Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Harpoon & Battleset 2 delivers a deeply engaging naval warfare simulation that challenges both newcomers and seasoned veterans. The core of the experience lies in its realistic command-and-control mechanics, where strategic planning and real-time decision-making intersect. Players plot courses, manage ammunition loads, and coordinate fleet formations, all while reacting swiftly to changing enemy movements. The inclusion of the original Harpoon campaign and the “Showdown in the North Atlantic” BattleSet provides a rich foundation of scenarios, from Cold War cat-and-mouse submarine hunts to high-stakes destroyer engagements.

With the addition of The North Atlantic Convoys BattleSet, the game introduces new mission types centered around escort duties and merchant shipping protection. Escorting vulnerable convoys through hostile waters requires constant vigilance and adaptive tactics, adding a fresh layer of intensity. This BattleSet shines in its portrayal of the logistical challenges faced by naval commanders—allocating air cover, scheduling refueling stops, and balancing the risk of U-boat ambushes against the imperative of delivering vital supplies.

The updated program supports later BattleSets and the Scenario Editor, vastly expanding replayability. You can import or create custom scenarios to test unconventional strategies: perhaps a surprise amphibious assault in the Baltic or a nuclear submarine patrol in the Arctic. The editor’s intuitive interface lets you place ships, aircraft, mines, and even weather effects. This flexibility ensures that no two playthroughs feel the same and that tabletop-style campaign chains can be tailor-made to your preferred difficulty and narrative pace.

Graphics

Graphically, Harpoon & Battleset 2 remains faithful to its 1990s roots, offering a clean, functional interface that prioritizes data clarity over visual flourish. Ship icons, sonar pings, and radar sweeps display crisply on a map-based theater view. The minimalist design means there’s virtually no pop-in or lag when zooming or panning across large operational areas, so your focus stays locked on tactical positioning rather than GPU horsepower.

While modern gamers accustomed to 3D warship models might find the presentation dated, the 2D top-down perspective has its own charm. Detailed unit counters convey real-time heading, speed, and classification information in a glance. Undersea contacts blink on the sonar grid, and missile tracks are drawn as colored lines, creating an almost board-game aesthetic that complements the strategic depth. Color-coding friendly, neutral, and hostile forces also provides immediate battlefield awareness without clutter.

The Scenario Editor further enhances visual engagement by allowing custom labels, grid overlays, and weather icons. Want to simulate dense fog limiting visibility? Simply place a weather marker and watch your detection ranges shrink. Storm icons and sea-state indicators add immersion, reinforcing the notion that the harsh North Atlantic environment is as much an opponent as enemy fleets. For players seeking a pure strategy interface, these graphical tools strike a fine balance between usability and thematic atmosphere.

Story

Although Harpoon & Battleset 2 doesn’t follow a traditional narrative arc, its scenarios weave a compelling tactical “story” through mission briefings and situational updates. Each BattleSet frames its encounters with historical or hypothetical Cold War tensions, casting you as a fleet commander responsible for safeguarding NATO convoys or probing Soviet naval patrols. The descriptive text that accompanies mission objectives paints vivid pictures of frigid seas, sonar echoes, and the ever-present dread of enemy torpedoes.

The North Atlantic Convoys BattleSet heightens narrative stakes by emphasizing logistics over brute force. You become deeply invested in protecting merchant vessels laden with vital goods—and every sunk freighter feels like a personal defeat. The mission dialogues, though utilitarian, effectively communicate shifting threat levels and diplomatic repercussions, grounding you in the larger struggle for economic lifelines. It’s a subtle form of storytelling that emerges organically from sandbox-style objectives rather than cutscenes or voiced dialogue.

Players who use the Scenario Editor can craft their own mini-campaigns, complete with branching outcomes. You could script a scenario in which a surprise submarine blockade forces diplomatic crisis talks, or stage a last-ditch rescue operation for a disabled carrier. This user-generated content layer transforms Harpoon & Battleset 2 into a narrative workshop, where stories of heroism, miscalculation, and narrow escapes unfold—often in ways the original designers never envisioned.

Overall Experience

Harpoon & Battleset 2 stands as a testament to enduring naval simulation design. Its learning curve is steep, demanding patience and attention to detail, but rewards players with one of the most authentic command experiences on the PC. The combined content of the original game, Showdown in the North Atlantic, and The North Atlantic Convoys offers dozens of hours of structured scenarios, while the support for additional BattleSets ensures that your fleet engagements remain ever-fresh.

The inclusion of a versatile Scenario Editor is a particularly strong point, granting you the freedom to reimagine Cold War confrontations or invent entirely new maritime crises. Community-made BattleSets and mods can be easily integrated, leveraging the updated software to expand theaters from the Mediterranean to the Sea of Japan. This openness keeps the game alive long after its initial release and fosters an active fanbase sharing creative scenarios.

While modern naval sims may boast high-fidelity visuals and streamlined controls, Harpoon & Battleset 2’s unparalleled depth and authenticity carve out a unique niche. If you’re seeking a strategic challenge that emphasizes realistic tactics, comprehensive ship data, and scenario-driven engagement, this package delivers. Its blend of historical context, flexible mission design, and classic interface makes it a must-have for anyone passionate about naval warfare and strategic simulations.

Retro Replay Score

null/10