Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Kelly Slater’s Pro Surfer immediately tosses you into the swell with a streamlined control scheme that feels both accessible and deep. Drawing from the familiar Activision O2 brand template, the game’s controls are intuitive: carve, pump, and launch tricks with button combinations that quickly become second nature. Whether you’re a newcomer testing the waters in Infinite Time mode or a high-score chaser with the clock ticking in High Score mode, the mechanics reward timing, precision, and creativity.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The Career Mode underpins much of the replay value, as you select from a roster of surfing legends—including Kelly Slater, Lisa Andersen, and Rob Machado—and embark on a global tour. As you accrue points and complete Icon Challenges, you unlock new boards, trick animations, and hidden beaches. This progression loop keeps you motivated to return wave after wave, chasing a more perfect line or stringing together that elusive combo.

Multiplayer amplifies the fun with several versatile competitive options. Push mode turns the split screen into a tug-of-war, with players “pushing” their opponent off-screen by racking up points. Head to Head lets you duel in a time-limited showdown, while Time Attack introduces a strategic twist: the more you score, the less time your rival has on their attempt. Together, these modes ensure that Kelly Slater’s Pro Surfer thrives as both a solo and social experience.

Graphics

Visually, the game delivers convincing water physics and beautifully rendered breaks. Waves crest and break with realistic spray and foam, and the shifting sunlight on the sea surface showcases an impressive draw distance for its era. From the translucent tubes of Pipeline to the dark, foreboding swells of Mavericks, each break carries a distinct mood that enhances immersion as you drop into the lineup.

Character models of the pro surfers are crisp and recognizable, complete with signature riding styles. Trick animations flow smoothly—whether you’re snapping off a quick floater or launching into an aerial shuffle, the transitions look natural and fluid. Ambient details, such as distant boats, crashing rocks, and distant seagulls, help reinforce the illusion that you’re chasing legendary swells in exotic locales.

The PS2 version’s inclusion of a playable Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 4 demo is a bonus visual treat, offering early glimpses of polygonal cityscapes and skatepark lighting that complement the surfing environments. Although texture resolutions show their age by modern standards, the art direction and overall palette remain vibrant, delivering a sun-drenched world that beckons you back wave after wave.

Story

Kelly Slater’s Pro Surfer lacks a narrative in the traditional sense but crafts a sense of journey through its Career Mode framework. You start as an up-and-coming surfer, choosing from a lineup of pros and unlocking new talent as hidden characters. Each new beach you conquer adds to the unfolding story of your rise through the ranks, offering a form of structured progression that feels rewarding.

The “story beats” emerge organically as you tackle Icon Challenges at each venue. Maybe it’s collecting a series of icons scattered along the reef at Teahupoo or stringing together high-value tricks at J-Bay before the timer expires. Meeting these objectives simulates the adrenaline of real-world competitions and lends context to your worldwide expedition.

Ultimately, the narrative backbone in Kelly Slater’s Pro Surfer is about personal achievement and exploration. There’s no cut-scene drama or dialogue trees—just you, your board, and the world’s most famous breaks. This minimalist approach focuses your attention squarely on the thrill of the ride and the satisfaction of mastering each new wave.

Overall Experience

Kelly Slater’s Pro Surfer stands out as a standout sports title that captures the exhilaration of big-wave surfing while offering enough depth to sustain repeated play sessions. The combination of accessible controls, diverse game modes, and a robust roster of pro athletes ensures there’s something for both casual players and hardcore score chasers.

The varied environments—from the icy barrels of Antarctica to the jungle-fringed reefs of G-Land—provide constant visual and gameplay variety. Unlocking new boards and tricks via Career Mode gives tangible goals that keep you invested, while the multiplayer suite guarantees high replayability when challenging friends.

Whether you’re drawn by the allure of hidden beaches, the competitive edge of Icon Challenges, or simply the joy of carving virtual waves, Kelly Slater’s Pro Surfer delivers a complete package. For anyone curious about surfing or seeking a spirited sports game with global flair, this title remains a must-ride classic.

Retro Replay Score

7.7/10