Retro Replay Review

Gameplay

WWF Super WrestleMania’s core gameplay is built around a distinctive “tug of war” system that captures the intensity of professional wrestling’s clinch battles. At the start of each grapple, two wrestlers lock up and players must rapidly tap a designated button to gain the upper hand. This mechanic injects a sense of physical struggle into each match, making every reversal feel earned and every slam all the more satisfying.

(HEY YOU!! We hope you enjoy! We try not to run ads. So basically, this is a very expensive hobby running this site. Please consider joining us for updates, forums, and more. Network w/ us to make some cash or friends while retro gaming, and you can win some free retro games for posting. Okay, carry on 👍)

Beyond the tug-of-war, the move set is both deep and approachable. Each competitor can perform a slew of classic WWF maneuvers—scoop slams, suplexes, hip tosses, dropkicks, clotheslines, and elbow drops—allowing players to craft signature sequences in the ring. The Genesis (Mega Drive) version goes a step further by granting each superstar a unique finishing move, lending greater authenticity and strategic depth as you decide when to unleash your wrestler’s trademark attack.

Match variety is another strength. One-on-one bouts are complemented by tag team matches, where timely tags and dual-team tactics come into play, as well as Survivor Series-style four-on-four elimination contests that capture the chaos of multi-man WWF events. On the Genesis, the added WWF Championship mode offers a structured path through a one-on-one tournament, giving solo players an incentive to master their chosen wrestler and climb the brackets toward the title belt.

Graphics

Visually, WWF Super WrestleMania delivers crisp, colorful sprites that stand out against the simple yet serviceable ring backgrounds. Wrestler animations are fluid for their era, with each move—be it a clothesline or a piledriver—rendered in enough detail to recognize your favorite WWF stars. The brown and black ring mats may feel a tad plain by today’s standards, but they help the characters pop and keep the focus on the action.

The Genesis version, in particular, boasts a vibrant color palette that highlights each wrestler’s distinctive attire. From the bright spandex of Shawn Michaels to the imposing visor and megaphone of “Macho Man” Randy Savage, the game does well to portray wrestlers with recognizable flair. Load times are minimal, and the crowd sprites—even if static—contribute to the atmosphere, cheering in unison when a signature move is executed.

One minor drawback is the lack of dynamic camera angles, resulting in a mostly side-on perspective throughout the match. While this keeps the action clear and consistent, it can make ring entries and post-match celebrations feel a bit stilted. Still, given the hardware constraints of the time, the game strikes a solid balance between performance and visual fidelity.

Story

Unlike narrative-driven titles, WWF Super WrestleMania focuses on simulation of WWF showdowns rather than weaving an overarching storyline. The “story” emerges from the rivalries you create in the ring, the rival’s reversal at a climactic moment, or the elation of survival in four-on-four elimination bouts. In this sense, the game’s narrative is player-driven—each match writes its own little drama.

The WWF Championship mode on Genesis introduces a loose campaign structure, pitting your chosen wrestler against a series of opponents in tournament fashion. This progression adds a light sense of journey, as you work through different hall-of-famers en route to the championship belt. While there’s no cutscene storytelling, the stakes of each bout feel tangible, mirroring the spectacle of a live WWF pay-per-view.

For fans craving backstory, the game’s manual supplies brief bios for each superstar, giving context to their wrestling personas and signature moves. These blurbs serve to remind players why they’re stepping into the virtual squared circle—whether to uphold Hulk Hogan’s legacy or to prove Shawn Michaels’ Heartbreak Kid moniker has teeth.

Overall Experience

WWF Super WrestleMania is a delightful time capsule of early ’90s wrestling, blending authentic move sets with varied match types that cater to solo and multiplayer sessions alike. The tug-of-war grappling system may feel old-school by modern standards, but it offers a tactile thrill that modern button-mashers sometimes lack. Each exchange in the ring carries weight, and executing a perfectly timed finishing move never gets old.

Replay value is high, thanks to the roster of memorable WWF heroes and villains, multiple play modes, and the inherent unpredictability of multiplayer brawls. Tag team specialists will appreciate the partner assist mechanic, while tournament enthusiasts can sink hours into the Championship mode on Sega Genesis. The lack of extravagant presentation elements or a fully fleshed-out story may deter narrative purists, but for fans of straight-up arcade wrestling action, this title hits the sweet spot.

Ultimately, WWF Super WrestleMania stands as a quintessential retro wrestling experience. Its simple controls and robust move roster make it easy for newcomers to pick up, while the layered tug-of-war battles and signature maneuvers provide depth for veterans. If you’re looking to relive the golden era of WWF or introduce a friend to classic grappling games, this one remains a must-play on its respective platforms.

Retro Replay Score

6.9/10