Skip to content
Retro Game Database · PlayStation 4

MLB The Show 17

Retro Game Database · PlayStation 4

MLB The Show 17

MLB The Show 17 earns its attention by letting baseball nostalgia sit beside its larger suite of modes instead of treating it as a throwaway filter. Retro Mode leans into 1990s-inspired displays, old-school music and effects, movable batter and pitcher positions, and the immediate fun of competing with someone on the couch.

Buy this game

Platform:

Game Overview

Gameplay

The first thing that stands out is how plainly MLB The Show 17 courts the baseball fan who misses a more arcade-adjacent, living-room kind of atmosphere. Retro Mode is not tucked into another mode as a cosmetic switch. It is its own destination, built around 1990s-inspired baseball-game touches and couch competition. That makes it easy to recommend to you if the idea of passing a controller and talking trash sounds more inviting than treating every game like a long-term project.

Its most interesting wrinkle is the ability to move batter and pitcher positions. That is a small-sounding detail, but it gives the retro concept some practical personality rather than leaving it at music and display changes. You are not merely looking at an old-school style; you have a way to alter the matchup on the field.

There is also a useful boundary here. Retro Mode sits apart from Road to the Show, Diamond Dynasty, and Franchise, so you should treat it as a focused side of the game rather than the wrapper around everything else. That separation may frustrate anyone hoping every part of MLB The Show 17 follows the same throwback rules, but it also keeps the mode’s pitch clean: sit down, pick up a game, and enjoy a deliberately old-fashioned flavor.

Graphics

Retro Mode’s clearest visual draw is its 1990s-inspired display style and old-school effects. The look is meant to pull your attention away from a contemporary broadcast feel and toward the simpler, era-specific baseball-game aesthetic that fits its Griffey-inspired theme.

Story

MLB The Show 17 does not need a scripted drama to establish a point of view. Its strongest bit of context is baseball nostalgia: a modern licensed release making room for the kind of mood associated with 1990s games and local competition. That gives the game a warmer hook than a generic yearly sports update.

Ken Griffey Jr. is the right figure to anchor that idea. As the cover athlete and the inspiration for Retro Mode, he connects the mode to a specific baseball memory rather than a vague “remember the old days” marketing line. The publisher's introduction to Griffey-inspired Retro Mode explains that connection directly.

That framing will mean more to you if Griffey and the baseball culture of that era carry some personal weight. If not, the mode still has a clear social premise in couch competition, but its nostalgic theme will naturally do less of the emotional lifting.

Overall Experience

MLB The Show 17 is easiest to appreciate as a baseball game with a distinct reason to exist beyond its standard mode list. Retro Mode gives it a specific personality, pairing classic displays and sound cues with a couch-friendly competitive angle. It is the part of this release that feels most likely to pull you in quickly.

The tradeoff is that the retro material is intentionally separate from Road to the Show, Diamond Dynasty, and Franchise. If you want every baseball session shaped by that concept, the split may feel limiting. If you like having a dedicated throwback option alongside other ways to spend time with licensed MLB baseball, it is a sensible division.

Give this one a chance if you want the Ken Griffey Jr. connection to be more than cover art and enjoy the idea of an old-school side mode built for playing beside someone else. The retro hook is specific enough to be memorable, and it gives MLB The Show 17 a welcome bit of character.

Retro Replay Score

7.9/10

Additional information

Publisher

Developer

Genre

, , , ,

Year

Retro Replay Score

7.9

Platform

PlayStation 4

Reviews

There are no reviews yet.

Be the first to review “MLB The Show 17”

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Spam has been overwhelming. To help us approve your review, sign up and introduce yourself in the Introductions forum so we know you’re not a bot.

Buy This Game

Find MLB The Show 17 for PlayStation 4 on eBay.

View copies on eBay

We may earn a commission when you buy through this link.

MLB The Show 17 speedruns on PlayStation 4

View MLB The Show 17 speedruns and leaderboards