Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

The Mystery Collection brings together six of Infocom’s finest interactive fiction titles under one CD-ROM, offering a rich tapestry of puzzles and detective work. Each game features the hallmark text parser that made Infocom legendary, allowing players to type natural-language commands and experiment freely with objects, characters, and environments. Whether you’re interrogating suspects in Deadline or navigating the haunted corridors of Lurking Horror, the intuitive verb-noun interface keeps you immersed in the action without breaking the narrative flow.

Depth of play varies from title to title, keeping the experience fresh across all six adventures. In Moonmist you chase clues through an English manor with multiple possible endings, while Sherlock: The Riddle of the Crown Jewels relies on period detail and logical deduction to recreate the world of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. The Witness and Suspect push you to thread together subtle hints and forensic evidence, demanding patience and careful note-taking. The built-in hint system can be enabled or disabled, so you can choose to sink or swim as you please.

Bonus games Planetfall and Zork Zero add even more variety, blending sci-fi comedy with epic fantasy in classic Infocom style. Planetfall’s spaceship exploration and heartfelt robot companion remain a high-point of emotional storytelling, while Zork Zero unfolds as a self-referential trilogy of quests packed with clever puzzles and playful map interfaces. If you ever find yourself stuck, the well-documented manuals and in-game help menus guide you back on track without spoiling the surprises.

Installation and play are straightforward on both Windows and DOS platforms, and Mac users will appreciate the compatible build that preserves the crisp text layout. Fast loading times, clear fonts, and customizable window sizes ensure that the focus stays on the words and the puzzles rather than technical hurdles. For modern systems, running under DOSBox or ScummVM is seamless, making The Mystery Collection a hassle-free retro treat.

Graphics

True to its interactive fiction roots, The Mystery Collection relies almost entirely on text for its storytelling, and any visual elements serve to support rather than overshadow the prose. A simple graphical shell surrounds the text window, complete with drop-down menus, scroll bars, and icon shortcuts for saving or restoring your game. This GUI wrapper looks clean in 256-color mode and never feels bloated or distracting.

Occasional static illustrations appear in the opening screens or as chapter headers, providing a touch of ambiance without interrupting the reading experience. These modest visuals capture the mood of each scenario—shadowy gables in Moonmist, Gothic silhouettes in Lurking Horror, and ornate engravings in Sherlock’s London. Fans of minimalist design will appreciate how every pixel is functional and evocative.

Sound effects are minimal but effective: the scratch of a pen when you write down clues in Suspect, the distant thunder rumble in Lurking Horror, or the triumphant chime when you unlock a door in Deadline. These audio cues, available in the Windows build, heighten immersion without becoming repetitive or intrusive. If you prefer pure text, the sounds can be muted at any time.

Overall, the graphical and audio presentation is purpose-built to complement text adventures. It neither tries to pass off old titles as modern blockbusters nor undercuts the power of your imagination. Instead, The Mystery Collection offers just enough visual polish to feel professional and accessible while allowing the writing to remain front and center.

Story

Infocom’s reputation was built on masterful storytelling, and this compilation is no exception. Deadline drops you into a tense drawing-room mystery where every word spoken by suspects could be a clue or a red herring. The pacing is taut and relentless—you must solve the crime before midnight or watch the culprit walk free. It’s a lesson in economy of prose and dramatic timing.

Lurking Horror transports you to a snowed-in university campus beset by otherworldly terrors. The mood is thick with dread, and the narrative unfolds like a Lovecraftian novella, with creeping suspense and revelation of forbidden knowledge. By contrast, Moonmist weaves a lighter, almost Gothic romance-mystery with multiple solutions and secret identities. The variety of atmospheres across the six main games ensures that you’re never stuck in one emotional register for too long.

Sherlock: The Riddle of the Crown Jewels invites you to don the deerstalker and pistol-whip with logic, delivering a meticulously researched Victorian adventure filled with period detail and historical cameos. Suspect and The Witness, set in a modern art gallery and a wealthy estate respectively, challenge you to piece together forensic evidence through dialogue trees and object manipulation. Each story is meticulously crafted, with branching paths and red herrings that reward perseverance and creativity.

The bonus titles Planetfall and Zork Zero showcase Infocom’s lighter side. Planetfall’s comedic sci-fi plot is punctuated by genuine emotional stakes that build to a famously touching finale, while Zork Zero’s self-aware humor and sprawling quest structure playfully riff on fantasy tropes. Together, these eight narratives form a showcase of interactive fiction’s range—from chilling horror to heartfelt comedy.

Overall Experience

The Mystery Collection stands as a definitive anthology for anyone interested in the golden age of text adventures. By packaging six standout titles plus two beloved bonuses, Infocom has delivered exceptional value for both newcomers and long-time fans. You’ll get dozens of hours of high-quality storytelling and puzzle-solving, all wrapped in a polished, user-friendly interface.

Technical requirements are minimal, and the cross-platform compatibility ensures you can play on Windows, DOS, or Macintosh with equal ease. The in-game hint system and adjustable parser settings let you tailor the difficulty to your taste, making the games accessible to casual players while still challenging veteran sleuths. For those who love to save, the generous undo and restore features encourage experimentation without penalty.

Although the graphics and sound are modest by modern standards, they never feel dated—rather, they serve as a respectful backdrop to the words and ideas that made Infocom famous. The mystery-lover in you will delight in dissecting motives, mapping hidden passages, and unlocking secret endings. And once you solve the main plot, replaying Moonmist or Deadline to chase alternate solutions adds significant longevity.

In an era when many adventure games chase flashy visuals, The Mystery Collection reminds us that the power of interactive fiction lies in its writing and its ability to engage the mind. If you’re looking for intellectually stimulating puzzles, memorable characters, and narratives that stick with you long after you type “quit,” this collection is a must-own for your gaming library.

Retro Replay Score

null/10