Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Murder Makes Strange Deadfellows places you in the shoes of Nick, the eager great-nephew of the late Randolph Steere, as he navigates a sprawling, time-sensitive investigation. From the moment you step into the haunted Steere mansion, each decision feels weighty: whether to inspect a dusty portrait for hidden clues or press a reluctant servant for information can make or break your quest. The non-linear nature of the investigation means you’re free to explore rooms in nearly any order, but the ever-ticking clock forces you to prioritize and strategize carefully.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The game employs a classic point-and-click interface, allowing you to guide Nick from room to room, click on objects of interest, and engage with various inhabitants of the mansion. Dialogue choices are pivotal: some characters will open up if approached tactfully, while others clam up or even leave the premises, cutting off vital lines of inquiry. This branching dialogue system ensures that each playthrough can feel distinct, as the order and depth of conversations directly influence which clues you uncover and how suspicion falls among the suspects.

Puzzles in this mystery are integrated organically into the investigation. Instead of standalone brainteasers, you’ll find yourself decoding cryptic notes, matching handwriting samples, and piecing together snippets of testimony to unlock hidden compartments or secret passageways. The time limit adds an extra layer of tension: if you dawdle over minor details, you risk running out of time before locating Randolph’s final will. This ticking clock dynamic transforms even simple observations—like examining an overturned vase—into crucial strategic decisions.

Replayability is high, thanks to multiple possible endings and several paths to the truth. If your first attempt leaves you puzzled, you can quickly reenter the mansion, choose alternative dialogue trees, or prioritize different rooms to visit. This flexibility keeps the experience fresh, as you continually refine your approach to outwit the game’s red herrings and dead ends. For players who relish the challenge of beating the clock while piecing together scattered evidence, Murder Makes Strange Deadfellows delivers an engaging blend of detective work and time management.

Graphics

The visual presentation of Murder Makes Strange Deadfellows channels a distinctive comic book aesthetic. Each scene is rendered as a richly detailed, hand-drawn panel, giving the mansion’s dusty corridors and grand ballrooms an atmospheric, slightly surreal quality. Though animations are absent, the still images are so meticulously crafted that they evoke movement through clever use of perspective, lighting, and shading. Shadows cast by flickering candles seem alive, and the dilapidated wallpaper practically peels off the walls before your eyes.

Voice-overs accompany each static image, lending personality to the cast of eccentric suspects and tragic servants who populate the Steere estate. The actors’ performances range from hushed whispers to dramatic outbursts, creating a dynamic contrast that breathes life into otherwise motionless illustrations. Ambient music swells at key moments—such as discovering a hidden letter or hearing the howling wind outside—heightening the sense of suspense and immersing you further into the ghostly setting.

Despite its lack of animation, the game’s art style is remarkably expressive. You’ll notice the slightest shifts in character posture—tilted heads, clenched fists, or furtive glances—that hint at motives or suppressed emotions. These visual cues play a vital role in your investigation, as they can reveal inconsistencies in testimony or suggest hidden relationships between suspects. In this sense, the static images function as both storytelling devices and essential gameplay tools.

For players accustomed to big-budget 3D thrillers, the minimalist approach may feel unconventional at first. However, the comic-inspired visuals and expertly timed audio elements combine to create an immersive, almost theatrical experience. The unique aesthetic sets Murder Makes Strange Deadfellows apart from other mystery titles, proving that static images, when executed with care and creativity, can conjure an atmosphere every bit as compelling as fully animated adventures.

Story

At its core, Murder Makes Strange Deadfellows is a classic whodunit wrapped in gothic intrigue. The sudden death of Randolph Steere, an eccentric patriarch with a rumored fortune, prompts his keen-eyed great-nephew to investigate the circumstances surrounding the patriarch’s demise. As Nick, you delve into family secrets, unearth old grudges, and navigate the labyrinthine politics of the Steere lineage. Every character you meet—from the stoic butler to the nervy heir—carries a potential motive, and it’s up to you to determine who’s hiding the truth.

The narrative unfolds through a series of carefully crafted vignettes, each set in a different wing of the mansion. In the library, you’ll decipher Randolph’s cryptic journal entries; in the conservatory, you’ll eavesdrop on hushed conversations among agitated relatives. These chapters build on one another, weaving red herrings and shocking revelations into a tapestry of suspense. The haunted atmosphere is more than window dressing—it reflects the restless spirits of family betrayals, unfulfilled vows, and unspoken regrets that linger within the mansion’s walls.

Pacing is expertly handled: hints drop at a steady rhythm, nudging you toward the mansion’s darkest secrets without ever feeling rushed. The time constraint adds a sense of urgency to even the smallest discoveries, ensuring that you remain alert and invested. As the clock winds down, the tension ramps up, culminating in a final confrontation where your accumulated clues must point to a single culprit. It’s a satisfying payoff that rewards meticulous observation and clever deduction.

The story’s depth extends beyond the central murder mystery. Subplots involving hidden romances, financial disputes, and supernatural rumors enrich the narrative tapestry. Optional dialogues and locked rooms offer further lore, giving completionists the chance to explore every creaking corridor and piece together the mansion’s tragic history. Whether you’re a fan of classic detective fiction or haunted-house thrillers, the intertwining storylines of Murder Makes Strange Deadfellows deliver a rich, immersive experience.

Overall Experience

Murder Makes Strange Deadfellows stands out as a hidden gem for discerning mystery aficionados. Its blend of non-linear investigation, time-pressured decision-making, and comic book–inspired visuals creates an experience both challenging and uniquely atmospheric. Though the lack of animation may surprise some modern players, the richly detailed artwork and expressive voice acting more than compensate, painting a vivid picture of the haunted Steere mansion.

The learning curve can be steep: newcomers to investigative adventures might initially find the ticking clock daunting, and the sheer number of possible paths can be overwhelming. However, this complexity is also its greatest strength. Multiple endings and branching dialogue trees encourage replay, and each repeat visit to the mansion reveals new clues, conversations, and hidden spaces. Those willing to embrace trial-and-error will find a deeply rewarding game that champions curiosity, patience, and logical reasoning.

While the game’s rarity makes it a collector’s item, its historic charm and innovative design still hold up today. Fans of its predecessor, The Case of the Cautious Condor, will appreciate the developer’s signature style, while newcomers will be drawn in by the intricate mystery and tense atmosphere. Ultimately, Murder Makes Strange Deadfellows delivers a memorable detective experience—one that proves the timeless appeal of a well-crafted whodunit.

For players seeking a thoughtful, immersive mystery with challenging puzzles and a haunting ambiance, this hard-to-find title is well worth the effort. Its non-linear structure, atmospheric graphics, and compelling narrative combine to offer a deeply engaging journey through the shadowy corners of the Steere mansion. Prepare for twists, turns, and a race against time—you might just uncover the truth before the mansion’s secrets claim you, too.

Retro Replay Score

null/10