Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

Mystery Master: Felony! delivers a deeply engaging detective experience by blending classic investigative mechanics with modern time-pressure elements. From the moment you step into the role of mystery master, the core gameplay revolves around interrogating suspects, scouring crime scenes, and piecing together disparate clues to build a compelling case. Each action is time-bound, lending the game a palpable sense of urgency—you’ll find yourself racing against the clock to get the evidence you need before the trail goes cold.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

The integration of a physical manual filled with crime backstories and hundreds of detailed clues adds a tactile layer to the gameplay. As the computer reveals clue numbers, you’re prompted to flip through the manual, cross-referencing information and making notes. This encourages active participation and rewards players who meticulously track every lead. The need to study the backstory carefully transforms typical point-and-click detective work into a more immersive puzzle-solving adventure.

For solo players, Mystery Master: Felony! offers a satisfying single-player campaign across 12 distinctly crafted cases, each presenting unique motives, suspects, and hidden secrets. Meanwhile, up to four players can compete head-to-head, vying to crack the case first. Competitive multiplayer adds a layer of strategic bluffing and speed, as you not only gather evidence but also gauge your rivals’ progress and decide whether to share or withhold critical information.

The game’s resource management at the police station—where you can analyze collected clues using limited lab time—introduces another strategic element. Prioritizing which evidence to process and when to press for confessions encourages careful planning. Every decision, from selecting which suspect to interrogate next to choosing which lead to pursue, feels meaningful and impacts your success in nailing down the culprit.

Graphics

Although Mystery Master: Felony! isn’t a visual showcase of cutting-edge 3D graphics, its design aesthetic perfectly suits the investigative theme. The game utilizes detailed 2D illustrations for crime scenes and suspect portraits, giving each location a distinct atmosphere. Subtle animations—like flickering office lights or a clue number popping up on the computer screen—enhance immersion without distracting from the core detective work.

The user interface is clean and intuitive, with clearly labeled menus for suspect interviews, location searches, and lab analyses. Navigation between scenes is seamless, allowing you to focus on the mystery rather than fumbling through confusing icons. Well-placed sound effects—typing on a keyboard, the door creaking open, the police radio crackling—further ground you in the world of Huxley’s crime wave.

Character portraits are expressive, using simple but effective art to convey a suspect’s mood or reliability during questioning. The manual itself is richly illustrated, featuring crime scene sketches and suspect profiles that boost the tangible detective vibe. While you won’t find photorealistic environments here, the game’s consistent visual style keeps you engaged and eases the process of clue gathering.

Subtle visual cues also guide your attention during complex investigations. When a key piece of evidence is uncovered, the game highlights relevant objects or suspects, ensuring you don’t miss critical leads. Overall, the graphics strike a balance between nostalgia and functionality, making Mystery Master: Felony! both approachable for veteran puzzlers and inviting to newcomers.

Story

The narrative foundation of Mystery Master: Felony! is its 12 unique cases, each chronicling a different crime wave in the town of Huxley. From art theft to high-stakes forgery rings, the cases span a broad range of criminal activities. This variety keeps the storytelling fresh, with each chapter introducing new locations—dusty archives, upscale galleries, abandoned warehouses—and a cast of intriguing characters with hidden motives.

The manual serves as your story bible, detailing suspects’ backgrounds, timelines, and secret connections. Investing time in reading and annotating this material is essential; skipping it risks overlooking subtle clues embedded in the text. For players who relish deep dives into conspiracies and plot twists, the manual’s narrative richness is a major draw. You’ll feel like a genuine detective piecing together a labyrinthine web of deceit.

Dialogue during interrogations is scripted to provide just enough red herrings to keep you guessing. Suspects may slip up, contradict earlier statements, or reveal personal grudges that muddy the waters. This dynamic interplay between suspects and the mystery master role ensures that each case unfolds unpredictably, rewarding players who adapt their line of questioning on the fly.

Although the overarching goal remains consistent—to deduce the culprit and gather enough evidence for conviction—each case’s climax varies in emotional intensity and complexity. Some mysteries wrap up with cold-blooded revelations, while others hinge on moral gray areas and unforeseen alliances. The result is a layered narrative experience that invites multiple playthroughs to catch every nuance.

Overall Experience

Mystery Master: Felony! stands out as a cerebral detective simulator that emphasizes active problem-solving over action-oriented gameplay. Its unique blend of computer interaction and manual lookup mechanics creates a hands-on feel rarely seen in modern titles. If you enjoy methodical investigations and real-world puzzle solving, this game delivers a richly rewarding experience.

The replay value is high, thanks to both the competitive multiplayer mode and the depth of each case’s script. Even after solving a crime, you may return to uncover alternate suspect paths or chase down every hidden clue. For groups of friends or family gatherings, the multiplayer race adds social tension and camaraderie, as you jostle to present the final conviction first.

The learning curve can be steep initially, especially if you’re not accustomed to cross-referencing manuals in tandem with digital prompts. However, once you master the note-taking workflow and resource allocation at the station, the game flows smoothly. The developers strike a careful balance between challenging and fair, ensuring you rarely feel stuck for too long while preserving the satisfaction of a well-earned breakthrough.

In sum, Mystery Master: Felony! is a standout choice for mystery enthusiasts and puzzle lovers who crave an interactive whodunit with genuine stakes. Its combination of strategic decision-making, engaging narrative, and tactile manual interaction offers a uniquely immersive detective adventure that will keep you hooked from the first crime to the final conviction.

Retro Replay Score

null/10