Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

The Clue! delivers a richly detailed crime simulation where you step into the shoes of Matt Stuvysant, a resourceful outsider determined to rise through London’s underworld. From the moment you secure your first hideout and assemble your initial crew, the game presents a layered system of choices—selecting targets based on security level, evaluating the skills of your accomplices, and allocating resources such as lockpicks, disguises, and getaway vehicles. Each decision has tangible consequences, requiring you to think several moves ahead to avoid the watchful eyes of law enforcement.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

As you progress from petty shoplifting to the audacious theft of the Crown Jewels, The Clue! gradually unlocks new mechanics that keep the gameplay loop engaging. You’ll research guard routines, scout building layouts, and liaise with fences to dispose of stolen goods. A real-time planning interface lets you assign roles, synchronize entry points, and even schedule distractions—offering a satisfying sense of control over every detail of the operation. Failures are instructive rather than punitive, encouraging you to refine your approach without punishing restarts.

Beyond individual heists, an open-ended campaign structure allows for emergent strategies. Do you invest profits in bribing informants, upgrading your safehouse, or recruiting specialists like hackers and forgers? Balancing short-term gains against long-term expansion adds a strategic layer that will appeal to fans of management sims. Whether you prefer meticulous planning or daring improvisation, the game’s systems adapt to your style, ensuring each playthrough feels distinct and rewarding.

Graphics

The Clue! features a stylish isometric presentation that captures a gritty, late-19th-century London in sumptuous detail. Cobblestone streets glisten under lamplight, and fog rolls in to obscure your nighttime excursions. Character sprites are well-animated, from the nervous glance of a lone shopkeeper to the tense stance of patrolling constables. Subtle lighting effects highlight shadowy alleyways, enhancing both the atmosphere and the strategic importance of dark corners.

Buildings are rendered with an impressively high level of interactivity: windows can be shimmed open, skylights slide aside, and even trapdoors can be located if you’ve gathered enough blueprints. Interior rooms feature period-appropriate furnishings that sometimes double as hiding spots or improvised distractions. The UI is integrated seamlessly, with tooltips and planning overlays that never break immersion while providing clear, accessible information about your operations.

Sound design complements the visuals with ambient creaks, distant church bells, and the urgent clip-clop of horse-drawn carriages. A restrained musical score heightens tension during stakeouts and climaxes in pulse-pounding cues when things go sideways. Each sound effect is crisply recorded, making every lock-picking attempt and footstep a satisfying audio event—reinforcing the game’s emphasis on stealth and timing.

Story

At its core, The Clue! weaves an engaging narrative around Matt Stuvysant’s transformation from penniless outsider to criminal mastermind. The writing deftly balances drama and dark humor, as you interact with a cast of shady contacts, rival gangs, and a few sympathetic allies. Dialogue choices influence relationships, opening—or closing—avenues for collaboration and unique side missions that shed light on London’s hidden social strata.

Subplots enrich the main campaign, exploring themes of loyalty, ambition, and moral ambiguity. Should you betray an accomplice to secure a bigger payoff? Can you maintain honor within a dishonest profession? Decisions you make during key story beats ripple throughout the game, sometimes altering the demeanor of NPCs or unlocking alternate strategies for later heists. This branching structure ensures that your personal playthrough tells a unique tale of ambition and cunning.

Story pacing is handled expertly, with smaller burglaries serving as both tutorials and character-building moments before grander schemes unfold. Occasional cinematic interludes—sketched in stylish sepia tones—highlight pivotal escapes or dramatic betrayals, giving a cinematic flair without overshadowing the core gameplay. By the time you set your sights on the Tower of London, the protagonist’s journey feels earned and emotionally resonant.

Overall Experience

The Clue! offers a compelling fusion of strategy, simulation, and narrative that few crime games achieve. Its steady difficulty curve and flexible planning tools welcome newcomers, while its deep systems and branching story arcs provide ample challenges for seasoned tacticians. The blend of methodical heist preparation and dynamic in-mission adjustments creates an exhilarating tension that keeps you on the edge of your seat.

Replayability is a standout feature. With numerous accomplice types, varying security setups, and divergent story paths, each campaign differs significantly. Seeking a stealthy ghost-in-the-night approach yields a markedly different experience than a high-risk, high-reward smash-and-grab style. Side missions inject variety, giving you reasons to revisit earlier neighborhoods and test new tactics against familiar targets.

In sum, The Clue! is a must-play for fans of strategic crime dramas. Its immersive world-building, robust mechanics, and engaging storytelling coalesce into an experience that rewards careful planning and creative improvisation alike. Whether you’re aiming to run a small-time ring or pull off the heist of the century, this game offers hours of tense, satisfying gameplay that will leave you plotting your next covert operation long after the credits roll.

Retro Replay Score

7.6/10