Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Medieval 2 picks up where its predecessor left off, refining the classic turn-based hex-grid mechanics that define its tactical battles. Units remain small—just 25 men each—so every casualty feels significant and forces you to weigh risk versus reward on every move. With each hex representing 25 yards of medieval battlefield, positioning and formation become crucial; a single flanking maneuver can turn the tide of an entire engagement.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The expanded arsenal in Medieval 2 gives commanders plenty to think about. From longbows and crossbows to polearms and cavalry lances, each weapon type has clear strengths and weaknesses. Combined with varied terrain—wooded glens, rolling hills, muddy fields—you’ll constantly adapt your strategy. Charging knights down a gentle slope, hiding archers in a grove, or using pikes to hold chokepoints all feel remarkably authentic to the era.

Perhaps the most compelling feature is the breadth of scenarios—thirty-six in all. You can relive the iconic clash at Hastings in 1066, hold the line at Falkirk against Scottish schiltrons, or mastermind Henry V’s triumph at Agincourt. For something more folkloric, take command of Robin Hood’s band in Sherwood Forest and pit outlaw archers against Norman patrols. Each scenario drops you into a unique tactical puzzle, but be aware: there’s no overarching campaign to tie them together.

Veteran wargamers will appreciate the improved AI, which offers smarter enemy formations and reactive battlefield tactics. However, newcomers may find the learning curve steep; understanding how terrain modifiers interact with unit morale and weapon reach takes time. That said, a handful of skirmishes will have you hooked, as the sheer depth of medieval warfare unfolds one hex at a time.

Graphics

For a sequel in a niche wargaming series, Medieval 2’s graphical overhaul is impressive. Unit sprites are crisper and more detailed, allowing you to distinguish pikemen from heavy cavalry at a glance. Textures on the battlefield—stone walls, forest undergrowth, and dirt roads—feel more varied and lifelike than in the original title.

Animations have received a marked upgrade as well. Cavalry charges feature believable momentum, with horses rearing and banners snapping in the wind. Infantry clashes are no longer just generic blocky figures; you’ll notice individual men swinging axes or raising shields. These visual flourishes may not compete with modern AAA titles, but within the wargame genre, they lend real personality to each unit.

Weather and lighting effects also enhance immersion. Drizzle on a muddy field can slow movement and obscure line of sight, while bright sunlight across an open plain makes ranged units even more deadly. The combination of dynamic lighting and day-night transitions deepens the feeling of commanding real armies in historical battles.

On the downside, zoom levels are somewhat limited, and the 2D map perspective can feel dated by today’s standards. If you’re used to full 3D camera control, the fixed-angle view may take some adjustment. Nevertheless, the clarity and color palette ensure that tactical information is always easy to parse, which is ultimately what this style of wargame demands.

Story

Unlike grand campaign-driven strategy games, Medieval 2 delivers its narrative through standalone scenarios. Each battle opens with a concise briefing that sets the historical context—whether you’re defending a Norman supply train or leading Welsh spearmen against English archers. These introductions are short but informative, anchoring you in the medieval world.

While there’s no continuous storyline linking every scenario, the sense of progression comes from mastering a variety of battlefields and forces. One mission might require careful defensive planning at Falkirk, while the next demands audacious frontal assaults at Agincourt. This format offers flexibility, letting you tackle conflicts in any order without waiting for diplomacy screens or resource management drills.

For fans of medieval lore, Sherwood Forest stands out. Though technically a “what-if” scenario, stepping into Robin Hood’s shoes and ambushing royal patrols brings a welcome change of pace. The blend of legendary material with hard-nosed historical warfare creates a unique storytelling flavor that most wargames lack.

The downside is an absence of character progression or faction management beyond a single battle. If you yearn for narrative arcs—building a dynasty or forging alliances over dozens of turns—Medieval 2’s scenario focus may feel limiting. Here, your only reward is the satisfaction of outthinking your opponent and claiming victory.

Overall Experience

Medieval 2 excels at delivering pure tactical satisfaction. Each scenario is a finely crafted puzzle, and the interplay of unit types, terrain, and weather keeps battles fresh. The improved AI means you can’t rely on predictable enemy behavior, so every engagement demands concentration and adaptation.

That said, the lack of a unified campaign mode will disappoint players who prefer the grand strategy trappings of resource management, diplomacy, and territory expansion. Medieval 2 is unapologetically a series of standalone battles, so your enjoyment hinges on whether you relish pure tactical challenges or crave a more layered strategic experience.

Multiplayer is another mixed bag. Turns can be exchanged via e-mail, which works in principle but feels archaic compared to hotseat or online matchmaking. For those who enjoy asynchronous play and have patient friends, it can still provide hours of head-to-head fun, but it’s far from seamless.

In the end, Medieval 2 is a must-see for dedicated wargamers and history buffs seeking tight, scenario-based combat. Its graphical improvements and sharper AI polish a classic formula, even if its old-school presentation and limited multiplayer options hold it back from wider appeal. If you appreciate deliberate, methodical battles and have the patience to learn hex-grid tactics, this title will reward you with deep, historically flavored engagement.

Retro Replay Score

null/10