Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Stronghold 2 picks up where its predecessor left off, combining detailed castle construction and resource management with real-time strategic warfare. You’ll spend as much time planning the layout of your kitchens, granaries, and barracks as you will coordinating trebuchet volleys and gatehouse assaults. The campaign splits neatly into a peaceful building phase—where your top priority is growing a self-sustaining economy—and a military phase, in which you marshal those resources to defend your stronghold or lay siege to your enemies.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The peaceful campaign isn’t entirely combat-free. Roaming bandits, wild beasts, and the occasional rebellious peasant will test your defenses, forcing you to strike a balance between population happiness, crime prevention, and security. You’ll need to employ the new crime and punishment system—complete with dungeons, stocks, or lashings—to keep thieves in line and ensure your food chain remains unmolested. At the same time, a healthy economy of farms, mills, and marketplaces must generate enough surplus to fund your future war chest.

When the military campaign kicks in, you’ll unlock deeper layers of strategy. Stronghold 2 introduces “honour” as a special currency, earned through tournaments, feasts, and other kingdom-level activities. Honour isn’t just a prestige meter—it allows you to recruit elite units and better fortifications, from boiling oil traps to spike pits. The Kingmaker mode and free-form skirmishes let you test these systems against human or AI opponents, while dozens of pre-made historical castles provide fresh challenges and strategic puzzles.

Graphics

Stepping into Stronghold 2’s 3D engine is a dramatic upgrade from the original’s 2D visuals. Castles rise in sweeping stone arches, gates creak on pivoting hinges, and walls crack under fire from trebuchets. Zooming in close reveals intricate details: villagers bustle through market stalls, blacksmith sparks fly when weapons are forged, and cavalry units glint in polished armor as they charge into melee. It’s a vivid, living medieval world.

Textures and models hold up well even by modern standards, thanks in part to the Deluxe edition’s integrated Patch 1.3.1, which streamlines performance and reduces pop-in. Terrain features—rolling hills, forests, rivers—are richly shaded, and shadows shift realistically with the day/night cycle. Even on large maps with hundreds of units on screen, frame rates stay smooth if you tweak the detail settings. For players with mid-range rigs, the adjustable draw distance and effects options ensure an immersive experience without constant slowdown.

Pre-made historical castles add an extra layer of fidelity: you’ll besiege the Tower of London, defend Windsor’s battlements, or attempt to breach Haut-Koenigsburg with all its towers and ramparts intact. Each fortress feels unique, with authentic masonry patterns, layout quirks, and period-correct architectural flourishes. Whether you’re surveying your own timber-framed manor or scouting the enemy’s stonework from afar, Stronghold 2’s visuals provide both clarity and atmosphere.

Story

The core narrative of Stronghold 2 unfolds in two halves: first, you establish your domain as a peaceful lord, forging trade routes, feeding your subjects, and quelling minor unrest. Flavor text and mission briefings paint a picture of a kingdom in disarray—bandits plague the countryside, and lawlessness threatens the crown’s authority. Your initial tasks focus on economic growth, punishing criminals, and proving your worth to the nobles.

Once your village matures into a fortified castle, the story pivots to a full-scale military campaign aimed at restoring order to England. Each mission presents historical or semi-fictional scenarios: defending key strongpoints, rescuing beleaguered allies, or leading sieges against traitorous barons. While Stronghold 2 doesn’t feature cinematic cutscenes, its scripted events—such as surprise attacks or relief armies arriving—lend a dynamic, story-driven feel to each battle.

The Deluxe edition’s crusade mode takes you beyond England’s shores, tasking you with conquering iconic European castles on a religious military expedition. As you storm famous fortresses and win jousting tournaments for honour, the campaign weaves in just enough historical context to keep you invested, even if you’re primarily in it for the castle-siege spectacle.

Overall Experience

Stronghold 2 is a deep, multifaceted strategy game that rewards careful planning and adaptability. The learning curve can be steep—mastering the interplay of farming, taxation, crime control, and troop deployment takes time—but each element feels meaningful. There’s real satisfaction in seeing a well-laid trap spring to life or watching your economy thrive, funding ever-more elaborate fortifications.

Multiplayer skirmishes and the Kingmaker mode add tremendous replay value. Whether you’re coordinating with friends to mount a joint offensive or facing off in a last-man-standing scenario, the customizable rules and map selection keep every match feeling fresh. The inclusion of new AI foes—The Queen, The Pontifex, and Sir Grey—plus extra world and scenery maps in the Deluxe edition means even veteran commanders will find new challenges to conquer.

All told, FireFly Studios’ Stronghold 2 stands the test of time as one of the most engaging castle sims and medieval RTS hybrids available. Its blend of detailed economic management, visceral siege warfare, and polished 3D presentation makes it a must-try for anyone who’s ever dreamed of ruling from a battlement or crushing foes under their portcullis.

Retro Replay Score

6.9/10