Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

The Balance of Power Campaigns expansion builds on the tight, responsive dogfighting mechanics of the original X-Wing vs. TIE Fighter, offering a fresh set of challenges for both Rebel and Imperial pilots alike. The introduction of the B-Wing as the only new playable starfighter changes the tactical landscape: its heavy armament and unique gyrostabilizer demand a more strategic approach to dogfights and capital-ship assaults. Veteran players will appreciate how the B-Wing’s firepower encourages hit-and-run tactics and careful energy management, while newcomers get a taste of high-stakes piloting without being overwhelmed by too many new craft.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Mission design in each campaign feels thoughtfully paced. Early sorties focus on skirmishes with light fighters, giving pilots a chance to learn the B-Wing’s quirks before progressing to tackling enemy cruisers or the awe-inspiring Super Star Destroyer. The variety of objectives—from classic “escort the freighter” tasks to high-octane interdiction runs—keeps the action feeling fresh. Moreover, the add-on’s new melee and combat missions provide quick, arcade-style dogfights that are ideal for warming up to a longer campaign or jumping into multiplayer deathmatches.

AI behavior remains one of the expansion’s strongest points. Opposing pilots exhibit aggressive flanking maneuvers, formation flying, and coordinated attacks on high-value targets, making every mission a dynamic dance of offense and defense. Friendly wingmen are equally competent, often drawing enemy fire or covering blind spots in your attack pattern. This balance of challenge and support makes single-player sorties feel alive and unpredictable, a significant factor in the campaign’s replayability.

Graphics

Graphically, Balance of Power retains the crisp, detailed texture work and polygonal starship models that defined the era’s top flight simulators. While the engine shows its age by modern standards, the level of detail on capital ships—especially the looming Imperial Super Star Destroyer—remains a highlight. Seeing that massive silhouette materialize out of hyperspace never gets old, and the scale feels authentic in cockpit view, reinforcing the player’s place in the vastness of space warfare.

Environmental effects such as laser beams, explosions, and debris clouds are rendered cleanly, ensuring that even on lower-end hardware the action remains legible. The shimmering thruster trails and dynamic lighting from weapon fire help guide the player through chaotic engagements, preventing confusion during large-scale battles. Cutscenes interspersed throughout the campaign use pre-rendered models and voiceovers to set the scene; while simple by today’s standards, they seamlessly integrate story moments without pulling you too far out of the cockpit.

Color palettes in dust-filled asteroid belts, brightly lit capital-ship yards, and the black void punctuated by distant stars provide enough visual variety to distinguish each mission environment. The only notable downside is the occasional pop-in of distant ships at longer draw distances, but these moments are fleeting and rarely impact gameplay. Overall, the graphics strike a strong balance between performance and immersion for a late-’90s space sim add-on.

Story

The dual campaigns in Balance of Power offer a compelling narrative framework centered on the Airam Sector conflict between the Empire’s Avenger Squadron and the Rebels’ Rogue Squadron. By allowing players to experience mirrored missions from opposing perspectives, the expansion deepens the lore of the X-Wing universe, showcasing how each side’s victories and failures affect the broader struggle. This symmetrical approach encourages replays to appreciate both tactical mindsets and the unfolding political gambits.

Cutscenes bridge the story beats with brief but effective dialogue exchanges, mission briefings, and status reports from squadron leaders. While these segments lack cinematic flair compared to modern titles, the voice acting is earnest and well-paced, conveying the high stakes of the campaign. Hearing Alliance commanders strategize around limited resources or witnessing Imperial admirals coordinate massive cruiser deployments adds weight to each sortie beyond mere target lists on a HUD.

Subplots—such as a Rebel effort to rescue a downed operative behind enemy lines, or an Imperial push to quell insurgent activity around a resource-rich planet—add texture to the main narrative arc. These diversions feel more than filler: succeeding on side objectives often grants tangible rewards like additional wingmen or prototype weaponry. Such narrative-driven incentives motivate players to explore different tactical approaches rather than simply blasting through missions.

Overall Experience

As an expansion to a beloved space combat sim, Balance of Power delivers a satisfying dose of new content without overhauling the core mechanics that fans adore. The solitary addition of the B-Wing as a flyable craft keeps the learning curve manageable, while the presence of non-playable capital ships like the Super Star Destroyer provides dramatic set pieces that heighten mission stakes. This measured approach ensures the add-on feels substantial yet focused.

One of the standout qualities is the seamless transition between single-player and multiplayer modes. Every mission can be tackled cooperatively or competitively online, extending the longevity of the expansion well beyond its initial campaign runs. Even today, organizing custom multiplayer matches or communal melee brawls with friends preserves the high-octane thrill of Star Wars dogfighting.

Ultimately, Balance of Power is a must-have for fans of X-Wing vs. TIE Fighter seeking fresh challenges and narrative depth. Its balanced gameplay, serviceable graphics, engaging story, and emphasis on replayability combine to form an expansion that enriches the original package without altering its beloved formula. For anyone curious about deeper tactical skirmishes in the Star Wars universe, this add-on still holds up as a rewarding—and at times epic—space combat experience.

Retro Replay Score

7.4/10