Skip to content
Retro Replay interview with Chris Avellone, featuring his portrait and Planescape Torment, KOTOR II, and Fallout New Vegas imagery
Chris Avellone on Planescape: Torment, Fallout, KOTOR II, and the player’s choices.

Chris Avellone Interview: Planescape: Torment, Fallout, KOTOR II, and the Player’s Choices

A player says their character is lawful good, then threatens the barkeep over a watery drink. Chris Avellone knows that gap between the character somebody imagines and the decisions they actually make. Around a tabletop, it gives the gamemaster something to work with. In Planescape: Torment, it helped him build a protagonist whose identity could emerge through play.

Avellone’s work has taken him through Black Isle’s computer RPGs, the arguments of Kreia in Knights of the Old Republic II, and the very different journeys of Fallout: New Vegas and its downloadable adventures. His answers keep returning to the person holding the mouse or controller: what their character knows, what their choices change, and whether the game genuinely leaves room for them to disagree.

He is candid about the work behind those experiences. Torment brought fears about translation costs and commercial failure, companions whose farewells hurt to write, and cut scenes involving an alarming set of living teeth. His account of Black Isle also gives plenty of credit to outside developers, especially BioWare, while describing the pressures and troubled projects he remembers inside the studio.

In this written interview, Avellone discusses tabletop experiments that fed later Fallout ideas, the humanity behind his companions, the unfinished ending of KOTOR II, and the lessons he carried from Fallout 2 into New Vegas. He closes with the projects he can discuss now, including work with Republic Games and Steel Strix.

For a fun journey from Arroyo to the Enclave, read The History of Fallout 2: A Bigger, Stranger Wasteland, including its hurried development, competing cities, and the choices behind the Chosen One’s adventure.

Chris Avellone speaking at e-Services 2009 in Manila
Chris Avellone at e-Services 2009 in Manila. Photo by Luna Cruz, CC BY-SA 2.0. Resized and converted to WebP.
Explore the interview (click to expand)

A gamemaster finds his way into games

Retro Replay: How did you first get involved in game development, and what originally attracted you to writing and narrative design for games?

Chris Avellone: It was pen-and-paper gaming that opened the door, and tabletop gamemastering was something I found myself doing in my free time almost non-stop.

I didn’t realize there could be an actual “job” being a digital gamemaster at the time, but once I started writing modules and gaming articles, other colleagues and friends in the same field brought up that there might be openings at game companies doing RPGs.

For me, interactive gaming has always been fascinating because of the collaborative aspect – while an author can write a story on their own, for me, the stories got a lot more interesting when players around the table brought their own characters and backstories to incorporate into the gaming plotlines.

This method was what we tried to do for Interplay’s Fallout 3 (Van Buren), and we had about 10-12 developer-players who brought their own character builds that we could use to test out quest lines and challenges in the tabletop paper version of the game (Arcade from New Vegas was one of them, and a lot of ideas from New Vegas came from those tabletop sessions). Also, the fact major antagonists and NPCs could be killed when encountered made the plot a lot more interesting when examining the ramifications of a certain NPC’s death you may have spent a lot of time designing.

Retro Replay: What do you remember most about the culture at Interplay and Black Isle Studios during that late 1990s period?

Chris Avellone: It was pretty freeing. Projects rarely got canceled, it always seemed there was enough money to keep things afloat (until that finally changed), and Interplay was a fun place to work.

There were some good decisions and some bad ones that heavily impacted the company, but overall, people were pretty positive about working there.

The internal studio culture was broken down mostly by genre so it didn’t feel like a colossal company (Black Isle did RPGs, 14 Degrees East did strategy titles, and uh, VR Sports did, well, sports). It was a great way to make you feel like you were part of a more personal sub-studio vs. being part of a corporate machine.

Fallout 2 and consequences the player can feel

Retro Replay: You worked on Fallout 2 fairly early in your career. What lessons did that project teach you about writing for a world where players could approach situations in so many different ways?

Chris Avellone: It was liberating. The dialogue system especially, and the way it leveraged your character’s statistics (which was new to me) opened up all sorts of fun possibilities of showing how each character and build might have a “special path” through a dialogue.

I confess, there were times where I’d get lost in adding little detours and easter eggs for certain builds or skill types that would get a unique experience because of their character build. It was what we tried to do in Pillars of Eternity, but it didn’t quite match the bar for Fallout 2 and Torment.

