Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Cat and Mouse, Football, Haunted House arrives on the Magnavox Odyssey’s Game Card #4 as a trio of very different multiplayer experiences. Each title shares the same hardware foundation, yet delivers unique challenges—from calculated pursuit to strategic play-calling to deduction under pressure. Your enjoyment will hinge on whether you’re looking for a quick cat-and-mouse maze chase, a rudimentary but charming take on American football, or a tense hiding-and-seeking adventure with supernatural overtones.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

In Cat and Mouse, two players alternate roles in a simple maze rendered as solid blocks on screen. One player guides the Mouse toward its “home” zone while the other maneuvers the Cat to intercept. Movement is turn-based, requiring you to think two moves ahead to anticipate your opponent’s path. Though the maze layout is fixed and collisions are determined by overlapping screen tiles rather than pixel-perfect accuracy, the back-and-forth duels can become surprisingly engrossing as risk-reward calculations intensify.

Football stands out as one of the earliest home-console implementations of American football. Using a set of 16 deck cards provided alongside the cartridge, you select Run, Pass or Kick plays off-screen, then watch a minimalist onscreen representation unfold. Passing and kicking maneuvers require insertion of game card #3 to unlock additional play-animation routines. While the action is abstract—conical player markers and simple line-field graphics—it captures the essence of play selection, play execution, and the unpredictable bounce of luck in a tightly contested drive.

Finally, Haunted House offers an early asymmetrical multiplayer twist: one player becomes the detective, racing through a series of rooms to gather Clue cards and locate hidden treasure before time runs out, while the other takes the role of a ghost striving to impede every step. The detective’s hunt involves mapping a rudimentary mansion floor plan, interpreting which rooms hold valuable clues. The ghost toggles between visible and invisible states, blocking corridors or sending the detective back to the start. Although the mansion’s layout remains static, the suspense of near-captures and the limited information on screen create genuine tension.

Graphics

All three titles rely on the Odyssey’s signature monochrome overlays and blocky sprites. In Cat and Mouse, walls appear as thick colored borders (via an overlay), and the Cat and Mouse are represented by solid squares that toggle on and off. There’s no animation per se—only positional shifts—but the clarity of the maze layout ensures you never lose track of your quarry.

Football employs a simplified gridiron with segmented lines indicating yard markers. Players manifest as small rectangular blocks that shift vertically and horizontally; movement is jerky by modern standards, but understandable given the technology. When a “pass” play succeeds, a second blob appears momentarily to represent the ball traveling, then merges with the receiver. The absence of player sprites or detailed motion is offset by the thrill of seeing your chosen strategy “play out” in real time.

The visual approach in Haunted House is more atmospheric. Rooms are demarcated by contrasting colored squares. The detective’s token blinks gently as it moves, and the ghost occasionally appears as a flickering shape. Darkness is simulated by blanking out non-occupied rooms. Although there’s no detailed artwork—just rectangles and on/off signals—the novelty of exploring “dark corridors” and evading a blinking specter generates a surprisingly immersive experience.

Across all three games, the Odyssey’s graphics remain faithful to the console’s pioneering era: stripped-down, conceptual, and reliant on players’ imaginations to fill in gaps. If you appreciate retro minimalism and can lean into the abstraction, these visuals hold a certain charm.

Story

Storytelling in this compilation is minimal and functional, serving more to frame objectives than to develop characters. In Cat and Mouse, there’s no backstory beyond the namesake chase, yet the premise is intuitive: outrun or outthink your opponent. The lack of narrative depth keeps matches focused squarely on the tactical puzzle of maze navigation.

Football doesn’t attempt a dramatic narrative; it simply borrows the familiar language of downs, yards, and touchdowns. The “story” emerges from your own play decisions—a trick play gone awry or a game-winning kick feels significant precisely because it’s the product of your strategy. Enthusiasts of the sport may appreciate seeing the core mechanics distilled into early-era pixels.

Haunted House offers the loftiest narrative veneer: a spooky mansion filled with hidden treasures and ghostly interference. The detective’s hunt for Clue cards and a final prize provides a clear goal, while the ghost’s role in creating jump-scares adds a playful tension. Though there are no cutscenes or dialogue, the mental image of skulking through a dimly lit estate is effective, especially when played with friends who relish a bit of theatrical flair.

Overall Experience

Cat and Mouse, Football, Haunted House on Odyssey Game Card #4 is a testament to early console innovation, delivering three distinct multiplayer experiences with nothing more than on/off pixels, overlays, and a deck of cards. If you seek fast-paced, competitive two-player fun, this package overdelivers on variety for its vintage era.

Each game rewards different skills: strategic foresight in Cat and Mouse, play-calling savvy in Football, and spatial reasoning plus psychological bluffing in Haunted House. The requirement to swap decks for certain Football plays adds a tactile, tabletop feel that many modern titles lack, bridging the gap between card game and video game.

Reliant on imagination as much as on visual fidelity, this trio captures the spirit of family-room gaming circa 1978. It’s best enjoyed with an opponent in the same room, sharing laughter at a near-missed maze turn, groans over a botched pass, or the delight of a detective narrowly escaping a ghostly trap. For collectors and retro enthusiasts, it’s a charming slice of gaming history that still offers genuine entertainment today.

Whether you’re curious about the origins of football videogame adaptations, nostalgic for primitive multiplayer mazes, or simply eager for a playful haunted-house showdown, Odyssey Game Card #4 provides enduring appeal—proof that engaging gameplay doesn’t require high-definition graphics or complex narratives.

Retro Replay Score

null/10