Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Arthur’s Knights II: The Secret of Merlin builds on its predecessor’s foundations, blending exploration, puzzle-solving, and combat into a cohesive medieval adventure. You step into the boots of Bradwen, newly minted Knight of the Round Table, but still plagued by a mysterious and crippling curse. The game’s core loop revolves around investigating ancient ruins, interrogating townsfolk, and deciphering cryptic runes to uncover Merlin’s hidden knowledge.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The combat system offers a satisfying balance between strategy and action. You’ll find yourself switching between swordplay, archery, and occasional magical abilities bestowed by Merlin’s artifacts. Enemy encounters range from minor skirmishes with bandits to larger battles against cursed knights and monstrous creatures. Each fight demands careful positioning and judicious use of Bradwen’s skills, ensuring that even the most trivial opponent can become a threat if you let your guard down.

Puzzles play a central role in progression, often tied to the game’s historical setting. Whether you’re aligning levers in a Roman bath complex or decoding ogham inscriptions in a Celtic grove, these brain-teasers feel organically woven into the world. The variety of puzzles keeps the gameplay fresh, and occasional branching paths encourage multiple playthroughs to uncover all of Merlin’s secrets.

Graphics

The Secret of Merlin excels in its visual presentation of 7th century Britain. Lush forests, misty moors, and crumbling stone keeps are rendered with an attention to period detail that immerses you in a bygone era. Dynamic lighting accentuates the mood—flickering torchlight in underground chambers and golden sunlight filtering through cathedral windows make each environment memorable.

Character models have been significantly improved over the first game. Bradwen’s armor bears realistic weathering, and his facial expressions convey weariness from his lingering curse. NPCs exhibit varied costumes and mannerisms reflective of their social standing, from ragged villagers to imposing nobles at court. Subtle animations, such as a blacksmith hammering metal or druids chanting by a standing stone, breathe life into each settlement.

While the textures and draw distances occasionally exhibit minor pop-in, these hiccups do little to detract from the overall spectacle. Cutscenes are fully voiced and make liberal use of cinematic camera angles, reinforcing key story beats with dramatic flair. The result is a polished visual package that feels right at home alongside modern adventure titles.

Story

Continuing directly after the events of Tales of Chivalry, Arthur’s Knights II plunges you into a narrative driven by both personal stakes and broader political machinations. Bradwen’s quest to rid himself of the dark curse intertwines with a brewing conflict between the Saxons, the Picts, and the fading pagan traditions. This historical tapestry gives weight to your every decision.

Merlin looms large as both mentor and mystery. Through visions and cryptic riddles, he guides Bradwen toward arcane relics that may hold the key to healing his wound. The dialogues strike a fine balance between legendary myth and human drama—Bradwen wrestles with doubt and desperation, while supporting characters reveal their own ambitions and loyalties.

Branching story paths offer multiple endings, hinging on moral choices that range from mercy toward captured foes to alliances with supernatural beings. Even side quests, such as aiding a displaced druidic sect or investigating a haunted monastery, contribute layers to the central plot. The pacing remains steady, with new revelations arriving just as you feel poised to solve the last enigma.

Overall Experience

Arthur’s Knights II: The Secret of Merlin stands out as a modern historical adventure that honors its Arthurian roots while delivering engaging gameplay. The seamless blend of exploration, combat, and puzzles ensures that you’re rarely at a loss for activities, and each element enhances the central quest to break Bradwen’s curse.

The game’s immersive world design and strong narrative drive make it particularly appealing to fans of medieval folklore and myth. You’ll likely find yourself poring over every map and dialogue option, determined to piece together Merlin’s hidden machinations. Even newcomers to the series can jump in, thanks to well-crafted tutorials and a recap of key events from the first title.

While minor graphical glitches and an occasionally obtuse puzzle might frustrate some players, the overall package remains highly satisfying. From its atmospheric British landscapes to its morally complex storyline, The Secret of Merlin offers a richly detailed journey that rewards curiosity and courage in equal measure. Potential buyers seeking a deep, story-driven adventure steeped in Arthurian legend will find plenty to admire here.

Retro Replay Score

6.4/10