Retro Replay: Fallout is known for allowing players to make morally questionable or unexpected choices. How difficult is it to write meaningful consequences without simply dividing everything into obvious “good” and “evil” outcomes?

Chris Avellone: It depends – but often, when you set up the moral dilemma, the consequences are bundled up in the dilemma itself. To make them meaningful, however, they need to be more than a cosmetic reaction – cosmetic reactivity is fine, but a decision should also have systemic or world consequences, and the player should not only be aware of the consequences, but also feel the impact.

To explain the “systemic” consequences a little more: So it’s entirely possible a player confronts a moral dilemma where it’s not plausible (or impossible) for the rest of the world to know about it. But if that choice has systemic repercussions for the player’s build or attributes, then you can add meaningful consequences to almost any action, even if it’s a private or internal one.

As an example, in Planescape, the fact we could govern alignment shifts depending on the choices you made was a perfect, systemic way of establishing consequences across a wide range of decisions – and that alignment shift was important to the game itself, how your companions treated you, and even down to what items or weapons you could make use of.

Inventing and reinventing the Nameless One

Retro Replay: Planescape: Torment remains one of the most unusual RPGs ever released. Where did the central idea of an immortal protagonist trying to understand his own past come from?

Chris Avellone: I think every writer has a story they need to get out of their system – whether it’s amnesia, classic high fantasy, or the idea of an immortal protagonist. For me, Planescape provided the means to do all three but without the “classic” part of fantasy. I’d also read a lot of Roger Zelazny, and if there’s an author that makes amnesiac protagonists sing, it’s him.

That said, there’s always the danger of falling into cliches, and amnesia + protagonists is one of them. However, the approach was to shake up the trope by doing a few things:

– Escalating amnesia to an extreme by leaning into the concept and adding immortality. Having amnesia once is pretty routine, but once the player realizes it’s happened many thousands of times, suddenly it becomes a much different beast. Then the fact that your previous incarnations could have been working for/against you added additional drama and (hopefully) a desire to figure out what their goals are/were and if they aligned with yours (usually not).

– Also – and this was due to the D&D alignment system – the idea occurred to me that the player could re-invent himself with every incarnation, and even become someone completely different in outlook.

To explain the D&D alignment angle, one thing I had come to realize from tabletop gaming is while players might assume their character has a certain alignment starting out (“I’m Lawful Good!”), we’d often find that when the rubber hit the road, that they actually acted quite different once they were playing and they were reacting to events in the world (“Yeah, I’m Lawful Good, but I’m still going to stab the barkeep and bathe in his blood if he serves me another watery ale”).

So in Planescape, amnesia felt a great way to establish a True Neutral starting point, and then allow each player to branch out into the alignment types as they adventured through the world. This also complemented the theme of the game as well (“What can change the nature of a man?” = That process is occurring continually throughout the game, both narratively and systemically).

– There was one other inspiration to the core concept: So there was a comic series Bill Willingham (of Fables fame, but he’s done such great work in other writing as well) wrote called “The Elementals.”

In it, he introduced an assassin called Sanction. Sanction was a projecting telepath (he could use his telepathy to make you think he was someone he wasn’t). More important to this story, Sanction could do a “reset” and completely change his personality when certain trigger words were given by his handler. That character stuck with me for a long time because the concept was so cool, and it occurred to me that the protagonist in Torment was in much the same boat. So thank Bill if you see him, and read The Elementals if you can – it’s great stuff, and was well ahead of its time.

Retro Replay: The question “What can change the nature of a man?” runs throughout Planescape: Torment. When did that idea become the philosophical center of the game?

Chris Avellone: When I started designing Ravel’s presence deeper into the plot, part of the foreshadowing I wanted was that she would ask you an impossible question (kind of like the Sphinx’s riddle). The “what can change the nature of a man?” question is what emerged, since it was so tied to the game’s framework – the game itself was literally asking that question, so having Ravel ask it and solidify the theme just clicked into place.

That question and design choice changed much of the original plot and elevated it to a much stronger place – but it was due to Ravel’s presence, not mine. : )

Retro Replay: The Nameless One is defined largely through choices and memories rather than a traditional heroic identity. What were you trying to accomplish with that approach?

