Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

All-Star Baseball 99 delivers a robust and varied gameplay experience that will satisfy both casual players and hardcore baseball enthusiasts. With modes that range from quick Training sessions to full-fledged Season and World Series campaigns, Acclaim has packed this title with enough content to keep you busy for dozens of hours. The inclusion of specialty modes like the Home Run Derby, All-Star Match, and MLB trivia rounds out the package for those seeking a break from conventional play.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

One of the standout features is the depth of the batting and fielding controls. The game boasts 100 different batting styles, letting you tailor the swing mechanics to fit your own comfort level—whether you prefer a power-hitting uppercut or a contact-oriented level swing. Fielding is equally satisfying: sliding catches, base collisions, kneeling throws and even broken-bat animations infuse every inning with drama and realism. You’ll need quick reflexes and strategic positioning to turn double plays or rob home runs at the warning track.

For those who love team management, the Season and Playoff modes provide a complete front-office experience. You can release, sign, and trade players from the entire 700-player roster—including minor leaguers—so you can craft your own dynasty. The “Create a Player” option adds even more customization, letting you inject fresh talent into the league if you can’t find exactly what you want. The three skill levels ensure that both novices and veterans can find an appropriate challenge.

Graphics

Visually, All-Star Baseball 99 holds up impressively well for its era. The polygonal stadiums are richly detailed, and each of the 30 Major League ballparks is faithfully recreated, complete with team logos and distinctive outfield dimensions. From the green expanse of Fenway Park’s “Green Monster” to the cavernous feel of Tiger Stadium, you genuinely get a sense of stepping into the real ballparks.

Player models exhibit smooth animations, particularly during key plays. Sliding tackles, diving catches, and dynamic base collisions are handled with surprising fluidity. The broken-bat effects and midair player flinches add a layer of authenticity, reminding you why baseball is called America’s pastime. Even the crowd animations and scoreboard details contribute to the lively ballpark atmosphere.

While some textures may appear a bit flat by modern standards, the game’s color palette and lighting work in harmony to produce a bright, inviting look. Night games are especially striking, with the infield floodlights casting realistic shadows. Overall, the graphics serve the gameplay beautifully, ensuring that every swing, sprint, and sent-over-the-fence blast feels impactful.

Story

Strictly speaking, All-Star Baseball 99 does not feature a linear story mode like a role-playing game—but that doesn’t mean there’s no narrative tension. Each Season or World Series push becomes its own story, shaped by your trades, breakout rookies, and come-from-behind victories. The game effectively turns you into the protagonist of your own baseball drama.

Between innings, the league standings and statistical updates build suspense in much the same way that a serialized TV show might. Will your ace pitcher remain unhittable during the pennant race? Can you discover the next hidden gem in your minor league system before a rival snaps him up? These unfolding subplots give your managerial decisions real weight and emotional payoff.

Even the Home Run Derby and All-Star Match inject a fun, event-like feel that deepens immersion. Though there’s no cutscene-driven storyline, the game’s structure and rich scoreboard presentation craft an engaging narrative arc that plays out inning by inning. By the time you reach the World Series, your team’s journey feels personal—an accomplishment you’ve earned through a succession of well-timed hits and savvy roster moves.

Overall Experience

All-Star Baseball 99 stands as a testament to the depth and replayability that sports simulations can achieve. From the moment you step into Training mode to fine-tune your swing, through the highs and lows of a full season, the game keeps you invested by offering meaningful choices at every turn. Whether you’re calling the shots in franchise mode or going toe-to-toe in an All-Star showdown, the balance between accessibility and depth is expertly maintained.

The commentary by John Sterling and Michael Kaye adds a professional touch, calling plays with enthusiasm and lending an authentic broadcast feel. Their voiceovers strike a fine line between informative and entertaining, making each home run call or double-play turn feel like a national-television moment.

For potential buyers in 1999, this title represents one of the most complete baseball experiences on the market. Its comprehensive modes, detailed ballparks, lifelike animations, and deep management options make it a worthy addition to any sports gaming library. Even decades later, All-Star Baseball 99’s blend of arcade-style fun and simulation depth ensures it remains a standout entry in the genre.

Retro Replay Score

7.6/10