Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Super Mario 64 revolutionized the platforming genre by transitioning Mario into a fully 3D environment. Instead of the traditional side-scrolling formula, players explore Princess Peach’s castle and dive headfirst into its many painted worlds, each a distinct realm with multiple missions to earn Power Stars. The hub system encourages exploration and replayability: levels open new areas as Mario acquires additional stars, keeping progression organic and rewarding curiosity.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Mario’s move set is a highlight, balancing accessibility with depth. In addition to running and jumping, he can dive, climb, crouch, crawl, backflip off walls, and perform triple jumps, providing an arsenal of maneuvers that feel fluid and responsive. These mechanics are intuitive enough for newcomers yet offer enough nuance to challenge seasoned players with advanced tricks and speedrunning techniques.

The objectives within each course are varied, ranging from boss battles against oversized Koopa enemies to timed races and intricate puzzle-based tasks. This variety keeps the formula fresh across over a dozen worlds. Hidden alcoves, multiple star requirements, and secret challenges ensure that Mario’s castle remains ripe for discovery long after the first playthrough.

Power-ups such as the Wing Cap, Metal Cap, and Vanish Cap add another layer of experimentation. Each cap is tied to specific courses and grants Mario unique abilities—flight, invulnerability, or phasing through barriers—forcing players to strategize how best to use their temporary effects. The thrill of tracking down these caps and mastering their limitations enhances the core platforming experience.

Graphics

Although originally released on the Nintendo 64, Super Mario 64’s visual design has aged with surprising grace. Its vibrant color palette and whimsical character models retain their charm, demonstrating how strong art direction can transcend hardware limitations. Each level—from the sunny slopes of Bob-omb Battlefield to the eerie halls of Bowser’s Castle—features distinct atmospheres that feel lived-in despite simple geometry.

Technical constraints of the era are evident in low-resolution textures and angular edges, but these are offset by smooth frame rates and smart camera work that mask draw-distance limitations. Mario’s animations, from his joyful landings to his expressive faces, exude personality that draws players into the adventure.

Later ports and re-releases on platforms like Wii U Virtual Console and Nintendo Switch’s Super Mario 3D All-Stars have introduced upscaled resolutions and anti-aliasing, polishing the original visuals without sacrificing their nostalgic appeal. Even in its pure N64 form, the game’s graphics remain iconic, a testament to Nintendo’s knack for crafting memorable, colorful worlds.

Complementing the visuals is a playful soundtrack that reinforces each environment’s mood. From the celebratory fanfare upon collecting a Power Star to the serene melodies drifting through hidden courses, the audio-visual synergy elevates immersion and keeps returning players humming the tunes long after they’ve put down the controller.

Story

Super Mario 64 presents a straightforward yet effective narrative: Princess Peach has been kidnapped by Bowser and trapped within the walls of her own castle. This simple premise serves as a backdrop rather than the focus, allowing players to jump straight into exploration and platforming challenges without lengthy exposition.

The tale unfolds through minimal cutscenes—Peach’s pleading letter, Bowser’s taunting laughter, and the climactic final duel. By keeping story beats concise, the game maintains a brisk pace, ensuring that the thrill of discovering new levels and solving puzzles remains front and center.

In-world characters like the trapped Toads offer snippets of dialogue that hint at hidden secrets and optional objectives, rewarding attentive players with hints toward elusive stars. Bowser’s menacing presence is reinforced through environmental storytelling, from crumbling corridors to lava-pocked arenas, making each encounter feel earned.

While the plot isn’t complex, its simplicity invites players to project their own sense of heroism onto Mario. Every recovered star, freed Toad, or defeated minion becomes a personal victory, reinforcing the core motivation to press onward until Peach is finally rescued.

Overall Experience

Super Mario 64 stands as a landmark achievement in gaming history, blending intuitive controls, innovative level design, and an open-ended hub system that encourages exploration. Its influence can be seen in virtually every 3D platformer that followed, yet few titles have matched its playful spirit and design elegance.

For newcomers, the game offers a gentle learning curve that gradually introduces new mechanics, while veterans will appreciate the depth of advanced movement techniques and the thrill of uncovering every secret. Occasional camera quirks or imprecise collision detection may crop up, but the satisfaction of mastering each course and collecting hard-to-find stars far outweighs these minor drawbacks.

The game’s longevity is bolstered by its secrets and optional challenges. Even after securing the 120 Power Stars needed for the final showdown, time-trial races, coin collection quests, and hidden alcoves provide endless replay value. A thriving speedrunning community and fan-made mods further extend its lifespan, keeping Super Mario 64 fresh decades after its original release.

Whether experienced on original hardware, through a modern re-release, or via emulation, Super Mario 64’s core magic remains undiminished. Its combination of tight controls, imaginative worlds, and secret-laden stages makes it essential for platformer enthusiasts and a must-own title for anyone seeking a masterclass in game design.

Retro Replay Score

8.6/10