Skip to content
Retro Replay FYI distressed collage featuring Ecco and the headline Ecco Was Hard on Purpose.
Ecco’s creator said weekend rentals influenced the game’s difficulty.

Ecco’s Creator Says He Made the Game Hard Because of Weekend Rentals

Ed Annunziata says he made Ecco the Dolphin hard because he worried that kids would rent it and finish it over a weekend. If that peaceful blue box ever sent you home with a very different idea of dolphins, there is your explanation.

He put it plainly in a December 30, 2012 tweet: “I was paranoid about game rentals and kids beating the game over the weekend.” Then came the confession: “So.. I.. uh… made it hard.”

A Long Weekend Underwater

Ecco looks like a lovely choice for a rental. There is a dolphin on the cover, the water is beautiful, and swimming feels good. The trouble starts when a promising tunnel takes you farther from the surface than you intended. Now you have to remember the way back while watching the breath meter shrink.

Ecco swims near an orca and a crystal in a blue underwater cavern in the Genesis game.
An orca, a crystal, and another stretch of submerged cavern in Ecco the Dolphin on Genesis.

Sega’s official instructions explain the tools you have: sonar can reveal a map, songs can produce clues, and air pockets let you breathe in submerged caverns. None of that makes the trip effortless. You still have to read the map, work out what a crystal wants, and get Ecco somewhere he can breathe.

The game does give you passwords for returning to its levels. That helps when you own the cartridge. It does rather less to extend a rental agreement.

Retro Replay FYI card explaining Ed Annunziata said he made Ecco hard because of weekend game rentals.
Annunziata linked Ecco’s difficulty to his fear of kids finishing a weekend rental.

Hard by Design, According to Its Creator

Annunziata’s tweet explains his concern without naming a particular level or describing a Sega order. He did not say which obstacles were added because of rentals. The useful detail is his own admission that the fear influenced how hard he made the game.

There is another firsthand perspective on that difficulty. In a 2004 Sega interview, localization producer Ryoichi Hasegawa discussed how little guidance could make exploration frustrating for Japanese players. He described adjusting hints and navigation during localization. Getting lost in Ecco was enough of a problem to come up on the production side too.

The adventure continued in Ecco: The Tides of Time, while Ecco Jr. took the series toward younger players. For more on those games and the people behind them, our Ecco history follows the wider story.

For the original, though, Annunziata’s explanation is wonderfully blunt. The dolphin on the box promised an ocean to explore. Its designer was worried you might explore all of it before the cartridge had to go back.

Sources

More #RetroReplayFYI

Sonic CD’s First Boss Shares the Famicom’s Model Number

Tags

About

David (dmb062082) Becker. is a writer with a passion for retro gaming, Christianity, disaster preparedness, America’s military and law enforcement, and the occasional dose of slapstick absurdity masquerading as satire. He enjoys digging into forgotten stories, preserving various elements of history, and creating content that is informative, entertaining, and full of personality.

Check Also

Spencer Nilsen portrait with Sonic CD, Batman Returns and Spider-Man screenshots in the Retro Replay interview collage

Spencer Nilsen Interview: Sonic CD, Ecco and Sega’s Studio Sound

Spencer Nilsen recalls Sonic CD, Ecco, Batman Returns, Spider-Man, David Young, Sega’s recording studios, and returning to Ecco’s musical world.

One comment

  1. I have yet to play the Dreamcast edition of this amazing franchise, and the DC was one of my fav systems. SOON!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Spam has been overwhelming. To help us approve your comment, sign up and introduce yourself in the Introductions forum so we know you’re not a bot.