Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Casual Romance Club centers on a straightforward yet engaging loop of afternoon meetups, conversation choices, and relationship-building. Each day, you select up to three club members from a roster of twelve to chat with over tea and snacks. As you progress, your responses can unlock new conversational branches, deepening emotional connections and revealing personal details about each girl.

The notebook feature is a clever addition, allowing you to jot down each girl’s preferences, schedules, and little quirks you uncover. These notes aren’t just cosmetic—they help you choose the right dialogue options later on, turning what might feel like guesswork into a more strategic, memory-driven experience. If you miss a detail, you still have multiple attempts across different afternoons to catch up and steer the relationship in your favor.

When you’ve built enough rapport, you can ask a girl out on a proper date. These date sequences open up special scenes—some emotionally heartfelt, others more risqué in the original PC version. While the Saturn-based English release removes explicit content, it compensates with animated cutscenes and voiced dialogue that add a richer layer to each outing. Choices during dates determine whether a relationship deepens or stalls, offering genuine replayability as you explore different routes.

Overall, the pacing is deliberate rather than frantic. There’s no penalty for taking your time to learn each girl’s personality; in fact, the slower build-up makes those breakthrough moments feel earned. For players new to dating sims, the clear dialogue prompts and notebook system ease you into the mechanics, while veterans will appreciate the variety of personalities and branching paths awaiting discovery.

Graphics

Casual Romance Club’s visual presentation is a marked improvement over the barebones PC original. The English bilingual release draws heavily from the Sega Saturn version’s art assets, featuring fully redrawn character sprites and richly detailed CG illustrations. Each of the twelve heroines has her own distinct look, with expressive facial animations that breathe life into their on-screen interactions.

In-game backgrounds capture the cozy, intimate atmosphere of the local restaurant where the club gathers. Warm lighting, wood-accented furniture, and ambient details like steaming cups and soft shadows contribute to a welcoming setting. These backgrounds anchor your conversations and dates in a believable world, making each encounter feel like stepping into a real afterschool hangout.

Animated cutscenes add a dynamic flair to milestone moments, whether it’s a shy confession or a playful tease. While not full-motion video, these short animations elevate key scenes beyond static images, helping to punctuate emotional highs and lows. The CG gallery unlocks as you progress, providing replay value for art enthusiasts eager to admire each illustration in greater detail.

Overall, the graphical overhaul in this release strikes a nice balance between nostalgia and polish. It preserves the charm of the original character designs while applying modern touches that prevent the art from feeling dated. Whether you’re a collector of retro-style visuals or simply appreciate well-crafted character art, Casual Romance Club delivers on the aesthetic front.

Story

The narrative premise is delightfully simple: Renichi Amagi (Jim Thanders in English) is the new face in the Afterschool Romance Club, a casual gathering for students curious about love. Over weekly meetings at a quaint restaurant, he strikes up conversations with a diverse cast of twelve girls, each harboring distinct dreams, fears, and romantic aspirations.

As you progress through conversation choices, the story unfolds organically, revealing the daily lives and hidden depths of each heroine. Some routes focus on lighthearted comedy—think misunderstandings over text messages or humorous mishaps on a date—while others delve into more emotional territory, exploring themes of self-confidence, familial pressure, and first love jitters.

Although the Saturn-based English release forgoes the PC version’s explicit scenes, it retains the core narrative beats. Intimacy is handled with tact, relying on suggestive visuals and evocative voice acting to convey the chemistry between Renichi and his date. This approach allows the story to reach a wider audience without diluting its romantic essence.

The strength of Casual Romance Club lies in its character-driven storytelling. Each heroine’s route feels unique, with personal story arcs that require genuine effort to unlock. As you complete one girl’s path, you’ll find yourself eager to start another, discovering new dialogue branches and hidden CG events that enrich the overall narrative tapestry.

Overall Experience

Casual Romance Club offers a rewarding blend of strategic dating-sim mechanics, charming visuals, and heartfelt storytelling. The afternoon meetups and notebook system provide a satisfying structure for relationship-building, while the inclusion of animated cutscenes and voiced dialogue in the English release elevates the experience beyond typical text-based sims.

Replayability is high, thanks to twelve distinct romance routes, each with multiple endings and unlockable CGs. The bilingual presentation also adds value for players interested in Japanese, letting you switch between languages on the fly—a nifty feature for both learners and purists who prefer original voice performances.

Newcomers to the genre will appreciate the clear choice prompts and the forgiving pace, while longtime fans can relish the depth and variety of character interactions. Though the adult skincare of the original PC release is toned down, the English version maintains enough romantic tension to satisfy players looking for a mature dating sim without overt explicitness.

Ultimately, Casual Romance Club shines as an affectionate tribute to afterschool romance scenarios, blending nostalgia with modern enhancements. Whether you’re drawn by the anime-style art, the branching narratives, or the chance to relive the thrill of first love, this title is a solid pick for anyone seeking a finely tuned dating-sim experience.

Retro Replay Score

null/10