Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Broken Sword 2.5: The Return of the Templars faithfully preserves the classic point-and-click mechanics that endeared the original titles to adventure fans. Movement is handled entirely with the mouse, and the cursor intelligently shifts to indicate available interactions when you hover over hotspots. This intuitive interface feels right at home for veterans, yet remains accessible for newcomers seeking a taste of traditional 2D adventure gameplay.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The inventory system is straightforward and user-friendly, allowing players to inspect, combine, or use items with a simple click. Dialogue trees are represented by icons featuring either characters’ portraits or relevant objects, making it easy to select conversation topics without hunting through text menus. Occasional trial-and-error puzzles and an unforgiving “you can die” mechanic add a welcome touch of tension that keeps you on your toes throughout George and Nico’s globe-trotting investigation.

One of the strongest gameplay elements is the ability to alternate control between George Stobbart and Nico Collard. This dynamic shifts not only the perspective on puzzles—sometimes requiring cooperative thinking between the duo—but also the narrative stakes. Fans of the series will appreciate the clever callbacks to earlier puzzles, while new settings and fresh challenges ensure that Broken Sword 2.5 doesn’t feel like a mere rehash.

Graphics

Visually, Broken Sword 2.5 embraces a lovingly hand-painted 2D aesthetic that recalls the first two official games. Each background is meticulously detailed, from the café tables of Paris to the shadowy crypts where Neo-Templar secrets lie buried. The vibrant color palettes and atmospheric lighting effects give every scene a rich, storybook quality that enhances the sense of adventure.

Character portraits and on-screen sprites remain true to the franchise’s iconic look, yet benefit from smoother animations and more expressive facial cues. The inclusion of fully rendered cut-scenes elevates key story beats, blending seamlessly with in-game graphics to maintain immersion. Even as a fan production, the polish here rivals many smaller commercial titles.

Audio design also stands out, with both German and English voice acting provided by seasoned performers, some reprising roles from the original games. Ambient sounds—from bustling café chatter to echoing temple drips—underscore the environments effectively. The musical score weaves in familiar motifs while introducing new themes, ensuring the game retains a cohesive Broken Sword identity.

Story

Picking up after the events of the first two games, Broken Sword 2.5 dives directly into intrigue when George returns from the U.S. to discover Nico apparently “dead” by telegram. This clever ruse sparks a tense reunion at Café della Chandelle Verte in Paris, immediately setting a tone of mystery and emotional complexity. The narrative quickly expands as Inspector André Lobineau reveals that the Neo-Templars may still be operating.

Players will travel to both familiar and brand-new locales—ancient catacombs, sun-drenched plazas, and secretive archives—accompanied by a cast of returning favorites and intriguing newcomers like Christophe Brai and English historian Jimmy McLaugh. Each character contributes to the unfolding puzzle, often providing essential clues or unexpected twists. The global scope of the hunt for Templar secrets gives the story an epic feel, while the interplay between George and Nico maintains a personal core.

The pacing strikes a satisfying balance between contemplative investigation and high-stakes drama. Clever dialogue delivers the series’ trademark wit, while voice performances infuse emotional weight into key moments. Although it’s a fan sequel, the storyline bridges directly into Broken Sword 3, offering long-time followers a rich sense of continuity and rewarding payoff.

Overall Experience

Broken Sword 2.5: The Return of the Templars is a remarkable fan-made achievement that stands shoulder-to-shoulder with the original classics. High production values—ranging from polished 2D art and rendered cut-scenes to professional voice performances—create an experience that feels both nostalgic and refreshingly new. Few fan projects match this level of quality or storytelling ambition.

For veterans of the Broken Sword franchise, 2.5 offers a satisfying bridge between the second and third official installments, filling narrative gaps and revisiting beloved mechanics. Newcomers will find an engaging introduction to point-and-click adventures, complete with modern usability enhancements and no small amount of humor. The blend of puzzle solving, exploration, and character-driven drama makes for a thoroughly engrossing journey.

Minor rough edges do appear—occasional pixel-perfect hotspots and the occasional translation quirk—but these pale in comparison to the game’s many strengths. Whether you’re a die-hard Templar hunter or simply seeking a well-crafted story-driven adventure, Broken Sword 2.5 delivers an experience that’s both heartfelt and thoroughly entertaining. Highly recommended for anyone looking to rekindle or discover the magic of classic 2D adventures.

Retro Replay Score

7.6/10