Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Golf’s Best: St. Andrews – The Home of Golf offers an impressively authentic simulation of one of the world’s most revered courses. Each hole has been mapped to exact scale, faithfully reproducing the undulations, bunkers, and water hazards found on the Old Course. Wind is a critical gameplay element, and the simulation reflects the famously blustery conditions of St. Andrews, requiring players to factor in both strength and direction when plotting their shots.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The in-game display is highly informative, presenting both an overhead view and side profile of each hole. A dynamic wind arrow at the bottom of the screen indicates the prevailing wind’s force and direction, so you can anticipate how your ball will behave in mid-flight. Additional on-screen indicators relay your exact distance to the pin, current lie (fairway, rough, sand, or green), and which stroke you’re about to attempt, empowering players to make strategic decisions on every swing.

Gameplay accommodates up to four players, making it an excellent choice for friendly tournaments or family gatherings. You begin by entering your name and selecting your preferred tees—Medal or Championship—which remain fixed throughout the round. With 14 clubs at your disposal (including a mandatory putter), you must weigh wind conditions against distance and shot shape. After selecting your club (C), you choose the swing strength (F) from full down to quarter for irons and woods, or enter a precise number of feet for wedges and putts, then set your direction (D) and shot curvature (S) before pressing “1” to execute your swing.

Graphics

Despite its vintage origins, Golf’s Best: St. Andrews delivers a remarkably detailed representation of the Old Course’s terrain. Greens roll subtly into valleys, fairways rise over natural ridges, and bunkers are etched sharply into the landscape. Each visual element—from the tufts of grass on the 17th island green to the rocky outcrops along the shoreline—adds to the feeling of immersion.

Environmental features such as trees, bushes, ponds, and period-accurate buildings, including the iconic clubhouse, have been carefully positioned to mirror their real-world counterparts. While the color palette is somewhat restrained, it effectively conveys the muted hues of the Scottish coastline and the varying textures of different surfaces—be it lush fairway grass or the coarser vegetation of the rough.

The user interface complements the visuals by remaining clean and unobtrusive. Overhead and side views are presented in crisp, pixel-perfect detail, and the wind arrow graphic is both clear and informative. On-screen indicators use contrasting colors to highlight key data—distance, club selection, stroke count—without cluttering the main display, allowing you to focus on lining up the perfect shot.

Story

While Golf’s Best: St. Andrews is primarily a sports simulation and lacks a traditional narrative arc, it nevertheless tells a story of golfing heritage. Every hole you play is steeped in history, from the legendary Road Hole (No. 17) to the ancient Swilcan Bridge on the first fairway. As you progress, you gain an appreciation for the traditions and lore that have shaped the game of golf over centuries.

The inclusion of the clubhouse as hole 19 serves as a metaphorical conclusion to your round, inviting reflection on the challenges you’ve overcome and the legacy of champions who have walked those same fairways. Although there are no cutscenes or character-driven plots, the course itself becomes the protagonist—a living, breathing entity that captures the spirit of St. Andrews.

For history buffs and golf purists alike, the game’s careful attention to authentic course details provides a narrative through scenery rather than dialogue. Every bunker you escape, every wind-blown approach you tame, and every putt you sink contributes to an ongoing tale of skill, perseverance, and respect for the game’s origins.

Overall Experience

Golf’s Best: St. Andrews delivers a deeply satisfying simulation that appeals to both seasoned golfers and strategy-minded gamers. The steep learning curve—mastering club selection, swing power, wind compensation, and shot shaping—rewards patience and dedication. Those willing to invest time will find the gameplay both challenging and endlessly replayable.

Multiplayer support for up to four players adds a competitive edge, turning solo practice rounds into social events. The honor system, which gives the previous hole’s lowest scorer the privilege of swinging first, adds a traditional touch that enhances realism and sportsmanship. Displaying the scorecard at any time keeps everyone informed of standings, fostering friendly rivalry.

While the graphics may feel dated by modern standards and the control scheme requires some getting used to, the overall package is an engrossing tribute to the “Home of Golf.” Its accurate course recreation, detailed wind mechanics, and uncluttered interface make it a must-play for aficionados of golf simulations. In the end, Golf’s Best: St. Andrews offers a genuinely transporting experience that honors the legacy of the sport and the storied course it represents.

Retro Replay Score

null/10