Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

NHL FaceOff ’99 delivers a robust on-ice experience that veterans of the series and newcomers alike will appreciate. From the drop of the puck, you’ll notice how responsive the controls feel—skating is fluid, passing is precise, and shots come off your stick with satisfying weight. Whether you’re deking around defenders in the offensive zone or hammering out a big hit along the boards, the game strikes a fine balance between arcade-style fun and simulation authenticity.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

One of the standout features is the comprehensive roster management. You can trade and release players, create your own custom skaters, and sign free agents to reshape your lineup. This level of depth ensures that every franchise you manage can develop its own identity. You’ll find yourself poring over stat sheets and scouting reports, seeking the next breakout star or balancing your cap space to assemble a championship contender.

For multiplayer enthusiasts, NHL FaceOff ’99 shines brightly. Supporting up to eight human players via the PlayStation multitap, this title transforms any living room into a virtual rink. You can team up with friends in co-op play or square off in heated rivalries, rotating through the five available camera angles to keep everyone engaged. The variety of viewing perspectives not only adds replay value but also gives you strategic insights, whether you’re watching from the blue line or a classic overhead view.

Graphics

Graphically, NHL FaceOff ’99 represents a significant step forward for its era. Player models are well-defined, with distinctive jerseys that capture the look and feel of every NHL franchise, including the latest expansion teams. Ice surfaces reflect arena lighting convincingly, and the shadowing under skates provides a subtle but effective sense of depth. Even in the midst of a fast break, the action remains clear and easy to follow.

The game’s five camera angles are more than just a gimmick—they offer practical advantages and aesthetic variety. If you prefer a television-broadcast style, choose a dynamic sideline angle; if you want the strategic overview, the overhead or blue line views give you a playmaker’s eye on every passing lane. Each angle stays smooth and consistent, without noticeable frame drops, even during the most chaotic scrums in front of the net.

Arenas feel alive thanks to animated crowds and realistic rink boards that show scuffs and marks from previous checks. Player animations are fluid, especially when executing signature moves like spin-o-ramas and slapshots. While modern gamers might find textures a bit dated, at the time of its release, NHL FaceOff ’99 pushed the PlayStation hardware to its limits, resulting in a visually compelling package that still holds nostalgic appeal.

Story

As a sports simulation, NHL FaceOff ’99 doesn’t offer a traditional narrative campaign, but it does provide plenty of context and progression through its season and franchise modes. You’ll step into the shoes of a general manager, making roster decisions that impact your team’s destiny. From mid-season trades to rookie call-ups, your off-ice strategy becomes the backbone of your on-ice success.

The create-a-player feature adds a personal touch, allowing you to craft an underdog rookie with unique attributes, then guide them from scrappy newcomer to superstar status. Watching your custom player rack up points, earn All-Star selections, or lift the Stanley Cup adds an emotional throughline that many sports titles lack. Your created skater’s journey becomes a story worth following, even without cutscenes or voiced dialogue.

Although there’s no cinematic storyline, the ebb and flow of a full 82-game season generates its own drama. Rivalries intensify, playoff races come down to the last weekend, and every hat trick or game-winning save feels earned. The lack of a scripted story actually empowers you to craft your own hockey lore, as you record memorable moments and forge rivalries that will keep you coming back year after year.

Overall Experience

NHL FaceOff ’99 stands out as one of the finest hockey simulations on the PlayStation, offering a blend of deep management options, exciting on-ice action, and robust multiplayer support. Whether you’re striving to build a dynasty in franchise mode or simply looking for some pick-up-and-play fun with friends, this game delivers on all fronts. The learning curve is approachable, yet there’s enough nuance to satisfy hardcore hockey fans.

While modern titles have surpassed it in raw graphical fidelity and online connectivity, NHL FaceOff ’99 retains a timeless charm. The breadth of features—the full NHL license, expansion teams, player creation, free agency, and multiple camera angles—means you’re getting a complete package that still feels fresh today. Its multiplayer offerings, in particular, make it a must-have for anyone who loves couch competition.

In the crowded marketplace of sports games, NHL FaceOff ’99 carved out a winning formula that balances depth, accessibility, and authenticity. It’s an engaging experience from the first puck drop to the final buzzer, and its robust suite of modes ensures that no two seasons ever play out the same way. For hockey fans looking to relive late-’90s console glory or newcomers eager for classic gameplay, this title remains a standout choice.

Retro Replay Score

6.8/10