Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

What Makes You Tick? delivers a classic point-and-click adventure experience that will feel instantly familiar to fans of 1990s LucasArts titles. The game is controlled entirely with the mouse: simply click and hold on interactive elements to bring up a verb menu offering options to Examine, Pick Up/Use, or Talk. This straightforward interface makes it easy to dive into the puzzles without wrestling with complex controls.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Puzzles range from inventory-based challenges—combining odd items found around Dr. Coppelius’s home—to dialogue-driven tasks where you must choose the right questions to coax information from eccentric characters. While none of the puzzles are so obtuse that you’ll spend hours stuck in a single room, they still require careful observation and a willingness to experiment with every clickable hotspot.

One of the strengths of the LASSIE engine is its smooth, responsive point-and-click mechanics. Animations play out fluidly when you use an item on an object or character, and the game never slows down during inventory juggling or dialogue sequences. For a freeware title, the level of polish in the interaction design is impressive, making each action feel weighty and satisfying.

Graphics

Visually, What Makes You Tick? wears its influences on its sleeve, borrowing heavily from The Curse of Monkey Island’s art style. Backgrounds are rendered in rich, hand-painted hues that capture the shady, cluttered atmosphere of Dr. Coppelius’s residence. From dusty bookshelves to creaky floorboards, every backdrop is packed with details encouraging you to click and explore.

The character sprites are charmingly expressive, even if they’re limited to a handful of frames. Nathan, our shy but determined protagonist, gestures nervously when examining objects, while Dr. Coppelius’s voice recordings play over mostly static portraits that shift subtly in reaction to dialogue choices. These small touches lend personality to each scene without the need for full animation sequences.

The inventory bar and mouse cursor are nearly indistinguishable from those in Monkey Island, down to the slight drop shadow on interactive icons. Some players might view this as derivative, but in practice, the familiar UI feels comfortable and intuitive. The overall visual package may not push technical boundaries, but its nostalgic appeal and cohesive aesthetic more than make up for any lack of next-gen effects.

Story

At its heart, What Makes You Tick? is a mystery inspired by E.T.A. Hoffmann’s 1817 tale Der Sandmann. The narrative kicks off when the revered Dr. Coppelius vanishes without a trace, prompting the university to dispatch Nathan to his last known address. The goal is simple: uncover the circumstances behind the doctor’s disappearance before time runs out.

As Nathan pokes around the dusty mansion, he unearths fragments of Coppelius’s research into the human mind—experiments that blur the line between science and the supernatural. The dialogue is peppered with references to Hoffmann’s original tale, giving the story a dream‐like quality. Small details, such as an ominous music box or a dusty journal entry, hint at darker forces at work beyond mere academic ambition.

While the plot unfolds over a relatively brief runtime (expect around 1–2 hours of play), it hits all the classic adventure beats: eerie atmospherics, eccentric supporting characters, and a twist that reframes earlier events in a new light. For players seeking a concise, self-contained mystery, the narrative delivers enough intrigue and surprises to keep you engaged from start to finish.

Overall Experience

What Makes You Tick? stands out as a lovingly crafted freeware adventure that punches well above its weight. The game’s short length means there’s minimal filler—every room, object, and conversation serves the central mystery. This tight pacing ensures that even casual players will feel motivated to keep clicking until the final revelation.

The combination of familiar interface mechanics, nostalgic pixel art, and Hoffmann-inspired storytelling makes the game a delight for anyone who grew up on classic point-and-click adventures. At the same time, its straightforward puzzles and clear objectives make it accessible to newcomers curious about the genre’s golden age.

While it may not boast advanced graphics or sprawling environments, What Makes You Tick? delivers a complete, polished package that feels more like a paid indie release than a free hobby project. For budget-conscious gamers or adventure enthusiasts looking for a quick, engaging mystery, this title is a must-play.

Retro Replay Score

8/10