Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

NES Play Action Football delivers a robust arcade-style football experience that balances simplicity with strategic depth. Players choose from eight city-based teams—each stocked with real NFL players from the 1989 season thanks to the NFL Player’s Association license. Even without the official NFL team names, the authentic rosters and player substitutions for quarterback, running back, wide receiver, tight end, and safety positions add a layer of realism, letting you swap in fresh “second-stringers” when fatigue sets in.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The playbook is surprisingly deep for an NES title. On offense you have 12 passing plays and 12 running plays, and each design can be reversed, effectively giving you up to 48 unique options to keep opponents guessing. Defensively, eight coverage schemes and eight blitz packages allow you to match your tactics to your opponent’s tendencies. This level of variety ensures that each drive feels distinct and that mastering the playbook is key to outwitting friends or the AI.

The control scheme is intuitive: directional pad movement, a pass button, a run button, and dedicated commands for blitz or coverage. Kicking and punting use the classic directional arrow and power-meter setup, offering a satisfying test of timing and precision. With four accelerated 15-minute quarters and no in-game penalties, the action stays brisk—referees still appear to signal touchdowns, take measurements, and announce “First Down!” in voice samples, keeping the game atmosphere lively.

Graphics

Visually, NES Play Action Football stands out with a unique three-quarters tilt perspective that places you just behind the offense. The diagonal scrolling—from the bottom left to the upper right of the screen—feels smooth and dynamic, giving a clear view of both the line of scrimmage and breaking defenders. This pseudo-3D angle was ambitious for the NES and still looks compelling today.

Player sprites are chunky but well-defined, each team’s colors contrasting nicely against the green gridiron. You can easily pick out your quarterback dropping back or your halfback powering through gaps. The field markings, end zones, and sidelines are crisp, and on-screen animations—like referees marking a first down or players celebrating a touchdown—add personality without slowing the frame rate.

Although the stadium backgrounds are fairly minimal, the scrolling crowds and occasional cheer animations contribute to the game-day atmosphere. Sound effects like the quarterback’s snap, the thud of tackles, and the referee’s whistle are punchy, while the celebratory fanfare after a score keeps the excitement high. Overall, the graphics push the NES hardware to deliver an enjoyable, fast-paced sports presentation.

Story

As a sports simulation on the NES, Play Action Football doesn’t feature a traditional narrative campaign or character arcs. Instead, its “story” emerges through the league structure and the journey to the Power Bowl. You guide your chosen city’s team through the regular season and into playoff matchups, chasing the ultimate championship trophy.

The absence of penalties keeps the focus squarely on on-field action and your play-calling prowess. Quarter after quarter, you build momentum with big drives, nail-turning defensive stands, and last-second field goals. Each victory advances you toward the Power Bowl, where the drama of sudden-death matchups and bracket eliminations fuels a mini-tournament epic more engaging than many storylines found in modern sports titles.

Although there’s no cutscene-driven storyline, the combination of licensed player names and the NFLPA endorsement creates its own narrative authenticity. Fans of ’80s NFL rosters will appreciate lining up Joe Montana against Boomer Esiason, imagining the head-to-head legends of that era. The game’s pacing and playoff mechanics weave an emergent story that feels personal and competitive every time you power on your console.

Overall Experience

NES Play Action Football remains one of the most memorable gridiron titles on the NES. Its blend of accessible controls, strategic play-calling, and authentic rosters delivers a satisfying kickoff-to-kneel experience. Whether you’re a solo player facing increasingly tough AI defenses or competing head-to-head with a friend, the game’s fast quarters and varied playbook keep each session fresh.

The lack of penalties and limited camera zoom can feel a bit arcade-like compared to modern football sims, but that simplicity is part of the charm. The game moves at a brisk pace, and learning to read defensive formations or nail the perfect power-meter kick becomes an addictive challenge. On top of that, the diagonal scrolling perspective and crisp sprites give it a visual identity that still holds up.

For collectors and retro sports aficionados, NES Play Action Football is a must-have. Its unique angle on football action, combined with real 1989 NFL players and a playoff mode culminating in the Power Bowl, offers depth without overwhelming newcomers. If you’re looking for quick pick-up-and-play thrills or a head-to-head rivalry to settle old scores, this NES classic continues to deliver gridiron glory.

Retro Replay Score

6/10