Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

The Sporting News Baseball offers a variety of play options that cater to both casual hitters and dedicated ballplayers. With exhibition games for quick pickups, a Home Run Derby for power hitters, and a full pennant race for those looking to tackle a season-long challenge, there’s a mode to suit almost every taste. The All-Star Game mode brings together the era’s top talent—thanks to the MLBPA license—so you can see Ken Griffey Jr., Daryl Strawberry, and John Smoltz square off in one unforgettable showcase.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Controls are straightforward yet flexible, with separate buttons assigned for power swings, bunt attempts, and defensive plays. Pitchers can choose from a handful of pitch types—fastball, curve, slider—and even adjust pitch speed on the fly. At the plate, timing and swing type matter, and mastering the sweet spot on the bat is key to sending balls soaring out of the park or placing line drives into gaps. The inclusion of automatic fielding assists alongside manual mode ensures beginners can dive in without being overwhelmed, while purists can turn off all aids for maximum challenge.

Under the hood, the AI adapts to your playstyle over the course of a pennant race, adjusting defensive positioning and pitch selection based on your tendencies. That sense of progression keeps season play fresh, as you learn to outthink computerized managers trying to shut you down. While the lack of a full Major League license means teams go by city names rather than official club brands, the tight mechanics and roster accuracy more than make up for it—after all, who wouldn’t want to build a lineup featuring Griffey Jr. alongside other 1990s stars?

Graphics

Visually, The Sporting News Baseball strikes a balance between clarity and nostalgia. Player sprites are chunky and easily distinguishable on the diamond, with simplistic but effective animations for running, diving, and throwing. Batting stances for the big names capture a hint of each star’s real-world style, and the game’s color palette ensures the green of the outfield and the brown of the infield dirt pop on screen.

The game features just three playable stadiums—two generic parks with slight cosmetic tweaks and the iconic Field of Dreams ballfield lifted straight from the movie set. The latter adds a cinematic backdrop of cornfields and moonlit skies, offering a unique nighttime atmosphere. While the generic stadiums lack distinct personality, they do provide the necessary space dimensions and crowd animations to make every home run or diving catch feel satisfying.

User interface elements, such as the scoreboard graphic and on-screen pitch meter, are clean and unobtrusive. Pitch selection menus present clear icons for each pitch type, and pop-up indicators let you know when you’ve executed a perfect swing or reached optimal pitch speed. Though the overall visual package won’t rival modern polygonal baseball titles, it delivers a charming retro aesthetic that reinforces the game’s nostalgic appeal.

Story

As a sports simulation, The Sporting News Baseball doesn’t follow a scripted narrative in the traditional sense, but it crafts its own stories through gameplay. Building a pennant race campaign around a roster loaded with Ken Griffey Jr., Daryl Strawberry, and John Smoltz naturally sets up rivalries, clutch moments, and highlight-reel plays. In each new season, you write your own baseball epic, steering your team from Opening Day to the championship.

Modes like the Home Run Derby and All-Star Game inject additional drama, pitting you against CPU challengers in quick bursts of high-stakes action. Imagine facing off with Strawberry in the finals of the Derby, or pitching to Griffey Jr. with the roof (or cornfield) on the line—these stand-alone events play out like mini-movies, complete with tension and payoff. While there’s no cutscene-driven plot, the ebb and flow of a season-long push naturally generates its own narrative arcs.

The inclusion of the Field of Dreams stadium adds a meta-textual layer to the experience, evoking the classic baseball movie’s romanticism. Playing under the lights in that hallowed diamond transports you, if only for an inning or two, into the realm of silver-screen storytelling. Each game here feels like a special chapter in a larger saga, reminding players why baseball is often called “America’s pastime.”

Overall Experience

The Sporting News Baseball delivers a satisfying blend of accessible mechanics and nostalgic charm. The lack of a full Major League license is noticeable, but with the top-tier player roster secured through the MLBPA agreement, you still get to swing for the fences with some of the era’s biggest stars. The robust pennant race mode and varied exhibitions ensure that you’ll spend hours tweaking lineups, fine-tuning your approach, and chasing down championships.

Graphic limitations—namely the small stadium selection and sprite-based visuals—may deter those expecting modern presentation values. However, the simplicity of the parks and the clear, colorful on-field action work in your favor, preventing visual clutter and keeping the focus squarely on gameplay. If you’re looking for a deep, simulation-heavy baseball title from the mid-’90s era, this game hits more than it misses.

Ultimately, The Sporting News Baseball is best suited for players who appreciate straightforward controls, strong player rosters, and a dash of nostalgia. Whether you’re aiming to relive classic moments with Ken Griffey Jr. or carve out your own legendary season in the pennant race, this title offers an engaging baseball experience that remains enjoyable decades after its release.

Retro Replay Score

6.9/10