Chris Avellone: It felt in keeping with the other narrative foundations, plus it had the added lure of players suddenly realizing that just about every NPC in the game, including your companions, may hold knowledge of your identity and actions.

This was a great way of making a player-focused plot and having every NPC be a potential treasure box to explore that might reveal something about yourself.

Planescape’s probably the most intentionally player-selfish game I’ve ever done, but it was done with intention: I wanted everything in the game to matter to the Nameless One and the player, and I felt that would make them feel both important (in an epic way) and also keep the focus on the protagonist as the main challenge vs. an evil wizard operating from afar (but we had that, too).

The party in Sigil’s Hive district in Planescape: Torment for Windows
The Hive in Planescape: Torment for Windows. Avellone describes a world where the people the Nameless One meets may know more about his past than he does.

Too many words, too little time

Retro Replay: Planescape: Torment contains an enormous amount of dialogue and text. Was there ever concern that players would simply not tolerate that much reading?

Chris Avellone: Oh, hells yes. Not only did I think I would be fired (Brian Fargo walked into my office to deliver an angry lecture about translation and localization costs), but I honestly didn’t know how the game would land with the audience.

Our playtesters certainly thought it was a very wordy game (one of them, Danny, pointed out that “the longest dialogue response is usually the best one” which made me realize my own writing flaws).

So yeah, I guess my first worry was translation costs (which were high), then job stability (we needed another runaway success like Baldur’s Gate, and it became clear Torment wasn’t going to be it as things progressed), then having enough support (we had a small team, and we were effectively the “C” team at Black Isle – we didn’t get much support or funding), and finally, the concern that it was going to “lead zepplin” its way out of the hangar. And to be fair, it didn’t sell great, but the critical reception both surprised me and made me sigh with relief.

That said, Black Isle still tried to punish the team, me specifically, for the project. When it came around to review time (well after the product was released), the studio head tried to cut my raise. What he didn’t realize is that I had such a callus on my soul by that point from developing Torment and Fallout 2 simultaneously – a situation he created that led to 120+ hour weeks, easily, not to mention the toll on my health – I simply said, “no you won’t.” And he didn’t.

When that happened, I probably should have left Interplay, but I had enjoyed working on Torment and Fallout, so I wanted to stay for the chance to do more titles like that – unfortunately, as time wore on, Black Isle reduced its game aesthetic targets more and more – the Icewind Dale series was fun to work on, but it was always intended as a lesser version of Baldur’s Gate that was easier to crank out, so it’s hard to think you’re contributing to the evolution of the genre.

When Baldur’s Gate 3 finally fell apart and it looked like Fallout Van Buren was going down the same road (it did), I turned in my resignation.

Finding the person inside the companion

Retro Replay: Characters such as Morte, Dak’kon, Fall-from-Grace, Annah, and Ignus remain incredibly memorable. When writing companions, what makes a character feel like a person rather than simply another source of quests and dialogue?

Chris Avellone: There are a lot of rules I follow when writing companions, mostly because of the many mistakes I’ve made with them – but one important element to make them feel “human,” is you really have to place yourself in that character’s shoes and empathize with their experience and background.

When you do that, and you start examining what comprises their daily life and challenges in the world where they exist and really dig deep, I think that’s where the personal and bonding elements come out.

Even when writing Ignus, who is to all appearances a pyromaniac monster, he was still written with humanity in mind – even Ignus has a heart and remorse deep down inside, and the player has a chance to open that window and see it during the game, and hopefully see Ignus differently after seeing the path that led him to his current state.

Retro Replay: Is there a particular Planescape: Torment companion or storyline you personally feel closest to?

Chris Avellone: I liked all of them, and felt deeply about them. When wrapping up the project – and you may have felt this when experiencing the ending – it was like saying goodbye to eight good friends and realizing you might never see them again. It actually hurt quite a bit to do their final dialogues, but I’d like to hope some of that emotion bled into the words at the end.

Morte’s teeth and a delighted kidnapping victim

Retro Replay: Was there content planned for Planescape: Torment that you still wish had made it into the finished game?

Chris Avellone: Yeah, two things:

There’s one sequence where Morte gets an upgrade for his teeth (not kidding, this is for real). Basically, you get a set of living, sentient teeth from an NPC you do a quest for, and as soon as the living teeth “spot” Morte, they go quiet and all turn and pointedly “stare” at him in unison in a creepy fashion.

