Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

The Heroes of Might and Magic Compendium delivers a timeless turn-based strategy experience that laid the foundation for one of the most beloved tactical franchises in gaming history. Each title in this collection encourages careful planning, from recruiting an army of mythical creatures to managing town upgrades and collecting resources scattered across diverse maps. The original Heroes of Might and Magic (HoMM I) introduces the core mechanics—hero movement, combat encounters, and town development—while its sequel, Heroes II, refines these systems with deeper creature hierarchies and branching faction paths.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Heroes II: The Succession Wars elevates decision-making by offering players distinct campaign stories and hero specializations. You’ll find yourself weighing the pros and cons of offensive spells versus defensive buffs, or choosing between immediate combat strength and long-term town growth. The expansion pack, The Price of Loyalty, further deepens your strategic choices by introducing new heroes, scenarios, and a political twist on resource management that forces you to juggle loyalty, wealth, and military power.

Beyond the two core titles, the Compendium includes King’s Bounty, the spiritual ancestor of the series. Although simpler by modern standards, King’s Bounty shines in its straightforward quest structure and role-playing elements. Exploring taverns, negotiating troop prices, and engaging in quick skirmishes gives you a taste of the strategic DNA that would be fully realized in HoMM I and II. As a whole, this collection offers hundreds of hours of turn-based fun, providing both bite-sized scenarios and sprawling campaigns.

Graphics

While these games predate the era of high-definition 3D, their hand-drawn art and vibrant color palettes remain charming and functional. In Heroes of Might and Magic I, towns have a quaint, pixel-art style that evokes late 1990s fantasy, and the tactical battle screens use clear, distinguishable icons for creatures and terrain features. Even today, it’s easy to read the battlefield at a glance, which is crucial for planning your next move.

Heroes II and its expansion take a step forward with more detailed unit sprites and richer backgrounds. Each faction’s architecture and creature designs have greater variety, from the gothic towers of the Necropolis to the sun-lit spires of the Castle. Animations are limited by today’s standards, yet each movement and attack frame is carefully crafted to convey personality—dragons roar, elementals shimmer, and barbarians swing their axes with gusto.

King’s Bounty retains a simpler aesthetic, but its map tiles and character portraits remain evocative. The fog of war effect, rolling hills, and woodcut-style menus all contribute to a sense of exploration and discovery. Though the graphics feel dated alongside modern strategy games, they serve their purpose perfectly: they make gameplay intuitive, support the strategic layer, and preserve the nostalgia factor that longtime fans cherish.

Story

The Compendium’s narrative scope spans from the classic high-fantasy rivalry between good and evil to political intrigue and personal vendettas. In Heroes of Might and Magic, you follow a straightforward struggle as your hero liberates towns, defeats enemy lords, and ultimately confronts a powerful overlord. This archetypal storyline is delivered through in-game text and animated cutscenes that, while simple, effectively set the stage for epic battles.

Heroes II: The Succession Wars expands the lore with multiple perspectives. You can play as the noble queen Catherine Ironfist, the scheming duke Slava, or the exiled sorceress Elena. Each campaign reveals different facets of the central conflict, and decisions you make can lead to divergent outcomes. The Price of Loyalty adds further intrigue by testing your allegiances: do you remain faithful to your dying king or seize power for yourself? These branching storylines keep players invested beyond the battlefield.

King’s Bounty offers a more modest narrative but still provides memorable moments. You take on quests from a benevolent king, confront roaming bandits, and discover magical artifacts that hint at a broader mythos. While not as densely written as its successors, King’s Bounty’s storyline feels personal and charming—perfect for a prequel that lays the groundwork for the Heroes series.

Overall Experience

The Heroes of Might and Magic Compendium stands as a monumental package for fans of turn-based strategy and fantasy role-playing. By bundling the first two games, a major expansion, and the original King’s Bounty, it offers an unparalleled retrospective on the series’ early evolution. Whether you’re a newcomer curious about the genre’s origins or a veteran seeking a nostalgic trip, this collection delivers depth, replayability, and timeless strategic challenges.

Reuse of classic soundtracks, intuitive controls, and a supportive community of modders ensure that these titles remain playable on modern systems. Steam Workshop and fan patches breathe new life into old maps, improve resolution scaling, and even introduce fresh AI scripts. The Compendium thus bridges the gap between retro appeal and contemporary convenience.

Admittedly, some elements—like the isometric perspective or lumbering unit animations—show their age, but these quirks contribute to the collection’s charm. If you appreciate thoughtful resource management, elaborate army compositions, and turn-by-turn tactics, the Heroes of Might and Magic Compendium is a treasure trove that stands the test of time.

Retro Replay Score

7/10