Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes places you squarely in the deerstalker of the world’s greatest detective, tasking you with piecing together clues scattered across fog-shrouded streets and shadowy drawing rooms. Rather than relying on live-action video snippets as in its spiritual successor, the game delivers its evidence in stylized, fill-in-the-blank text screens. Each screen challenges you to decode cryptic wordplay or phonetic puzzles, leading you closer to naming the culprit, method, and motive of each case. This approach transforms every clue into a miniature riddle and demands both deductive reasoning and a keen eye for linguistic tricks.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Time management is another crucial element of the experience. You have a finite number of “moves” to dash between locations in Olde London Towne, consulting familiar characters—Dr. Watson, Mrs. Baker, and Inspector Lestrade—for hints or leads. Every minute spent gathering testimony or scouring crime scenes must be weighed against the risk of missing critical evidence. This resource-limited structure adds a compelling layer of tension, forcing you to prioritize which locations and witnesses to visit before time runs out.

One of the game’s most engaging features is the inclusion of user-contributed cases, which extend replayability well beyond the original set of mysteries. The tone and difficulty of these fan-created adventures can vary widely, ranging from straightforward homicides to perplexing locked-room puzzles. While the community scenarios can sometimes feel uneven in quality, they reflect the game’s enduring appeal and passion among amateur sleuths.

Despite its text-based roots, the core investigative loop remains solid. You’ll interview witnesses, examine clues, and gradually assemble a picture of motive and opportunity. If you delight in classic mystery stories and don’t mind flexing your brain on word games, you’ll find the gameplay both rewarding and refreshingly different from more action-oriented detective titles.

Graphics

Visually, The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes embraces a purely textmode presentation, with occasional simple monochrome maps or diagrams to illustrate key locations. There are no elaborate sprites or cinematic cutscenes—everything is conveyed through carefully formatted text and occasional line-art flourishes. For some players, this minimalist aesthetic may feel archaic, yet it also channels the atmosphere of a Victorian newspaper or penny dreadful, letting your imagination flesh out the foggy London streets.

The lack of video clips or high-resolution images might be a turn-off if you expect modern multimedia spectacle. Yet the game’s designers turn this limitation into an asset: text descriptions are rich and evocative, peppered with period details that conjure gaslit lampposts, horse-drawn carriages, and the hush of midnight alleys. When you shift from one locale to another, a few well-chosen words establish mood far more effectively than a static screenshot could.

For players who cherish nostalgia, the sparse graphics feel authentic and immersive, reminiscent of vintage mainframe adventures. The fill-in-the-blank puzzles themselves are integrated seamlessly into the text windows, with empty spaces that beckon you to type in earned answers. This direct interaction keeps your focus on deduction rather than flashy visual effects.

Ultimately, if you’re evaluating the game on graphical prowess alone, it will seem modest at best. But when viewed as a proof-of-concept for interactive mystery storytelling, the textmode approach proves surprisingly charismatic, capturing the spirit of Arthur Conan Doyle’s world without relying on elaborate visuals.

Story

The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes crafts brand-new mysteries that feel right at home alongside the original canon. Each case unfolds through a series of textual vignettes interspersed with cryptic puzzles. You won’t revisit “The Hound of the Baskervilles” or “A Study in Scarlet,” but the atmosphere, dialogue, and investigative process echo the style of Doyle’s finest tales. Whether you’re interrogating a jittery maid or examining a mysterious monogram, the writing evokes the crisp cadence of Victorian prose.

Supporting characters—Dr. Watson, Mrs. Baker, and Inspector Lestrade—anchor the stories in familiar territory. Watson serves as your empathetic sounding board, offering wry commentary on your deductions, while Lestrade’s official police resources sometimes clash with your amateur methods. Mrs. Baker, meanwhile, provides local color and neighborhood gossip that can open unexpected leads. Their presence enriches each plot, making you feel part of a living, breathing London community.

The motives and methods of the culprits range from the wholly plausible to the delightfully bizarre. You’ll encounter passionate love triangles, bitter business rivalries, and even an opportunistic jewel thief making use of theatrical stagecraft. The puzzles themselves often hint at the killer’s psychology—phonetic clues might suggest arrogance or hubris, while obscure vocabulary can point to a literary-minded perpetrator. This interplay of narrative and codebreaking heightens the sense that you’re unraveling a layered mystery rather than ticking off checklist items.

User-contributed adventures expand the storytelling canvas further, introducing fresh settings and eccentric characters. While these fan scenarios vary in writing quality, many deliver inventive premises and memorable twists. The game’s community remains active decades after release, a testament to the strength of its core storytelling framework.

Overall Experience

The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes offers a unique fusion of literary drama and interactive puzzle-solving. It’s not designed for players seeking flashy visuals or real-time action; instead, it invites you to slow down, read carefully, and think laterally. For fans of classic whodunits, the deliberate pacing and cryptic fill-in-the-blank clues deliver an authentic sense of sleuthing triumph when you finally name the murderer.

Patience and persistence are rewarded here. Cases can be fiendishly tricky, with clues that hinge on subtle wordplay or period-specific references. Beginners to the genre may find themselves consulting a Victorian dictionary or retracing steps multiple times to catch a hidden pun. Those willing to invest the effort, however, will find a highly satisfying “aha!” moment when each piece of the puzzle slots neatly into place.

The textmode design may feel old-fashioned to newcomers, but it fosters immersion by letting your imagination do the heavy lifting. You’ll picture the gaslight glare, the echoing footsteps in narrow alleys, and the anxious faces of suspects as vividly as any rendered scene. And with additional user-made cases constantly available online, the game remains endlessly replayable for those who crave fresh enigmas.

In the end, The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes is a niche gem—best suited to mystery aficionados, linguistic puzzle lovers, and anyone who appreciates the charm of interactive fiction. If you’re prepared to embrace its text-based style and relish slow-burn investigations, you’ll uncover a timeless detective experience that still feels fresh and challenging today.

Retro Replay Score

null/10