Not long after, they jump him and drill into his jaw (there’s a few nodes where he’s screaming) – it’s a sequence that I loved writing, but it wasn’t able to be implemented in the core game. Also, it doesn’t really hurt Morte, it makes him tougher (the teeth could be shaped into fangs, for example, for added piercing damage so Morte could change his loadout by asking the teeth to shapeshift).

Also, we had plans to do a companion-specific questline for the Modron Cube dungeon where Fall-From-Grace and/or Annah gets kidnapped (the classic “princess is kidnapped” plotline) except, comically enough, Fall-From-Grace is actually very excited to be kidnapped because she’s never been kidnapped before. So she has a few lines where Grace is actually delighted by the whole situation, which sort of throws a wrench into the “villain’s” plans. Jennifer Hale, who voiced Fall-From-Grace, really put the right tone in the lines, too, she nailed it (she usually does, she’s an excellent voice actress).

The reception he had not expected

Retro Replay: The game was critically respected but did not immediately become the commercial phenomenon its later reputation might suggest. Were you surprised by how dramatically its reputation grew over the years?

Chris Avellone: Yes. Again, I thought I was going to get fired over it, and it did turn a modest profit over time, but it wasn’t the runaway success that Baldur’s Gate was. I was very happy with the critical reception, though, which was much better than I had thought it would be.

Icewind Dale, borrowed engines, and Black Isle’s limits

Retro Replay: Icewind Dale placed more emphasis on party creation and combat than Planescape: Torment. Was it refreshing to work on an RPG with such a different emphasis?

Chris Avellone: It was a lot easier to get the game done that way – Icewind Dale was very much about doing a “Diablo”-style version of Baldur’s Gate – that’s how our studio director phrased it when pitching it to us. It was designed to be done quickly and focus more on action than story/characters/content.

The advantages were that it did harness a lot of our talented artists to make some beautiful locations for sure – some locations felt like you were exploring paintings.

Also, we were allowed more “do as you will” design freedom (especially in Icewind Dale 2) because it had to get done so quickly.

For me, it was fun to work on, definitely easier but not in a good way (because there was little to no story), but I do like doing narrative design so Icewind Dale didn’t really have much “push” in that aspect. I do wish we’d kept pushing the boundaries of RPGs and still doing stronger RPG titles like BG and Fallout – which we eventually tried to do with BG3 and Fallout Van Buren, but those two projects ultimately failed. Icewind Dale was more of a “here’s the financial reality of Interplay, churn these out as quickly as possible” – and we did our best to keep everyone afloat (which also failed).

Retro Replay: What did the Infinity Engine allow Black Isle to do particularly well, and what aspects of it were frustrating for designers?

Chris Avellone: Well, it was a working engine, which Black Isle could never seem to do, despite several attempts. Game engines aren’t easy, but for Black Isle, we couldn’t seem to come close on our own.

It’s not that we didn’t have the engineers, it’s just that management and production didn’t seem able to guide a working engine – although a lot of time, money, and developers were invested in trying. I’m not sure as to all the reasons why the efforts seemed to fall apart, but at the end of the day, it was repeatedly clear that we didn’t have the ability to make our own engines, we had to rely on others.

That said, we did have the Fallout engine, but it was a pretty “old” engine that didn’t last long beyond Fallout 2. We did try Lithtech, and then tried again to do our own engine for Baldur’s Gate 3 and Fallout 3, but it was an uphill battle that never really got to the top of the summit.

One studio Black Isle worked with, Snowblind, provided the engine for Dark Alliance 1 and 2… although because Interplay and Black Isle had screwed them over in various ways (this is a lesson on why you treat developers with respect, I guess), we lost the ability to consult with Snowblind on Dark Alliance 2 on their engine and how it worked, so we had a lot of difficulties there getting it up and running – but we eventually did (thanks to Scot Lane and Dave Maldonado leading the charge).

BioWare’s “Infinity engine,” however, for whatever minor issues it had, worked, was solid, was perfect for D&D games, and it was something both Black Isle and BioWare continually iterated on and improved – but the major work was from BioWare, and many of Black Isle’s games relied on it. If not for BioWare, Black Isle’s catalog would have been much smaller for sure, they really saved our asses.

Retro Replay: Black Isle produced several very different RPGs within a relatively short period. Why do you think that studio was able to create so many distinctive games?

