Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Shadow of the Colossus delivers a bold, singular gameplay loop that centers entirely on seeking out and defeating sixteen colossal beings. From the moment you step into the Forbidden Lands on Agro’s back, the game funnels you into a series of epic one-on-one battles, each feeling like a self-contained platforming puzzle. There are no hordes of enemies or fetch quests to distract you—just the vast, open world and the towering colossi that inhabit it.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Traversal is a core element of the experience. Riding Agro across sweeping plains, through arid deserts, and among ancient ruins creates a strong sense of scale and isolation. The sword you carry emits a guiding glow when you’re near a colossus, but otherwise, you’re left to interpret the landscape and landmarks on your own. The world feels alive and expansive, yet devoid of traditional threats, reinforcing the weight of your mission.

Combat is a graceful blend of action and strategy. Each colossus presents a unique challenge: some lumber slowly but are heavily armored, while others dart across rocky terrain or take to the water. You’ll need to time jumps, grip tufts of fur, and find creative ways to exploit environmental features. In addition to the sword, a bow allows for ranged attacks, luring beasts into traps or weakening their defenses before you make your climb.

Graphics

Shadow of the Colossus stands out visually with its minimalist yet breathtaking art direction. The Forbidden Lands are rendered in muted earth tones, punctuated by dramatic lighting that bathes ruins, cliffs, and valleys in golden hues at dawn and dusk. The result is a hauntingly beautiful world that feels ancient and mysterious.

The design of each colossus is a testament to the game’s attention to detail. From the moss-covered armor plates to the sinewy movements of their limbs, these giants exude presence and weight. Animations are fluid, whether a colossus is shaking you off its back or pawing at the ground in frustration. Even the smallest gesture—like the glint of light on a horn—adds to the realism.

Environmental effects further enhance immersion. Gusting winds stir tumbleweeds across the plains, swirling dust in desert arenas, and gentle ripples in lakes where watery colossi emerge. Though the palette is restrained, the shifting weather and changing light create a living backdrop that feels both timeless and dynamic.

Story

At its core, Shadow of the Colossus weaves a poignant tale of love, sacrifice, and ancient magic. A young man ventures into forbidden territory carrying the body of a cursed woman, pleading with the godlike entity Dormin to restore her soul. This simple premise unfolds without lengthy cutscenes or dialogue, relying instead on atmosphere and context to convey emotion.

The sparse storytelling leaves much to interpretation. Dormin’s cryptic warnings about the laws of mortality hint at dire consequences, yet the hero’s unwavering determination keeps him pressing forward. This ambiguity invites players to question the morality of their quest: is resurrection worth the price, and who will ultimately pay it?

Connections to ICO, the game’s companion title, deepen the lore for those familiar with the franchise. Shadow of the Colossus serves as a prequel, filling in backstory while maintaining its own identity. The result is a narrative that feels both epic and intimate, encouraging repeated reflection long after the final colossus falls.

Overall Experience

Shadow of the Colossus offers an emotional journey unlike most action-adventure games. The contrast between the serene beauty of the Forbidden Lands and the heart-pounding intensity of colossus battles creates a powerful sense of solitude and purpose. You’re never overwhelmed by enemies, but each boss fight demands your full attention.

Pacing is deliberate: long stretches of exploration build anticipation, then culminate in monumental clashes. This rhythm keeps each encounter feeling monumental, and the satisfaction of overcoming a seemingly invincible foe is unparalleled. The absence of traditional collectibles or side quests focuses the experience on its core narrative and gameplay pillars.

While some players may crave more variety in side activities, the game’s unwavering commitment to its central premise is its greatest strength. Every element—gameplay, visuals, and story—serves the mission of slaying the colossi to reclaim a lost soul. If you’re seeking a game that challenges both your reflexes and your emotions, Shadow of the Colossus stands as a masterpiece of interactive art.

Retro Replay Score

8.8/10