Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Diablo + Hellfire delivers the classic hack-and-slash action that helped define the ARPG genre. Players explore procedurally generated dungeons beneath the cursed town of Tristram, fighting hordes of demons, skeletons, and other unholy creatures. The core gameplay loop of dive, loot and upgrade is as addictive today as it was at the time of release, with each run offering new combinations of monsters and treasures.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The base game offers three distinct character classes—Warrior, Rogue, and Sorcerer—each with unique strengths and weaknesses. Hellfire’s add-on expands that roster with three additional classes: the stealthy Bard, the sturdy Barbarian, and the mystical Monk. These new classes introduce fresh combat styles, spells, and strategies, extending replayability significantly.

Character progression feels rewarding. As you level up, you allocate points to attributes like Strength, Dexterity, and Magic, then choose new spells or combat abilities. The variety of items—potions, scrolls, weapons, and armor—keeps players hunting for that next gear upgrade. While Hellfire’s quest content is more limited than the main campaign, its new dungeon types and unique treasures offer enough variation to keep hardcore fans engaged.

Difficulty settings range from Normal to Nightmare, catering to both newcomers and veterans seeking a punishing challenge. However, Hellfire’s increased monster density and novel enemy behaviors can feel unbalanced at times. Careful inventory and resource management become crucial, ensuring each dungeon dive remains tense and strategic rather than a mindless hackfest.

Graphics

Visually, Diablo remains a masterclass in moody, 2D isometric art. Dark corridors are lit by flickering torches, and gore-soaked battlefields convey a grim atmosphere that perfectly complements the game’s infernal theme. Despite its age, the hand-painted textures and sprite animations retain a certain charm that many modern pixel-art titles aspire to match.

Character and monster designs are distinct and memorable. From the skeletal warriors to the boss-level Butcher and Diablo himself, each sprite is well-defined, with smooth attack animations and satisfying spell effects. Lighting effects—particularly fire spells and holy beams—add flair without taxing hardware, making the game accessible on a wide range of systems.

Hellfire’s enhancements are subtle but welcome. The add-on includes new dungeon tilesets and monster sprites that blend seamlessly with the original visuals. Though the color palette remains largely unchanged, these fresh assets prevent the experience from feeling too repetitive during extended campaigns.

Story

Diablo’s narrative is straightforward: you descend into the depths of Tristram’s cathedral to confront Diablo, the Lord of Terror. NPC interactions—such as those with Deckard Cain and King Leoric—lend weight to the journey, while occasional in-game journals and letters hint at a larger, malevolent force corrupting the land.

Hellfire adds a supplementary storyline that explores a new cabal of warlocks seeking Diablo’s power for themselves. This side campaign introduces a handful of hidden quests and unique lore, though it remains somewhat tangential to the core canon. Hardcore fans will appreciate the extra context, but newcomers shouldn’t expect the same narrative polish found in the original.

Dialogue and exposition are kept concise, focusing on atmosphere over deep characterization. The game’s strength lies in its sense of dread and discovery rather than intricate plot twists. While voice-overs are sparse, the combination of haunting music and ambient sound effects more than compensates, immersing players in Sanctuary’s darkness.

Overall Experience

Diablo + Hellfire stands as a landmark title in action-RPG history, offering hours of addictive dungeon crawling wrapped in a sinister, gothic world. The base game’s tight mechanics and randomized levels keep you coming back, while Hellfire’s added classes and content extend the lifespan for completionists.

Players on a budget or those new to classic CRPGs will find tremendous value here. The combined package represents a comprehensive experience: Diablo’s foundational design enriched by Hellfire’s experimental additions. Even in 2024, the core loop of explore-fight-loot retains its magnetic pull, proving that solid gameplay often outlasts flashy graphics.

For modern audiences, the dated interface and lack of quality-of-life features (such as shared stash or streamlined inventory) can feel clunky. Yet, this “old-school” charm is part of Diablo’s enduring appeal. Fans of dark fantasy and looter mechanics should dive in, while those seeking narrative depth or cutting-edge visuals might prefer newer entries in the series.

Retro Replay Score

7.2/10