Chris Avellone: Distinctiveness came from accident and outside help, not necessarily a plan. Some of our most successful titles were pitched to us by others or were dictated by franchises that Interplay had bought the rights for.

So for example, Fallout 1 wasn’t a Black Isle project, just the Fallout brand got put under Black Isle at some point since it was an RPG and it felt like it belonged in the RPG division. As I understood it, though, the Fallout leads didn’t have to answer to the Black Isle studio head (which I believe was one of the stipulations, but they would know for sure) and had a more direct connection with Fargo.

We did have experimental titles that were either done largely by 3rd parties (Lionheart, Dark Alliance 1) or were done internally (TORN, Stonekeep 2, both of which you may not have heard of), but some of our internal projects didn’t fare well and never saw the light of day – the Planescape Playstation game, for example, had run aground pretty quickly, and we got members from that team when working on Planescape.

TORN, our version of “fantasy Fallout,” had a lot of production and creative difficulties, plus engine difficulties, and that definitely resulted in it being canceled.

Stonekeep 2 was intended to be a premier RPG release, but management and the team spent so much time and money on it that it eventually became untenable. In addition, there were a lot of internal conflicts within Stonekeep 2, just like TORN, to the point where the lead writer, Zeb Cook, finally quit rather than continue to work on it.

With Dark Alliance 2, we had new challenges because we didn’t have a strong connection to Snowblind, so trying to figure out the workings of their engine proved difficult. Snowblind may have been happier to help had original contractual elements been more positive, but I think they were largely done with working with Black Isle after Dark Alliance 1. BioWare departed for much the same reason (more on that in a bit).

Fallout 2 rode the coattails of the Fallout 1 team’s efforts – they’d provided the game engine and the overall story arc, and then after the Fallout leads left Interplay, the rest of the studio was conscripted to finish it (I was pulled off Torment to also work on Fallout 2 because they were so short-handed)… but we never got around to doing a proper version of Fallout 3 for many years – despite my best efforts.

So largely, we lived off the BioWare Infinity engine for most of our successful releases (Icewind Dale series, all 4 titles) and the not-so-successful ones (Torment) as well as the Baldur’s Gate series – but Baldur’s Gate was the real moneymaker, and for good reason.

Unfortunately, one thing that soured the BG relationship and BioWare relationship was Baldur’s Gate: Dark Alliance – in a technically legal but somewhat insulting move, Black Isle decided to leverage the Baldur’s Gate IP into a platform style fighting game, but they didn’t tell BioWare about it until it was too late – and Ray and Greg, the CEOs of BioWare at the time, definitely weren’t happy once they found out. This may have been part of the reason why “Throne of Bhaal” was more of an expansion to BG2 than a standalone game – I think BioWare was done with Black Isle and Interplay in general after that, and they were right to do so: they did much better on their own.

We did attempt to do a Baldur’s Gate 3, but we didn’t have the resources to do it properly, and even so, the franchise was lost to us partway through due to an “accounting error” on Interplay’s part where apparently they hadn’t paid the proper funds to Wizards of the Coast to keep using the BG franchise, so we lost that.

The remnants of that team went on to Fallout Van Buren, but by that point, Black Isle was on its last legs, so that title didn’t see the light of day, either.

Still, I was grateful to have worked there despite all the difficulties. For a first game industry job, I couldn’t have asked for much more.

Star Wars from the other side of the conflict

Retro Replay: When you later worked on Knights of the Old Republic II, what interested you about examining the Star Wars universe from a more philosophical and morally ambiguous perspective?

Chris Avellone: They were questions that naturally popped up during development, and also from digging deep on the humanity angle I mentioned previously with Torment: I tried to imagine what life would be like for the majority of people in the galaxy who were affected by the Jedi-Sith conflict – but that also requires knowing a lot about the Star Wars franchise (in this case, Han Solo’s perspective on Jedi and the Force, as well as Darth Vader’s officers on the Death Star and their crude dismissal of his belief as fiction) and taking that core and expanding on it: Most people in the galaxy, if examined from a real world perspective, don’t fully understand or even believe in the Force, let alone the Jedi and Sith philosophy, yet they suffer the consequences of them, and I thought that was an interesting angle to explore. I think part of the appeal was because it’s so wildly divergent from the audience’s perspective, who are 100% aware the Force, Jedi, and the Sith are real.

