Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Poy Poy 2 picks up the frantic, item-driven chaos of its predecessor and refines it into an addictive four-player skirmish. The core loop is simple: grab rocks, bombs, logs and a host of interactive objects from the arena and hurl them at your opponents before the 90-second timer expires. Precision and timing are key—knowing when to toss a spinning stump or unleash a bouncing bomb can turn the tide of a match in the blink of an eye.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

What sets Poy Poy 2 apart is its collection of psycho-gloves, each granting a unique special ability. Whether you prefer the telekinetic lift of the Tele-Glue glove or the close-range shockwave of the Thunderstorm glove, there’s a playstyle to suit every competitor. These gloves are earned and upgraded as you progress, adding a satisfying layer of depth to the otherwise straightforward brawls.

Beyond the frantic multiplayer bouts, the game features a solo Challenge mode that lets you unlock new arenas, gloves and characters. While the human-versus-human matches remain the heart and soul of the experience, the Challenge mode offers a respectable training ground. It gradually introduces tougher AI foes and varied objectives, keeping solo players engaged between couch-minigame sessions.

Graphics

Poy Poy 2’s visual design is a colorful, cartoon-inspired feast that holds up even against later-generation titles. Character models are chunky and expressive, with exaggerated animations that highlight each glove’s unique power. Watching an opponent soar skyward on a rocket-powered glove never gets old, thanks to the crisp sprite work and fluid frame rates.

The arenas are equally varied and vibrant, ranging from sun-drenched beaches to ancient temples dripping with vines. Interactive elements—like rolling barrels, spiked fences or erupting geysers—are clearly distinct, ensuring you always know when danger is imminent. The top-down camera angle offers an unobstructed view of the action, even when the screen is swarmed by bouncing explosives or tumbling logs.

While Poy Poy 2 doesn’t push texture fidelity, it compensates with charming art direction and a lively color palette. Particle effects for ice shards, fireball explosions and electric sparks are sharp and satisfying, reinforcing each impact’s weight. In local multiplayer, the split-screen remains smooth and responsive, with no noticeable slowdowns even in the heat of four-player mayhem.

Story

Poy Poy 2 keeps narrative lean, focusing more on fast-paced gameplay than elaborate plot twists. You assume the roles of charismatic fighters memorialized as “Poy Poyers,” each with their own backstory snippets and glove preferences. While there’s no sprawling storyline, the character bios add just enough personality to make every match feel like a competition for more than just points.

The single-player Challenge mode frames each bout as part of a larger tournament, complete with rivalries and unlockable rivals. Though these story beats are brief—often delivered through static portraits and quippy one-liners—they inject a sense of progression and stakes into otherwise mechanical battles. You’ll find yourself curious about which glove you’ll earn next or which rival will stand in your way.

By design, the narrative never overshadows the gameplay. Poy Poy 2 is more of a party game than a role-playing epic, and its story elements exist to complement the action. If you’re looking for a title driven by character development or dramatic twists, you may find the plot skeletal. But as a framework to support the arcade-style fun, it works perfectly.

Overall Experience

Poy Poy 2 is, at its core, a brilliantly balanced party brawler that thrives on local multiplayer mayhem. Few games capture the spontaneous joy of couch competition quite like this one. Gathering friends for a quick 90-second match, only to have it snowball into a half-hour marathon of epic throws and narrow escapes, creates stories you’ll retell for years.

The longevity comes from the combination of unlockable gloves, diverse arenas and the unpredictable nature of four-player chaos. Even after mastering every glove’s special move, the dynamic interactions—bouncing objects off walls, snagging lucky hearts to boost your score, dodging surprise traps—keep the action fresh. It’s the kind of experience that rewards repeat play as you continually refine your strategies.

For potential buyers, Poy Poy 2 offers a perfect blend of accessibility and depth. Newcomers will appreciate the straightforward controls and pick-up-and-play design, while seasoned competitors can chase leaderboard supremacy by honing glove combos and arena tactics. If you own a PlayStation and seek a timeless party title to share with friends, Poy Poy 2 remains a must-have classic.

Retro Replay Score

6.9/10