Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Downfall delivers a classic point-and-click adventure experience, where every interaction unfolds new horrors. Players navigate Joe Davis—and later other characters—through more than 70 meticulously hand-drawn locations. The mouse-driven controls are intuitive: left-click to interact, right-click to examine, and an inventory system that allows combining or deploying items in the environment. This simplicity keeps the focus squarely on exploration and puzzle-solving.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The puzzles in Downfall strike a fine balance between challenge and fairness. Items often require creative combinations, and clues are tucked away in obscure corners or whispered through cryptic notes. While some players may occasionally find themselves hunting for that one elusive hotspot, the sense of accomplishment upon solving each enigma enhances the game’s tension and pacing.

Horror elements permeate every corner of the gameplay loop. As Joe traverses the Quiet Haven Hotel, sudden jumpscares and unsettling noises keep you on edge, while the inability to save at any point adds a layer of vulnerability. Switching between characters introduces fresh perspectives on the hotel’s mysteries, ensuring that each playthrough portion feels distinct and increasingly unnerving.

Graphics

One of Downfall’s standout features is its striking hand-drawn art style. Many scenes are rendered in stark black and white, with only subtle washes of color to guide the eye. Blood-red splashes punctuate crucial moments, delivering visceral shocks that break the monochrome in the most dramatic fashion. This bold palette choice amplifies the sense of dread, making every corridor and door frame feel oppressive.

The Quiet Haven Hotel itself is a marvel of horror design. Dimly lit hallways, flickering lights, and storm-lashed windows set the stage for a claustrophobic exploration. Each of the 70+ locations is densely packed with details—peeling wallpaper, cryptic messages scrawled on bathroom walls, and surreal party sequences where guests stand frozen in time. These visual touches constantly reinforce the hotel’s otherworldly nature.

Animation is handled with restraint to maximize impact. Subtle sways, a twitch of a curtain in the wind, or a sudden smear of blood across a doorway heighten the atmosphere without resorting to over-the-top effects. The inventory icons and UI elements are clean and functional, ensuring that essential information never gets lost in the shadows of the art.

Story

At its core, Downfall tells a deeply unsettling tale of Joe and Ivy Davis, a couple seeking refuge from a raging storm. When Ivy’s panic attack spirals out of control, she disappears into the labyrinthine Quiet Haven Hotel, leaving Joe alone to confront whispers from the walls and the eerie semblance of a birthday party gone wrong. This premise immediately hooks players with its blend of psychological and supernatural horror.

The narrative unfolds in layers, revealed through environmental storytelling, scattered documents, and fragmented dreams experienced by both the living and the dead. Party guests stand silent, the birthday girl weeps endlessly, and voices echo from behind wallpaper—each fragment builds toward a disquieting climax. Encountering multiple playable characters deepens the plot, offering various angles on the hotel’s tragic history.

The strength of Downfall’s story lies in its ambiguity. You may never fully unravel every mystery, but the sense of dread and curiosity keeps you pressing forward. Themes of isolation, mental illness, and the blurred line between reality and nightmare permeate every scene, making for a haunting, unforgettable narrative journey.

Overall Experience

Downfall is an immersive horror adventure that excels at creating an atmosphere of unrelenting tension. A storm rages outside as you tiptoe through haunted corridors, accompanied by subtle ambient sounds and disquieting whispers. The game’s pacing waxes and wanes effectively—quiet moments of exploration give way to sudden, heart-pounding scares that remind you why you ventured inside the Quiet Haven Hotel in the first place.

With over 70 hand-drawn locations to explore, Downfall offers substantial playtime for fans of the genre. While it occasionally dips into pixel-hunting territory, the overall design ensures that progression feels earned rather than arbitrary. The combination of tight inventory puzzles and environment-based clues means each discovery carries weight, and every step closer to the truth ratchets up the suspense.

For those drawn to indie horror and point-and-click adventures, Downfall represents a standout offering. Its unique art direction, layered storytelling, and nerve-wracking gameplay blend into a cohesive whole that will linger in your nightmares long after the credits roll. Be prepared for explicit horror elements and a few spine-chilling surprises along the way—you won’t want to miss this descent into madness.

Retro Replay Score

7.5/10