Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

X-Men II: The Fall of the Mutants offers a surprisingly deep gameplay loop for a late-80s title. Players begin by assembling a strike team of five X-Men from a roster of fifteen fan-favorite mutants. This roster variety encourages multiple playthroughs, as each character brings unique abilities—ranging from Cyclops’s optic blasts to Wolverine’s berserker rage—that can dramatically alter your tactical approach.

Once your team is assembled, exploration unfolds in a top-down RPG style. You navigate sprawling levels, searching for objectives and encountering NPCs who provide mission intel or reveal hidden areas. This exploration phase feels suitably “X-Men,” as it captures the sense of infiltration and crisis-management that defines the comics.

Combat transitions offer two distinct modes: side-scrolling action or turn-based RPG encounters. The side-scrolling segments let you control your mutants in real time, chaining special attacks and mastering jump-and-dodge maneuvers. In contrast, the turn-based system leans into resource and cooldown management, inviting strategic planning as you weigh each mutant’s power against the enemy’s vulnerabilities.

Graphics

Graphically, X-Men II strikes a good balance between detailed sprites and functional design. Character portraits and in-battle animations are faithful to the comic book aesthetics, delivering expressive pixel art that captures each mutant’s signature look. While the hardware limitations are evident, the game’s art direction does an admirable job of suggesting scale and drama.

The top-down maps are rendered in muted, atmospheric palettes—industrial complexes, city streets, and mutant strongholds all feel distinct. Subtle animations, such as flickering lights or moving machinery, reinforce a living world. Although some texture repetition occurs, the varied level themes keep exploration visually fresh.

During side-scrolling combat, power effects truly shine: Cyclops’s optic blast beams and Storm’s lightning strikes light up the screen with satisfying clarity. These visual flourishes not only enhance the spectacle but also serve as clear feedback for successful attacks, which is crucial for an engaging action experience.

Story

Adapting the “Fall of the Mutants” storyline, the game places players in the heart of a world teetering on chaos. Cutscene interludes, presented via text and static images, outline a high-stakes narrative: the X-Men are hunted by a mysterious force, and mutants everywhere are being eradicated. This premise effectively conveys urgency and stakes, setting the tone for each mission.

Character interactions in brief dialogue exchanges allow for moments of comic-book banter. While dialogue is kept concise, it captures the personalities fans expect—Magneto’s moral ambiguity, Nightcrawler’s hopeful optimism, and Beast’s scientific curiosity each come through. These narrative beats weave into the gameplay, reminding players why they care about these heroes.

Mid-game plot twists, including betrayals and unexpected alliances, boost engagement by disrupting established strategies. Although the story structure can feel linear at times, the integration of narrative choices—such as which mission order to tackle—gives players a sense of agency within the larger arc.

Overall Experience

X-Men II: The Fall of the Mutants delivers a robust blend of action and strategy that stands out among its contemporaries. The dual combat systems mean you can tailor sessions to your preferred pace: jump into dynamic side-scrolling brawls or settle into calculated turn-based showdowns. This flexibility greatly enhances replay value.

While the graphics and sound reflect the era’s technical limits, the game’s faithful character art and evocative soundtrack successfully evoke the mood of the X-Men universe. Occasional loading pauses and repetitive enemy encounters are minor detractors in an otherwise polished package.

For fans of the comics and retro gamers seeking a hybrid RPG/action experience, X-Men II: The Fall of the Mutants remains a compelling choice. Its combination of team customization, strategic depth, and faithful storytelling makes it a must-play for those curious about classic superhero gaming.

Retro Replay Score

null/10