Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Murder in a Wheel offers a classic point-and-click investigation that feels instantly familiar to fans of early LucasArts adventures. You guide investigative researcher Lionel Ulmer through Lord Blackwin’s sprawling mansion, clicking on hotspots to gather clues, question suspects, and interact with objects. The game employs a SCUMM-style interface with a command bar that includes verbs like “Examine,” “Use,” and “Talk,” although it smartly applies the most logical action when you simply click on an interactive element. This streamlines the experience and keeps the focus on solving the mystery.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Puzzles in Murder in a Wheel are generally logical and well-integrated into the setting. You might need to find a key to unlock the library or piece together snippets of overheard conversations to deduce someone’s motive. None of these challenges overstay their welcome—if you find yourself stuck, most clues are hidden in dialogue or in plain sight on the screen. The game’s entirely mouse-driven control scheme means you never second-guess your inputs, allowing the narrative to take center stage.

The investigation itself is both brisk and rewarding. While the entire adventure takes place within the mansion’s walls, each room houses unique secrets and red herrings that heighten the suspense. Lionel’s status bar tracks key items in your inventory, and the game auto-highlights hotspots when you hover over them, preventing unnecessary pixel hunts. Overall, gameplay feels polished for a student project, maintaining a steady pace without bogging you down in filler tasks.

Graphics

The visuals in Murder in a Wheel are a loving homage to the golden age of adventure gaming. Created as a semester project at Zurich University of the Arts, the pixel art style draws heavily on LucasFan’s MMM Starterpack and evokes the warm color palettes of classic LucasArts titles. Each room is hand-crafted with detailed backgrounds: dusty portraits line the hallways, ornate furniture casts dramatic shadows, and subtle animations (a flickering candle or a twitching curtain) breathe life into the mansion.

Character sprites are expressive despite their small size. Lionel’s contemplative frown, Lady Blackwin’s shocked gasp, and the suspicious glances exchanged by other suspects all convey personality without the need for voice acting. Even the unfortunate pet Roderick receives an endearing design that makes his untimely demise surprisingly poignant. NPC animations are smooth, and the SCUMM-style user interface complements the retro aesthetic without feeling dated.

Transitions between rooms are swift, thanks to efficient coding in the Adventure Game Studio engine. There’s no long loading time to break immersion; merely a brief fade-out and fade-in before you find yourself in the next wing of the mansion. Overall, the graphics strike a fine balance between nostalgia and clarity, ensuring that hotspots remain visible and environments feel rich and atmospheric.

Story

The narrative hook in Murder in a Wheel is delightfully macabre and surprisingly witty. When Lionel Ulmer arrives at Lord Blackwin’s mansion to assist with a manuscript, he’s instead faced with the brutal murder of the household’s beloved rodent, Roderick. From the moment Lady Blackwin shrieks at the scene of the crime, the game plunges you into a whodunit teeming with eccentric suspects and well-placed misdirection.

Dialogue is sharp and character-driven. Each inhabitant—from the sly butler to the aloof governess to Mrs. Winterbottom the cat—has a believable motive for silencing the hamster. Conversations feel genuine, with branching remarks that reward curiosity and occasionally inject humor. Lionel himself serves as an empathetic guide, often offering tongue-in-cheek observations that balance the darker elements of the plot.

While the core mystery remains contained within the mansion, the game’s pacing ensures that every new clue leads you deeper into a web of secrets. The final revelation is satisfying rather than predictable, encouraging a moment of reflection on how small grievances and innocent ambitions can spiral into unexpected violence. For a freeware student project, the story beats are remarkably well-structured and emotionally engaging.

Overall Experience

Murder in a Wheel is a standout example of what passionate students can achieve when given solid tools and creative freedom. Despite its origins as a semester assignment, the game feels cohesive, polished, and free of noticeable bugs. The MIDI soundtrack—drawn from existing game libraries—complements the tense atmosphere, with eerie harpsichord staccatos and ambient tones that underscore every creaking door.

The entire experience lasts around one to two hours, making it an ideal palate cleanser between larger titles or a bite-sized treat for fans of detective adventures. Its straightforward interface and clear hotspots minimize frustration, while the clever writing ensures you remain invested until the final twist. Even seasoned mystery enthusiasts will appreciate the nods to classic adventure tropes, executed here with genuine heart.

Ultimately, Murder in a Wheel succeeds as both an homage to LucasArts classics and a testament to emerging game design talent. It’s freeware, so there’s no barrier to entry: simply download, click your way through the manor, and savor a charmingly morbid tale that proves great storytelling doesn’t require a blockbuster budget. Whether you’re a veteran sleuth or new to point-and-click adventures, this game offers an engaging and memorable experience.

Retro Replay Score

7.3/10