware setup can enhance visuals dramatically. By loading the Expansion Pak on Nintendo 64, replays become longer and more detailed, offering multiple camera angles to savor highlight-reel catches. Textures pop with extra clarity, making the grass look greener and the stadium signage crisper than ever before for an N64 title.

Story

As with most sports simulations, All-Star Baseball 2000 lacks a traditional narrative, yet it excels at crafting its own “story” through the season modes. Every game feels like a chapter in your franchise’s journey—one swinging bunt, one bullpen collapse, one walk-off home run away from rewriting the standings. Tracking player progress, injuries, and hot streaks lends a dramatic arc that unfolds across the calendar.

Creating custom players further personalizes your narrative. You can imagine the backstory of a rookie sensation rising from Double-A stardom, or a veteran slugger attempting one final World Series run. Watching your personally designed prospect bat in the big leagues transforms dry stat lines into compelling, emotional moments that mimic the highs and lows of real-world baseball.

The atmosphere created by dynamic in-game commentary and crowd reactions ties it all together. Even without a scripted storyline, the ebb and flow of each series stoke rivalries and heighten tension. Whether you’re chasing a division title or battling for a Wild Card spot, the arc of the season feels authentic and engaging from first pitch to last.

Overall Experience

All-Star Baseball 2000 is a triumphant follow-up to ’99, packing meaningful enhancements that appeal to both casual fans and hardcore baseball enthusiasts. The combination of lifelike animations, robust team licensing, and expanded management options makes it one of the deepest baseball sims of its era. Jumping into a single game is fun; committing to a full season is even more rewarding.

While the game’s complexity can be daunting at first—roster trades, minor-league call-ups, and lineup tinkering all demand attention—tutorials and intuitive menus smooth the learning curve. Quick-play settings also let newcomers enjoy the on-field action without getting bogged down in front-office minutiae.

Overall, All-Star Baseball 2000 strikes a rare balance between arcade accessibility and simulation depth. It celebrates the nuances of the sport while offering customizable options to suit your style of play. For anyone looking to experience the excitement of America’s pastime on a console, this title remains a compelling choice.

Retro Replay Score

8.2/10