Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

The Lord of the Rings Online: Mines of Moria expansion significantly deepens the gameplay loop established in Shadows of Angmar. By raising the level cap from 50 to 60, it reintroduces a sense of growth as players unlock a host of new skills and abilities. Each class benefits from a refreshed talent tree, with previously underused talents rebalanced to accommodate these new powers. Combat feels more dynamic as veteran players revisit their builds to integrate fresh options and optimized rotations.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Two brand-new classes—Runekeeper and Warden—add substantial variety to team compositions. The Runekeeper’s resource-shifting mechanic rewards sustained specialization, allowing players to choose a handful of key runes that grow stronger the longer they’re used. Conversely, the Warden’s gambit queue system emphasizes precise timing and sequence-building, rewarding players who master their off-tank role with both mitigation and burst damage. Group synergy reaches new heights as these classes fill roles that previously lacked depth.

Legendary weapons bring another layer of customization and long-term engagement. Each weapon earns experience in combat and gains attribute points on level-ups, letting players fine-tune stat distributions or unlock hidden, class-specific bonuses. The re-forging system—resetting stats every ten levels to grant access to more powerful tiers—creates a satisfying cycle of progression and experimentation. Whether you’re crafting an ancient dwarven hammer or forging an Elven blade, the journey of empowerment keeps players invested in their gear.

Quest design in Moria balances epic lore beats with varied mechanics, from escort missions through subterranean ruins to rescue-oriented group skirmishes against orc warbands. The new high-level zones encourage both solo adventuring and fellowship-based raids, seamlessly integrating public quests that reward casual players without undermining the challenge for dedicated parties. Overall, Mines of Moria excels at mixing traditional MMORPG structure with Tolkien-inspired thematic diversity.

Graphics

Visually, Mines of Moria marks a notable step up from the base game. The expansion’s centerpiece—the vast, torch-lit corridors of Khazad-dûm—showcase intricate stonework, grand staircases, and environmental storytelling through ancient carvings. Subtle ambient effects like drifting dust motes and faint echoes bring the underground realm to life, creating a richly immersive setting for exploration.

Lothlórien’s glade presents a striking contrast, with soft golden light filtering through towering mallorn trees, ethereal mist hovering over mirrored pools, and Elven architecture that balances ornate curves with natural harmony. The shift from cramped caverns to an open, forested realm feels narratively and visually seamless. Water reflections, dynamic shadows, and seasonal weather patterns further enrich the world’s aesthetic diversity.

Character and monster models have received targeted enhancements to match the expansion’s thematic tone. Orcs and cave-trolls boast more menacing textures and refined animations, while new armor sets and cosmetic options reflect the cultures of Dwarven and Elven craftsmanship. Spell effects, particularly from Runekeeper runes and Warden gambits, feature crisp particle work that clearly distinguishes each ability in the heat of battle.

While the underlying engine is showing its age in some areas—occasional frame dips in massive skirmishes and less detailed foliage at extreme draw distances—the overall artistic direction compensates with cohesive color palettes and memorable landmark designs. For fans of Tolkien’s landscapes, the graphical presentation in Mines of Moria offers a visually compelling reason to journey back to Middle-earth.

Story

Mines of Moria thrusts players into one of the most iconic chapters of Tolkien’s legendarium. Beginning with the uneasy departure from Lothlórien and the ominous descent beneath the Misty Mountains, the expansion weaves new side arcs around famous events like the fall of Balin’s colony. Quests are punctuated by narrative-driven set pieces, cinematic dialogue, and voiceovers that capture the tragedy and hope inherent in the Fellowship’s saga.

The expansion balances original narrative content with the familiar beats of the novels. Players encounter both iconic NPCs—such as Gimli and Legolas—and fresh characters, like Dwarven loremasters and Elven scouts, whose personal quests add emotional depth to the overarching story. These side stories explore themes of loss, perseverance, and camaraderie, reinforcing the bonds forged among adventurers facing ancient evils.

Major plot points are conveyed through a mix of in-engine cutscenes and in-game events that blur the line between story and gameplay. Defending dwarven outposts from orc incursions, navigating treacherous chasms, and confronting the resurrected Balrog all unfold with dramatic pacing. The sense of scale is reinforced by dungeon interiors that dwarf even the largest player characters, reminding you that the dangers beneath the mountain are as vast as they are deadly.

Overall Experience

As the first paid expansion for The Lord of the Rings Online, Mines of Moria delivers on its promise to expand and refine the core experience. It offers a palpable sense of progression, not just in levels and gear, but in narrative stakes and world-building. The blend of nostalgia for Tolkien’s works and fresh gameplay systems makes this expansion feel both familiar and groundbreaking.

While entry costs and the added investment in time may give pause to casual players, the wealth of content—new zones, classes, skills, and legendary gear—provides ample value for those committed to exploring Middle-earth. Community events in public quests and large-scale raids foster social engagement, ensuring that the expansion remains lively long after its release window.

Whether you’re a veteran Loremaster or a newcomer drawn by the promise of epic fantasy, Mines of Moria stands as a high point in The Lord of the Rings Online’s evolution. Its combination of deep mechanics, atmospheric visuals, and faithful storytelling makes it an essential journey for fans of both MMORPGs and Tolkien’s enduring world.

Retro Replay Score

8.4/10