Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Umbra plunges you into an unfolding mystery as a student in the vanished Port Washington school, armed only with a single cryptic clue. Exploration is at the heart of the experience: you roam the eerily deserted halls, scavenge for evidence, and piece together fragments of conversation recorded on your phone. This slow-burn investigation style rewards patience, encouraging you to revisit locations and scrutinize every photo-based texture for hidden hints.

The game’s branching narrative system shines through its ten possible story paths, each triggered by different investigative choices and interactions. Early decisions—whether you approach an abandoned classroom or venture outside to the schoolyard first—can send you down entirely distinct story arcs. This design fosters a sense of agency, making each playthrough feel genuinely unique and personal.

Puzzles in Umbra are thoughtfully integrated with the environment. Rather than tacked-on lock-and-key mechanics, challenges stem from interpreting the real-world photographs that form the game’s visuals. Deciphering a coded message scrawled on a chalkboard or matching a landmark’s signage becomes a satisfying test of observation and critical thinking.

With over 30 hours of potential gameplay tied to its multiple endings, Umbra continually incentivizes replay. Certain story threads only reveal themselves on later runs, nudging you to explore alternative paths you might have missed. This level of depth and replayability is a significant achievement for a narrative-driven indie title.

Graphics

Umbra’s visuals are composed entirely of actual photographs taken around Port Washington, New York, lending the game an uncanny realism that most virtual environments struggle to match. Hallways, classrooms, and suburban streets come alive with authentic details—from the texture of peeling paint to the glint of sunlight on a car windshield.

The photographic approach also imparts a distinctive atmospheric quality. Shadows cast by real-world objects feel unpredictable, and lighting variations between day and night scenes intensify the mystery. During the titular solar eclipse, the sky darkens in a way that feels almost otherworldly, heightening tension in areas you thought you knew.

However, this realism comes with some trade-offs. Transitioning between photos can occasionally feel jarring, as the game stitches together multiple high-resolution images. At times, you might pause mid-step only to see a slight displacement in perspective—an effect that can momentarily pull you out of immersion.

Despite these minor hiccups, Umbra’s photo-based aesthetic remains its most striking feature. It grounds the supernatural events in a tangible world, making every ghostly whisper and flickering light all the more unsettling. If you appreciate a game that blurs the line between reality and the uncanny, Umbra delivers in spades.

Story

The central mystery of Umbra revolves around a sudden solar eclipse that inexplicably causes an entire school—and everyone inside—to vanish. You, a student from that school, awaken to find an empty campus and a trail of cryptic clues that point toward something far beyond a simple disappearance. The premise strikes a perfect balance between familiar small-town intrigue and uncharted supernatural territory.

Umbra’s narrative structure branches into roughly ten distinct storylines, each offering its own cast of characters, motives, and revelations. One playthrough might focus on a teacher’s secret research project, while another unravels a centuries-old local legend tied to the eclipse. These divergent arcs ensure that returning players constantly uncover fresh angles and hidden depths.

Dialogue and journal entries scattered throughout the game enrich the world-building, revealing daily life in Port Washington before the event. You get glimpses of teenage friendships, academic rivalries, and darker undercurrents simmering beneath the town’s placid surface. This grounding in relatable human drama makes the later supernatural twists feel all the more disturbing.

As clues accumulate, Umbra’s pacing tightens. Moments of calm exploration give way to tense sequences where you must piece together vital evidence under time pressure, especially when the eclipse deepens and the environment grows more hostile. By the final revelations, the story ties together emotional stakes and paranormal intrigue, leaving a lasting impact long after the credits roll.

Overall Experience

Umbra stands out as an ambitious indie title that leverages real-world photography to craft an immersive, eerie atmosphere. Its commitment to replayability, with more than 30 hours of content spread across ten branching narratives, makes it a must-play for mystery fans and completionists alike.

The game’s strengths lie in its unique visual style, richly layered storytelling, and the satisfaction of piecing together clues at your own pace. While the photo-based engine occasionally leads to visual quirks, these minor issues are far outweighed by the sense of being truly embedded in Port Washington’s uncanny quiet.

Whether you’re drawn to atmospheric exploration, complex branching narratives, or puzzle-solving rooted in real-world detail, Umbra delivers a compelling package. It isn’t a high-octane action thriller but rather a slow-burning, investigative adventure that rewards immersion and curiosity.

For players seeking a fresh spin on the mystery genre—one that blends photographic realism with supernatural elements—Umbra offers a memorable journey. Each playthrough unveils new secrets, ensuring that your next glimpse into the vanished school will be just as riveting as the first.

Retro Replay Score

null/10