Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Tales of Monkey Island: Chapter 3 – Lair of the Leviathan builds upon the series’ signature point-and-click formula with a few welcome twists. Instead of treasure hunting, players must learn and employ a set of pirate grimaces to navigate obstacles, adding a surprising layer of physical comedy to standard inventory puzzles. While the bulk of the puzzles still revolve around combining items and interacting with the environment, the pirate grimace mechanic injects fresh variety into Guybrush’s toolbox.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The movement system continues to deviate from classic adventure titles: instead of simply clicking to move, you hold the left mouse button and drag to guide Guybrush, or use the keyboard for more precise control. This proves handy when backtracking between the various set pieces, from Coronado De Cava’s pirate stronghold to the dank underbellies of La Esponja Grande. Though it takes a moment to acclimate, the fluidity of motion ultimately tightens the pacing and reduces frustration during long puzzle chains.

Dialogue puzzles form a larger share of Lair of the Leviathan’s challenges, placing more emphasis on eavesdropping, bartering, and using witty retorts to unlock new information. Fans of the series will appreciate how well these verbal sparring matches capture the spirit of Monkey Island’s repartee, while newcomers may find themselves chuckling as they out-wit adversaries with a clever line or two. The balance of traditional item-based puzzles and dialogue-driven encounters creates a satisfying rhythm that keeps the adventure moving without overstaying its welcome.

Graphics

Visually, Chapter 3 remains consistent with the vibrant, cartoon-inspired aesthetic that defines the Tales of Monkey Island series. Backgrounds are richly detailed—from the barnacled hull of Guybrush’s manatee-devoured ship to the ornate filigree of Coronado De Cava’s lair—each location brimming with hidden gags and environmental storytelling. Subtle animations, like flickering lanterns and shifting shadows, breathe life into otherwise static painted backdrops.

Character models benefit from expressive facial work, ensuring that every pirate grimace carries comedic weight. Guybrush himself is as lanky and earnest as ever, while supporting characters are equally animated in their gestures and vocal performance. The color palette transitions seamlessly between the sun-bleached decks of the Caribbean and the murky depths of the Leviathan’s domain, helping to underscore shifts in mood and narrative tension.

Performance is smooth on both PC and console, with quick load times and no noticeable frame-rate dips, even in the more elaborate set pieces. Subtle visual effects—such as rippling water, bioluminescent sea creatures, and the jittery glow of underwater caverns—are rendered crisply without overshadowing the hand-drawn charm that fans have come to expect. Overall, the graphics strike an ideal balance between playful cartoon styling and immersive world design.

Story

Lair of the Leviathan picks up immediately after the dramatic cliffhanger of Episode 2, with Guybrush’s ship swallowed whole by a giant manatee. This surreal opener sets the tone for an adventure that is equal parts whimsy and peril. The introduction of Coronado De Cava—a charismatic, rhyming pirate with dubious loyalties—brings fresh dynamics to the ensemble, keeping interactions lively and unpredictable.

The narrative maintains momentum with a clear objective: follow the trail of La Esponja Grande and uncover the secrets it holds. Along the way, Guybrush’s trademark humor remains front and center, delivering witty quips, pop culture nods, and well-timed slapstick. Secondary characters, from disgruntled sea monsters to conniving cutthroats, enrich the plot with their own agendas and comedic flairs, ensuring that every conversation is memorable.

Despite the episodic structure, Chapter 3 feels self-contained, offering satisfying mini-arcs even as it builds toward the larger season finale. The pacing is tight, rarely lingering too long on any single puzzle or dialogue beat. Whether you’re uncovering hidden lairs, negotiating with leviathans or decoding pirate grimaces, the story consistently rewards curiosity and a healthy sense of mischief.

Overall Experience

As the midpoint of the five-part Tales of Monkey Island saga, Lair of the Leviathan delivers a well-balanced blend of humor, puzzle-solving, and narrative momentum. Longtime fans will delight in references to classic series moments, while new players can jump in with little confusion thanks to smart design and occasional recaps. The absence of traditional treasure-hunt puzzles is more than compensated by the inventive pirate grimace mechanic.

The voice acting, led by Dominic Armato as Guybrush Threepwood, remains top-notch, capturing the spirit of Monkey Island’s golden era. Music and sound design evoke the Caribbean’s salty breeze and creaking timbers, immersing you in a pirate’s life that’s both rollicking and mysterious. With varied locales, inventive obstacles, and a host of colorful characters, the chapter never feels repetitive.

In summary, Lair of the Leviathan shines as a mid-season highlight, raising the stakes and keeping the series’ trademark wit in fine form. Its blend of dialogue-heavy puzzles, fluid movement, and charming visuals makes it a standout episode that will leave players eager for Chapter 4. For anyone seeking a clever, laughter-filled adventure on the high seas, this installment is well worth boarding.

Retro Replay Score

8.1/10