Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

This compilation brings together two classic Star Wars flight experiences, offering a robust mix of simulation and arcade-style action. In Star Wars: X-Wing Alliance, you step into fully simulated cockpits, managing shields, weapons, and engines as you pilot iconic fighters like the X-wing and the Outbounder transport. Missions range from stealthy courier runs to large-scale fleet engagements, each demanding careful resource management and split-second decision-making.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

By contrast, Star Wars: Rogue Squadron 3D leans into fast-paced dogfighting on rails, with an emphasis on all-out combat and spectacular set pieces. Here, you’ll fly everything from speedy A-wings to heavy bombers, storming Imperial bases and escorting Rebel carriers across exotic planets. The mission designs are tight and focused, with clear objectives that keep the adrenaline pumping.

The control schemes in both titles feel surprisingly approachable, with keyboard-and-mouse options complemented by gamepad and joystick support. Rogue Squadron’s responsive handling makes strafing runs and barrel rolls a joy, while X-Wing Alliance’s deeper simulation elements reward players who master power distribution and target prioritization. Overall, this duo offers hours of varied challenges for flight sim veterans and newcomers alike.

Graphics

Originally built for late-’90s hardware, X-Wing Alliance’s polygonal starfields and textured ship models have a nostalgic charm. Although you won’t find modern lighting or ultra-high-resolution textures here, the compilation’s compatibility with contemporary displays means you can play at higher frame rates and resolutions than ever before, smoothing out the experience without altering the original art style.

Rogue Squadron 3D, a port of the beloved N64 title, retains its crisp, colorful environments and playful rendering style. Its low-poly geometry holds up surprisingly well when scaled to widescreen, and the vibrant planetary backdrops—from the icy fields of Hoth to the neon-lit spires of Coruscant—still captivate the eye. Occasional pop-in and rudimentary particle effects are reminders of its age, but they do little to dampen the fun.

Cockpit views in X-Wing Alliance are especially evocative, with flickering instrument panels and dynamic damage visuals that heighten the immersion. Rogue Squadron’s third-person camera offers sweeping vistas of combat zones, letting you appreciate starships streaking past as you unleash laser blasts. For fans of retro space battles, these visuals strike a perfect balance between authenticity and playability.

Story

Star Wars: X-Wing Alliance delivers one of the most personal Star Wars narratives ever released. You follow Corran Horn on a journey from freelance pilot to Rebel hero, intertwined with subplots about family, betrayal, and galactic politics. Voiceovers from veteran actors and in-engine cutscenes bring the saga to life, making each mission feel like a chapter in a larger epic.

Rogue Squadron 3D takes a more straightforward approach, centering on the exploits of Luke Skywalker’s famed unit. While the storyline here is lighter and more mission-driven—focused on undermining the Empire’s operations—the tight pacing and colorful mission briefings, complete with map overlays and squad chatter, inject plenty of narrative flair.

Both games weave in familiar Star Wars lore, featuring appearances by Admiral Ackbar, Mon Mothma, and classic villains like Darth Vader. The contrast between X-Wing Alliance’s character-driven plot and Rogue Squadron’s action-first progression means you get both the emotional stakes of a personal saga and the thrill of frontline skirmishes. It’s a winning combination for fans seeking depth and spectacle.

Overall Experience

This compilation is a treasure trove for anyone who longs to reclaim the golden era of Star Wars flight titles. With hundreds of missions across two distinct gameplay styles, it offers remarkable value and replayability. Whether you’re meticulously planning strikes in X-Wing Alliance or unleashing torpedoes in Rogue Squadron, the package delivers consistent thrills.

Minor quibbles include the lack of modern achievements or integrated leaderboards, and a few dated UI elements that can feel clunky by today’s standards. However, the core gameplay remains solid, and the ability to remap controls ensures you can tailor the experience to your preferred setup. Multiplayer options are limited, but the solo campaigns alone justify the purchase.

In the end, X-Wing Alliance & Rogue Squadron 3D stands as a lovingly preserved snapshot of Star Wars gaming history. It’s perfect for nostalgic veterans eager to revisit familiar battles, and for newcomers curious about the origins of the franchise’s airborne adventures. Strap into your cockpit, power up your targeting computer, and prepare to experience some of the most iconic dogfights in gaming lore.

Retro Replay Score

null/10