Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

The Telstar Double Value Games collection brings together two pioneering horror adventures—Alone in the Dark and Call of Cthulhu: Shadow of the Comet—under one price point. Alone in the Dark introduced polygonal character models in a 3D environment, combining fixed camera angles with tank‐style controls. Players must explore the Derceto mansion, solve inventory­-driven puzzles, and outwit supernatural foes. The deliberate pacing encourages methodical exploration, rewarding those who pay close attention to environmental clues and journal entries. Combat is somewhat rudimentary by modern standards, but its clunky charm adds to the tense atmosphere.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Shadow of the Comet, on the other hand, refines the formula with more nuanced interactions and a richer emphasis on traditional adventure mechanics. You assume the role of John Parker, a photographer drawn to the eerie town of Illsmouth. Inventory puzzles range from assembling period­-accurate devices to deciphering occult texts. Dialogue choices and character encounters lend additional depth, letting you steer investigations down different narrative paths. While still retaining occasional combat sequences, the focus here is squarely on investigation and survival.

In both titles, puzzle design balances intellectual challenge with a hint of trial and error. Players will shuttle between map locations, jotting down notes and combining items to unlock new areas. Although modern gamers might chafe at pixel hunting or backtracking, fans of classic adventure gaming will appreciate the deliberate pace. The compilation neatly packages both experiences, letting you tackle each game in succession or revisit your favorite scares in any order.

Graphics

Visually, these late­-’80s and early­-’90s titles reflect the era’s technological limitations while showcasing ambitious design. Alone in the Dark’s pre­rendered backgrounds provide richly detailed rooms, flickering candles, and looming portraiture that hint at dark secrets. Character models, while blocky and low­-res, move with an unsettling stiffness that amplifies the game’s uncanny atmosphere. Occasional graphical quirks—such as odd clipping or static lighting—serve as nostalgic reminders of early 3D experimentation.

Shadow of the Comet pushes the envelope further, with hand­painted backdrops that immerse you in a coastal New England town beset by cosmic dread. The use of dynamic weather effects, such as swirling mists and lightning flashes, heightens the sense of isolation. Cutscene illustrations recall Lovecraftian pulp covers, complete with grotesque creatures and inscrutable symbols. Resolution scaling on modern displays can sometimes stretch textures, but the core artistry shines through.

While neither title competes with contemporary graphical standards, the compilation’s presentation remains faithful to the originals. The menus and interstitial screens are reproduced in crisp digital forms, preserving the look and feel of vintage PC and console releases. For retro enthusiasts, this visual authenticity is a primary draw—each pixel and polygon evokes a time when horror gaming was still in its experimental infancy.

Story

Alone in the Dark opens on a stormy night as private investigator Edward Carnby responds to a frantic letter from Emily Hartwood, heir to the Derceto estate. From the moment you step into the creaking mansion, the game weaves a tale of occult manuscripts and restless spirits. Story unfolds through journal pages, cryptic notes, and atmospheric encounters with lurking terrors. The narrative’s minimalist approach—relying on suggestion rather than exposition—amplifies the horror, letting your imagination fill in the blanks.

Shadow of the Comet shifts focus to an outsider’s descent into madness. John Parker arrives in Illsmouth to photograph Halcyon’s Observatory before Halley’s Comet makes its rare appearance. He soon uncovers a community steeped in cult rituals and forbidden knowledge. Through journal entries, dialogue with eccentric townsfolk, and lore­-laden documents, the game gradually reveals the cosmic stakes at play. The pacing allows suspense to build slowly, culminating in a finale that stays true to Lovecraft’s themes of infinite, uncaring universes.

Together, these two narratives showcase the evolution of horror storytelling in games. Alone in the Dark laid the groundwork with isolated manors and restless spirits, while Shadow of the Comet expanded the scope to cosmic horror and investigative nuance. Playing both back­to­back offers a fascinating journey—one that highlights how developers experimented with pacing, environmental storytelling, and player agency within the genre’s early days.

Overall Experience

The Telstar Double Value Games package delivers tremendous bang for the buck. Both titles have been essential to the horror adventure canon, and this compilation offers newcomers a chance to experience them affordably. The user interface remains as it was on original hardware, preserving the period charm without imposing unnecessary modern overlays. For players seeking a nostalgia trip or a historical deep dive, this release is hard to beat.

Replayability stems from the inherent mystery in each game and the satisfaction of piecing together cryptic clues. While puzzle solutions remain static, experimenting with different approaches and re­examining dark corners of the mansion or the town can unearth small narrative details you missed the first time. The dual­-game format also breaks up longer play sessions, allowing you to bounce between two distinct forms of horror.

Ultimately, this compilation stands as a testament to the ingenuity of early horror game designers. The blend of exploration, puzzle­solving, and atmospheric tension laid the foundation for countless successors. Whether you’re a seasoned genre fan or curious about horror’s roots, Telstar’s Double Value Games offers a compelling, historically significant experience that remains genuinely unsettling—even decades after their initial release.

Retro Replay Score

null/10