Showcasing that difference in perspective also gives a certain “plausibility” to the universe the players find themselves in and gives them a little surprise reminder that not everyone in the universe has the same privileged view of it that they do.

Also, while doing Star Wars research for the title, I was exposed to some of the foundations of the franchise that rattled my cage a bit – as an RPG designer, I tend to get my hackles up on the concept of “predestination,” mostly because it’s important to me that player choice matters and not everyone simply ends up following the same steps along the plot.

So when it was heavily stated in the prequels that people’s futures were plotted out and that the Force itself would seek to establish a balance even through the massive loss of life, this did bother me a great deal (the argument over time is more nuanced than that, but at the time, it did hit me hard). So I channeled those concepts into the game and had characters that took different views on that, and that gave me a lot of narrative fuel to work with.

Retro Replay: Kreia remains one of the most debated characters in Star Wars games. What were you trying to explore through her views of the Force, Jedi, Sith, and personal choice?

Chris Avellone: Kreia is Kreia, and one thing about characters I write is that once you establish certain pillars, they can get away from you and respond in ways you didn’t consider – but those responses are true to the foundations you built those characters on.

So for Kreia, she is someone who has explored both extremes of the Force, has immersed herself in both philosophies (which is important for a broader perspective) and has found them wanting, but she hasn’t found a truth she can grasp onto… until she becomes aware of you, the Exile, and realizes that you may hold that truth she’s been searching for.

As a result, you become her test subject where she is constantly challenging you to defend your perspective (as some of my best college professors did) to not only make you stronger, but hopefully to provide her with the answers that have eluded her. The proof of it is that your character made a powerful choice that she never did – a choice that almost all Jedi and Sith would never do, and she’s both fascinated by it and on a deeper level, afraid of it (she never really lets go of the crutch she says she despises).

Retro Replay: KOTOR II had a famously difficult development schedule. If you had been given substantially more development time, what areas of the game would you most have wanted to expand or change?

Chris Avellone: The ending. Like, all of it. And maybe an extra planet to explore in the middle, but the last area of the game definitely needed more time. Obsidian was pretty famous for accepting contracts with tight time frames even early on, so I wouldn’t lay the fault at LucasArts.

Retro Replay: Do you think the restored-content projects created by fans changed the way people now remember KOTOR II?

Chris Avellone: I hope so. We owe a lot to the modders who made that happen, even though Obsidian management and LucasArts were both very angry that modders had access to that content. Not me. : )

The main menu of Star Wars Knights of the Old Republic II for Windows
Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic II for Windows. Avellone discusses Kreia, the ending he wanted more time to finish, and the work of fan restoration projects.

Returning to Fallout with New Vegas

Retro Replay: Fallout: New Vegas again gave you the opportunity to work in the Fallout universe. How had your approach to RPG writing changed between Fallout 2 and New Vegas?

Chris Avellone: Fallout 2 had a tight schedule, much like Fallout New Vegas, but often, it was developers’ first steps into Fallout, and there’s a lot you can get wrong if you don’t understand the core of the franchise – and honestly, most of the people who knew the core of the franchise had resigned shortly before we were shanghaied to work on it. However, in the years following Fallout 2, I continued to do research and try to understand the franchise more, especially since I wasn’t under the gun, and so when New Vegas came around, I think I (and other developers) were in a much better place to understand what Fallout was about and bring that world to life. It’s not Mad Max, it’s not Wasteland, it’s not a bunch of different apocalyptic franchises – it has its own identity, and you have to study it in depth to make sure you’re representing it properly – I don’t think Fallout 2 did, but I think New Vegas did a much better job.

As an example, for Old World Blues, one of the mandates for that DLC was all the humor had to be in-universe (and any inside jokes or 4th Wall breaches were relegated to Wild Wasteland). Abiding by that rule made the game feel much more “Fallout” and made the players feel more immersed in the game world. (One mistake junior developers can make is making repeated inside jokes or parodies/nods to other games or media – I’ve certainly been guilty of it, but Fallout 2 cured me of it.)

Retro Replay: New Vegas is often praised for factions that have understandable motives even when the player strongly disagrees with them. How do you create ideological conflict without turning one side into an obvious caricature?

Chris Avellone: Well, unfortunately, we did turn one faction into “evil caricature” (Caesar’s Legion).

