Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Challenge of the Five Realms places you in the role of the young Prince of Alonia, commanding a party of up to ten unique adventurers in a race against time. Character creation follows an Ultima-style questionnaire, where your responses shape your protagonist’s class—whether diplomat, warrior, thief, or wizard—and allocate starting attributes. This approach ensures that no two playthroughs feel exactly alike, rewarding players who enjoy tailoring every statistic from their party’s weapon proficiencies to their magical aptitudes.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The game’s immense skill system, reminiscent of later titles like Daggerfall, provides countless options for overcoming obstacles. You might bribe a corrupt official one day, pick a complex lock the next, or intimidate bandits in a dark forest. Side quests abound, but a creeping Plague of Darkness spreads across the Five Realms—tracked via an in-game map overlay—which forces you to strike a balance between exploration and the main objective.

One of Challenge of the Five Realms’ most innovative features is the PAL (Personalities and Learning) system. Each companion possesses a distinct temperament—aggressive, cautious, scholarly—and will volunteer for missions aligned with their strengths. This dynamic party management keeps you engaged, as you must decide when to harness a character’s special talents and when to rein them in for the greater good.

Graphics

Visually, Challenge of the Five Realms adheres to the classic 256-color VGA standard, showcasing richly detailed sprites and environments that evoke the high fantasy settings of the early ’90s. The isometric, top-down perspective offers a broad view of towns, dungeons, and wilderness areas, each rendered with enough variety that even returning to a familiar locale feels fresh. While the visuals have aged, the color palette still impresses with warm earth tones in forested glades and eerie purples in plague-ravaged lands.

Microprose’s art team injects personality into every screen: NPCs display distinct costumes, and monsters range from goblins and giant spiders to fearsome Plague-wraiths. Combat animations are functional rather than flashy, prioritizing clarity of action over bombast. Special effects—such as glowing spell projectiles or flickering torches—add atmosphere without overwhelming the hardware limitations of its era.

The interface balances form and function, with a status bar tracking party health, morale, and the advancing Plague of Darkness. Menus for inventory management and skill checks might feel dated to modern players, but they remain intuitive. Map overlays present real-time updates on infected territories, visually reinforcing the urgency behind every expedition.

Story

Subtitled Spellbound in the World of Nhagardia, the narrative thrust pits you against the malevolent Lord Grimnoth, whose dark magic has unleashed a plague threatening all five realms. As Prince of Alonia, your quest is both personal and epic: avenge your homeland, rally allies, and discover ancient secrets that can seal away the darkness. The storyline unfolds through in-game dialogue, journal entries, and environmental storytelling, evoking classic tabletop RPG campaigns.

Along your journey, you’ll traverse bustling market towns, haunted ruins, and perilous mountain passes. Encounters with sympathetic NPCs—refugees, rival princes, and enigmatic sages—provide side stories that flesh out the world of Nhagardia. Choices made in dialogue and allegiance can open up alternate quest paths, ensuring a degree of replayability uncommon for its time.

Despite some narrative clichés typical of high fantasy, the script surprises with moments of genuine humor and pathos. Characters in your party bicker, form bonds, and react differently to Grimnoth’s atrocities, thanks to the PAL system. Their evolving relationships add emotional weight to the ultimate showdown against the Plague of Darkness.

Overall Experience

Challenge of the Five Realms stands as a hidden gem among Microprose’s early ’90s RPG lineup, overshadowed at release by the grandeur of Darklands but offering a tightly woven experience of its own. The balance of character customization, time-sensitive strategy, and personality-driven party dynamics delivers depth rarely seen in contemporaneous titles. Players who appreciate methodical world exploration and tactical decision-making will find themselves engrossed for hours.

However, its complexity can be a double-edged sword. Newcomers to classic RPGs may feel overwhelmed by the sheer number of skills, attributes, and dialogue options—especially under a 100-day in-game limit. The interface, while serviceable, may frustrate those accustomed to modern conveniences such as automated quest logs or quick-travel systems.

Ultimately, Challenge of the Five Realms rewards patience and creativity. Its combination of an evolving plague threat, open-ended puzzle solutions, and richly imagined realm makes for a memorable journey through Nhagardia. Though its VGA graphics and text-heavy encounters bear the hallmarks of early ’90s design, the underlying gameplay innovations continue to resonate, offering a compelling adventure for dedicated RPG enthusiasts.

Retro Replay Score

null/10