Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Triple Play 2000 delivers a robust baseball simulation that caters to both casual players and die-hard fans. With real players and up-to-date team rosters at the time of release, every swing, steal, and pitch feels rooted in the authentic Major League Baseball experience. Whether you opt for a quick single match or commit to a full 162-game season, the game’s depth ensures that each contest offers fresh challenges and moments of triumph.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The inclusion of multiple modes—full season, playoffs, and a high-octane Home Run Derby—gives players the freedom to craft their own baseball journey. Team selection and player transfers fall directly under your control, allowing you to rebuild underperforming squads or bolster championship contenders through trades and free agency. This level of managerial input adds a strategic layer that complements the on-field action.

On the PC, Triple Play 2000 marks its first foray into Internet play, opening the door to head-to-head matchups with friends or rivals around the globe. The online implementation is straightforward, with match setup and matchmaking handled through a simple interface. Despite occasional lag depending on your connection, the thrill of facing a human opponent brings a fresh dynamic that magnifies the replay value.

Graphics

For its era, Triple Play 2000 presents a remarkably detailed visual package, capturing the unique feel of each Major League ballpark. Player models are well-proportioned, complete with accurate uniforms, equipment, and signature batting stances. From the lush outfields to the painted baselines, the stadiums are lovingly rendered, and the crowd animations help sell the atmosphere of a packed house.

Animations during gameplay are fluid, with smooth transitions between fielding, pitching, and batting. Swing mechanics, diving catches, and pitcher windups all exhibit a level of polish that contributes to the simulation’s immersive quality. Lighting effects—like the glare off the pitcher’s mound under stadium lights—add a realistic sheen that few sports titles of the time could match.

While the graphics engine occasionally shows its age in the form of polygonal edges or clipping during close-up replays, these moments are rare and never detract significantly from the overall presentation. The camera angles are adjustable, giving you everything from a broadcast-style view to a more intimate “behind the pitcher” perspective. Replay controls allow you to analyze every play in detail, complete with instant replays and slow-motion options.

Story

As a sports simulation, Triple Play 2000 doesn’t follow a traditional narrative, but it crafts its own stories through the ebb and flow of a season. Each game becomes a chapter in your team’s quest for the pennant, and the hits, errors, and comeback victories write an unfolding drama that keeps you invested. The ability to control trades and lineups furthers this narrative, as you shape your franchise’s destiny through strategic decisions both on and off the field.

Commentary by Jim Hughson and Buck Martinez injects personality into each matchup, providing play-by-play calls that feel authentic and timely. Their banter and insights help contextualize big moments—whether it’s a game-winning home run or a bases-loaded full count. Although the commentary can repeat after long hours of play, it nonetheless elevates the presentation by simulating a live broadcast.

The unofficial “story” mode emerges when you dive into a Home Run Derby or playoff bracket, pitting your sluggers against rival hitters in win-or-go-home scenarios. These one-off events create memorable highlights, like crushing a walk-off shot over the right-field wall or striking out an all-star batter in the series-clinching game. Through these milestones, players craft personal narratives that endure long after the controller is set aside.

Overall Experience

Triple Play 2000 stands as a landmark release in EA’s baseball lineage, combining authentic MLB presentation with deep gameplay options. The breadth of content—from full seasons and playoff runs to an action-packed Home Run Derby—ensures that boredom is never an option. Whether you’re looking to manage a dynasty or simply challenge a friend to an internet showdown, the game has you covered.

The user interface is intuitive, making team management and matchmaking an effortless affair. Loading times on modern PCs of the day were impressively brief, allowing you to jump straight into the action without long waits. Offline play runs smoothly, and online lobbies, though rudimentary by today’s standards, still deliver a satisfying multiplayer experience.

While minor graphical hiccups and occasional commentary repetition can surface over extended play sessions, these faults are easily overshadowed by the game’s strengths. From the thrill of hitting a game-winning homer to the satisfaction of engineering a last-minute trade, Triple Play 2000 offers an engaging, comprehensive baseball experience. For fans seeking a true-to-life simulation with plenty of modes and online potential, this iteration remains a standout pick in the annals of baseball gaming.

Retro Replay Score

7.7/10