Generally, in a game where faction choice is important, you want factions that people actually would want to join and at least have some noble/higher goal even if “evil,” but the Legion failed that test.

NCR was more nuanced in a good way, though, but because so much of the content was focused around NCR, it made people gravitate toward that faction more.

Retro Replay: You wrote characters such as Ulysses and worked extensively on the New Vegas DLC. How did the DLC format allow you to explore ideas differently from the main game?

Chris Avellone: DLCs are much less riskier experiences, so there’s more freedom to play around with ideas. So if we want to try Survival Horror, or wacky sci-fi insanity, or a Damnation Alley kind of scenario, we can, and it won’t hurt the main game’s reception or plot (but hopefully should complement it).

Also, we had a lot less eyes on the DLCs than on New Vegas itself, so that freed our hands quite a bit to try out new things – there were some exceptions, of course, as there were things Bethesda had strong feelings about (Power Armor, Enclave presence), so we couldn’t explore everything, but they did give us quite a bit of freedom.

The player character seated on a bench overlooking a lake in Fallout New Vegas for Windows
A pause beside the water in Fallout: New Vegas for Windows. Avellone contrasts the main game’s development with the freedom to try different tones in its DLC.

Leaving room for the player

Retro Replay: Across Planescape: Torment, KOTOR II, and New Vegas, your work often asks players to examine their own assumptions rather than simply choose between two obvious moral options. Is that something you deliberately seek out when writing?

Chris Avellone: Yes. Games are interactive, and if there’s only one “right” answer to a player’s experience, I think that’s very limiting – and worse, it can come across as preaching vs. being a gamemaster and allowing players to explore questions rather than answering them for the player – for me, that’s a big part of what role-playing is all about.

This was something I tried to explain with reactivity and system/narrative design for Dying Light 2. In vision meetings, they kept returning to “one right answer for all players” and focusing on a linear experience with a single moral message, which isn’t reactive and also isn’t very welcoming of the player’s experience.

From my viewpoint, it’s also not very interesting to develop a plot that way, it’s like the player’s actions and choices don’t really have any freedom – and if you’re on rails, it diminishes the player experience into a series of steps everyone follows.

Retro Replay: Are there any characters, quests, or games from your career that you think are misunderstood or deserve another look from players?

Chris Avellone: I don’t want to dictate the correct interpretation of a story or character any more than I want to dictate a moral decision. Players take away what they want, and I think trying to explain author intention is pretty useless and sometimes disappointing to people.

As an example, several people have contacted me over the years asking if Torment represented views of this particular religion or philosophy, and it’s always been my shame to give the correct answer: It all came from the world itself, and just thinking deeply about what life would be like if you really did exist there. That’s it. No higher thought, no real world religion or philosophy, just focusing on the world itself and what life would be like for people living in it.

What comes next

Retro Replay: Finally, what are you working on these days, and are there any current projects, books, games, websites, or social media pages you would like me to mention or link to when the interview is published?

Chris Avellone: Yeah, I’m working on quite a few projects now, although I can’t talk about them for various reasons – and sometimes, it’s better if the actual project directors are the ones to speak about them (it’ll be apparent why when it happens).

That said, I’m working on a very cool dark-themed RPG with Republic Games which I’m very excited about. I’m also helping shape the narrative and lore for a project from Steel Strix that I’m also very excited to share when we can – so stay tuned. (If curious, you can subscribe to updates here: https://steelstrixstudio.com/ )

Thank you, Chris

Our thanks to Chris Avellone for taking the time to answer all 25 questions, sharing these stories, and explaining the choices behind the characters and games. We appreciate the care he put into the conversation.

About

David (dmb062082) Becker. is a writer with a passion for retro gaming, Christianity, disaster preparedness, America’s military and law enforcement, and the occasional dose of slapstick absurdity masquerading as satire. He enjoys digging into forgotten stories, preserving various elements of history, and creating content that is informative, entertaining, and full of personality.

Check Also

Chris Beatrice interview cover with his portrait and Caesar II, Caesar III and Pharaoh screenshots

Chris Beatrice Interview: Impressions Games, Caesar, and the Art of Building Living Cities

Chris Beatrice recalls Impressions Games, the art behind Caesar and Pharaoh, studio life, and the enduring appeal of classic city builders.

One comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Spam has been overwhelming. To help us approve your comment, sign up and introduce yourself in the Introductions forum so we know you’re not a bot.